52 ms·
Building enough reactors is impossible in the time we have left. Especially if you want to go for unproven tech that is just now entering trials.
by adrianN 7y ago
Building enough reactors is impossible in the time we have left. Especially if you want to go for unproven tech that is just now entering trials.
- Beltiras 7y agoThorcon aims to transform a shipyard into a factory for these things. Their plan is to mass-produce 250MW reactors.
- adrianN 7y agoThe world need on the order of 100k 250MW (thermal) reactors to replace today's energy consumption. How many are they planning to produce per year.
- spiderfarmer 7y agoIf it only delivers .5% of the worlds energy consumption it's still an enormous (and welcome) feat.
- adrianN 7y agoYeah, sure. Build as much nuclear as you can reasonably integrate into a grid that primarily runs on renewables. But don't trust in Thorium to somehow fix our problem.
- Beltiras 7y agoThorcon is using 20% enriched U-235. Their design can accomodate the Thorium fuel cycle in the future but for now it's mostly repurposed nuclear wastes.
- Beltiras 7y agoI don't remember the figures. There are plenty of videos on Youtube with presentations from the Thorcon team. I think it's 250MW electric, 500MW thermal that the design delivers.
- ryanmercer 7y agoThere are more than 60,000 power plants in the world, the bulk of which are fossil fuels. Replacing them, with a continually growing power demand as newly middle-class individuals begin to consume more, is effectively impossible without radical change on a planetary level. Never mind the concrete production for all of the new plants alone would release a staggering amount of CO2. Even if someone figured out fusion this afternoon, and could start construction of one plant on each continent (sans Antarctica) this year, with the plants going online late next year, we'd still need radical change to hold us over for (likely) the couple of few decades it would take to build enough of the facilities. Also consider ICE vehicles are still something like 90% of the annual sales in the world too. If you outlawed the production of ICE vehicles in every country in the world today, in 30 years you'd still have many millions of those vehicles on the road being used. Concrete, plastics, livestock... there are many facets to this problem.
- Beltiras 7y agoAbsolutely. We need all angles at the problem to find a solution. We also need to mitigate the damage we know can't be prevented. Shipping is 12% of CO2 emissions. It's a little bit harder to nail down (found a staggering figure of 46% of all emissions) how much coal contributes but together with shipping they are more than half of all emissions. If you are tackling a hard problem and a solution to half of it is on your doorstep, please answer the bell.
- incangold 7y agoIs this calculation as simple as: it takes order of 10 years to build a reactor using existing tech, and we don’t have that long left?
- adrianN 7y agoWith an added "and that is at the current buildout rate, which basically keeps every qualified person busy". 10x-ing the rate at which we build reactors would require training more personnel and (depending on the type of reactor you want to build) 10x-ing things like the huge machines we need to forge pressure vessels.
- imtringued 7y agoThe problem is that we will need thousands of reactors. 10 years for a single one won't cut it.
- Beltiras 7y agoThorcon means to retrofit shipyards to mass produce the reactors and service as refueling stations.
- thu2111 7y agoThat can't be a simple calculation given the tremendous disagreement and controversy over how much time is "left" (until what?)
- ppf 7y agoThe US uses 4 trillion kWh per year. Assuming 3MW wind turbines at 30% capacity factor, you'll need around 3.5 billion wind turbines. They take around 23 million kWh to manufacture (each), so you'll need to find the energy for that. However, that's not really enough, as the entire economy needs to be carbon-neutral. Electricity usage accounts for about 40% of the total US energy usage, so you'll actually need to multiply everything by 2.5. Seriously, I understand the "we only have 10 years to do anything" line, but the math is so far from adding up, it completely defeats the point. The only realistic way to achieve the 10 year goal is to radically cut energy usage.
- philipkglass 7y agoA 3 MW wind turbine producing at 30% capacity factor generates 3000 * 0.3 * 24 * 365 = 7,884,000 kWh per year. 4 trillion kWh annually would require (4 * 10^12) / 7884000 = 507,357 turbines Not 3.5 billion.
- ppf 7y agoFair point - I did the calc all at once and screwed up my parentheses. My point still stands. How realistic is it to manufacture 500,000 x2.5 = 1.25 million wind turbines, needing 27 trillion kWh to do so, in 10 years?
- philipkglass 7y agoThat's not going to happen. Nor are thousands of nuclear reactors going to be built in 10 years. Nor is the US going to cut its primary energy use by 60% in 10 years. Nor is the combination of all-of-the-above going to make the US carbon neutral in 10 years. Nor should we give up on continued incremental progress after another 10 years have passed without fully solving the problem. It's always possible to make climate change even worse by burning more fossil fuels. Regardless of whatever dangerous threshold of emissions has passed in 10 years, it doesn't make sense to resign ourselves to burning the rest of the fossil fuels. I'm afraid that the hardline "we need to have solved this emissions problem in 1X years" rhetoric is counterproductive. It asks too much and will prompt fatalism and/or cynicism when the deadline has passed, there are still billions of living people who need to make decisions affecting the future, and the problem still isn't "done with."