4 ms·
Interesting. I can see how it would be appealing to long-time alcoholics (the "endless optimism" would get pretty sickening). Not entirely sure what my stance
by Groxx 16y ago
Interesting. I can see how it would be appealing to long-time alcoholics (the "endless optimism" would get pretty sickening).
Not entirely sure what my stance is on it, though - it's essentially long-term non-profit euthanasia. It's what they want, but it's also what they want because they're addicted and it's re-wired their brain so drastically they'll do just about anything to keep feeding it.
On the flip side, rehabilitating someone who doesn't want to be rehabilitated to some degree is essentially throwing enormous sums of money down the drain, and drags that time of their life far lower than it was before. Instead, this offers them companionship and fewer insults (and keeps them in line) until they die, and that seems to be what many people want - what they have for shorter instead of something else which may or may not be better for longer.
If nothing else, it has jogged my thinker; I'll probably debate with myself for a while on this :)
- jackolas 16y agoI want to know if someone actually stops drinking being in there. I mean if they viscerally feel death and don't actually wish it...
- Groxx 16y agoThat'd be an interesting thing to check out. They do get to see first-hand what it's doing to others around them, over a period of time. It'd be a unique incentive to quit.
- alexandros 16y agoAlso, when the constant pressure is taken off and their basic needs are taken care of, maybe some of them can reflect and take a less forced decision to quit. But maybe I'm underestimating alcohol's hold.
- sophacles 16y agoI seem to recall a story about this place, or a similar one, where a couple residents decided to sober up after "living the dream" (free booze for life!) and still not finding happiness. Many more tho drank themselves to death there.
- joe_the_user 16y agoEven as something of a liberal, this makes me feel conflicted. It doesn't quite feel like harm reduction - just cost-reduction for the agencies. It's very bleak.
- Groxx 16y agoBut if you can't really reduce the harm (or not much), but you can significantly reduce the cost... is bleak bad? America is on a huge "everyone should be happy" kick - smile all the time, buck up and be cheerful, if you're not happy take this pill - but that has its own problems, and masks problems like these people are having, making them worse. It also trivializes pain / unhappiness - everyone can have it! Why don't you? Try this pill, go to a meeting, look everyone can do it! - and given the amount of depression occurring can it even be said to be working? For some, sure - there are outliers in any system of people.. There's also that it can cause things to get even worse - if everyone really can / should be happy, and I can't, clearly something's wrong with me. You'll find a lot of depressed people in that line of thinking, and it crops up in suicides pretty often too. Not really disagreeing, just debating with myself / you / the Internets.
- jacques_chester 16y agoOh hey, someone who mocks the use of antidepressants. I suffer from congenital depression. Zoloft helps me to be a functioning, productive member of society. It has prevented many deaths from suicide. People like you prevent people from seeking help because they buy into the "just harden up" bullshit. Should people with diabetes just kick the insulin habit? Please.
- Groxx 16y agoWhere the hell are you getting that from? Read what's written, not what you want to see. I said America is on a happy kick, not that such drugs don't work or that they're unnecessary. There's an obsession with appearing happy that hides and / or causes a lot of problems, including depression.
- iamelgringo 16y agolong-term non-profit euthanasia Not really. Euthanising long-term alcoholics would mean taking a syringe full of paralytics, potassium, versed and morphine and pushing as a lethal injection. Hospice is realizing they are dying from their disease and providing for them while the disease runs its course.
- Groxx 16y agoIf someone is dying from a disease you have cures for (it's simple, but hard: stop drinking), but they're not taking them, so you instead support that disease, how far from euthanasia is that really? It's absolutely hospice care in the approach, but they are literally helping them die more quickly. More happily, but more quickly. And euthanasia has nothing to do with absolute speed, only relative; a less-painful death at the expense of a shorter life. It's a trade-off everyone makes, but at what point does it switch from normal life / hospice care to occurring "too early"?
- iamelgringo 16y agoIf someone is dying from a disease you have cures for (it's simple, but hard: stop drinking), but they're not taking them, so you instead support that disease, how far from euthanasia is that really? The difference is that people have the right to choose what treatment they take or don't take. Forcing a treatment on someone (antibiotics, chemotherapy, sewing a laceration) when they don't want it is legally called medical battery, and it's against the law. This is particularly poignant in the case of diseases like alcoholism or drug addiction. I often have conversations with alcoholics along the lines of "Your alcohol level was 5 times the legal limit. If you keep drinking at this level, in a couple of years, your liver will be shot, and you're going to die of liver failure. Liver failure is one of the worst ways to die, because you die looking like a swollen yellow gourd." Most don't care, and keep on drinking. Same thing with smoking. I smoked for 10 years while I was a Critical Care nurse. It was my choice and my addiction. It took trying to quit 15 times before I did it successfully. Some people aren't able to quit, or don't want to quit, and it kills them. Should we deny people with lung cancer hospice because their disease was self inflicted? Should we deny people with heart disease hospice because they didn't manage their cholesterol properly? Should we deny people with type 2 diabetes hospice because they didn't manage their diet appropriately, exercise or lose weight?
- barefoot 16y agoIt seems like a very pragmatic solution for now. I think it could be taken a step further by providing an alternative to going out onto the street to try to get alcohol in various forms (including mouthwash). While I'm certainly no expert on psychology, my experience has shown me that sometimes the best way to get some tiny bit of purchase on a group of people is to offer a minimally reasonable alternative. For example, if scrapers are constantly inundating your website one solution is to publically offer an API. Obtaining the data is easier through the API and reduces the automated hits to the human readable part of your website. You can require API users uniquely identify themselves and you are then able to throttle and better track how your data is dispensed. Following this line of thinking: Why not put in a alcohol vending machine that dispenses variable percentage alcohol based on BAC of the user and frequency of use? It could also adjust the alcohol content up or down based on other factors, like recent civil service or run-ins with the police. I could think of hundreds of ways this could be improved. Since you are likely getting BAC readings on a regular basis you have a measure of how successful your dispensing profile is. With enough machines you could even split test different percentages, etc... If the machine is not getting any use at first the alcohol level could be stepped up.