4 ms·
First Amendment doesn’t apply on YouTube; judges reject PragerU lawsuit
- ddingus 7y agoI think this is fair. It is also a supporting argument for a public forum, square, something where the people can gather and benefit from the First Amendment.
- user53836 7y agoSo, because we don't have a forum owned by a state actor, by law, we don't have free speech on internet? Is that the conclusion?
- krapp 7y agoThe First Amendment doesn't define free speech. The First Amendment explicitly and exclusively prohibits Congress, and only Congress, from restricting free speech. Free speech exists apart from the First Amendment. Youtube is not Congress, therefore the First Amendment does not prohibit Youtube from restricting free speech. There is no Constitutional law that I am aware of that requires all private entities, platforms and persons to accept all forms of speech, or that requires publishers to publish all forms of speech, nor is there a common, legally accepted definition of free speech which assumes the same. Private platforms and entities have always been able to restrict free speech, and continue to be able to do so. The nature of free speech, in this regard, either in society or on the internet, has not changed. Whoever runs the site, the newspaper, the tavern or town square gets to make the rules, that's always been the case. That's the conclusion. Although I have no doubt the Orwellian slippery slope arguments are getting greased up I write this.
- user8313 7y ago> therefore the First Amendment does not prohibit Youtube from restricting free speech. If YouTube can restrict free speech, Google Groups can restrict free speech. And Facebook can restrict free speech. And WhatsApp, Messenger, Instagram, Twitter, Reddit, Slack, HN etc. etc. etc.
- krapp 7y agoYes. They're private companies offering a service under their own terms which the consumer can take or leave, of course they can do that. The salient point however is that the First Amendment was never intended to apply to private enterprise.
- ddingus 7y agoYes. The Internet is a peer system. Your speech is carried by others who find doing that worth doing somehow. This has always been true.
- quotemstr 7y agoWe impose restrictions on corporations in the name of the public interest all the time. It is completely reasonable to require that a company that has a de facto monopoly on personal video distribution uphold the principle of free speech. It's a virtual town square, and if you don't force its operator to allow free speech, the people as a whole don't get to have free speech.
- krapp 7y ago>We impose restrictions on corporations in the name of the public interest all the time. It is completely reasonable to require that a company that has a de facto monopoly on personal video distribution uphold the principle of free speech. Yes, but the First Amendment doesn't apply to corporations, and so it isn't relevant to any argument about restricting the speech of corporations or private citizens, or about the ability of the public, states or private companies to do so. Also, these companies don't have de facto monopolies on anything. Facebook et al. are not the modern day equivalents of Ma Bell or J.P Morgan. They don't control any scarce resources, and aren't capable of preventing anyone from publishing speech outside of their platforms, nor can they prevent the existence of other competing platforms, nor is it more difficult, time consuming or costly to reach the URL of a Twitter post or Facebook page than that of any other service or even a personal page. Information propagated perfectly well across the web prior to the existence of FAANG, and their existence and relative popularity doesn't render the rest of the web or its capabilities obsolete. Free speech doesn't require them, and their actions don't pose an existential threat to it. Also, what is the "principle of free speech," exactly? Because again... free speech isn't defined by the First Amendment, so if you want to put the force of the government and its monopoly on violence behind taking over private companies, declaring them "public" and forcing them comply with upholding it, please specify exactly what this principle is and what legal doctrine supports it. Bearing in mind that, of course, speech in public spaces is regulated as well, so you're going to have to explain why Facebook should be forced to allow speech that might not be allowed in actual public squares.
- a3n 7y agoYouTube is not preventing anyone's free speech. Everyone, including the plaintiffs, are free to say anything they want, regardless of any YouTube policy. YouTube is merely not obligated to provide a platform for everyone. People can go elsewhere and say exactly what they would have said on YouTube.