4 ms·
How is an emptor supposed to caveat if the so-called review system is systemically dishonest? Caveat emptor doesn't work, because Amazon has no incentive to im
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
How is an emptor supposed to caveat if the so-called review system is systemically dishonest?
Caveat emptor doesn't work, because Amazon has no incentive to improve review or product quality.
Bezos is rewarded whenever an item is sold. Most items won't be returned unless grossly faulty or misdescribed. Accurate reviews and more selective product filtering would decrease his earnings - a strong negative incentive, if you're someone like Bezos.
With current legislation, the only thing that might improve the situation for buyers is aggressive competition. As a de facto monopoly, Amazon doesn't need to worry about that.
Putting it crudely, e-commerce automates and amplifies scamming and dishonesty. There's limited accountability for sellers and virtually no accountability for the owner of the marketplace.
In the non-virtual world there are trading standards and other consumer protection mechanisms. They're not infallible, but they do at least exist.
The online equivalent would be some kind of blanket consumer-good-faith system which punished fake news, manipulated reviews, and substandard products.
Good luck getting that written and passed as coherent legislation with adequate enforcement.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoAmazon isn't a de-facto monopoly by any reasonable definition. Most big box retailers have online shopping, and Walmart even offers the same delivery speeds in many areas.
- jerf 7y agoOne of the biggest long term risks for Amazon's retail business is that they don't really have a moat. They can beat people logistically, but eventually, other companies will catch up, and there's probably a diminishing returns effect on money poured into that. They have Amazon Prime, which was probably created to try to be a moat, but I think they've had more difficulty making that a moat over the long term than they may have initially hoped. Why would I pay for faster shipping if Wal-Mart pretty much offers it by default? Tacking on a lot of mediocre streaming services is a weird way to add value to that. (AWS has a lock-in moat. Once you're in, you will find it harder and harder to leave over time. True of all the clouds, but that plays in favor of the biggest which at the moment AWS is.) If you look, you can kinda see a lot of flailing on Amazon's part over the past several years trying to figure out how to build a moat around their retail in a lot of ways; Amazon Basics, various games around Prime, trying to convince people to buy retail through Alexa which is hard-coded to Amazon, of course, etc. Almost everything the retail side is doing amounts to that in the end.
- blackrock 7y agoI don’t trust Amazon to buy important things. Like expensive electronics. Or things where the risk of counterfeits are too high. I’d rather buy it from Target, and pay more, because I can get access to reliable customer support.
- omgwtfbyobbq 7y agoPuffery is endemic in just about every other marketplace I'm aware of, and I imagine emptors would caveat in a similar fashion.