3 ms·
Windows 10 is a total catastrophe for business and private use. It established ads and spying as normal for an OS, it removed abilities to administrate the OS
by raxxorrax 7y ago
Windows 10 is a total catastrophe for business and private use.
It established ads and spying as normal for an OS, it removed abilities to administrate the OS in a meaningful way and mostly ignored users in favor of nudging people to their products. Products that I would declare to be mostly in beta phase. The bi-annual untargeted channel version couldn't sort desktop symbols without bugs if you had multiple monitors attached till a few month ago.
And before anyone mentions that "normal people" like it and it is just the icky nerds that have reservations: Not in my experience. They hate MS spying on them too. It is just that there is often a lack of an alternative if they are caught up in the ecosystem.
I wonder how people even manage if they don't have some friends and family to help them get rid of the bad stuff.
There are underlying improvements, but what use is a safer system if the malware comes preinstalled.
- dgellow 7y ago> it removed abilities to administrate the OS in a meaningful way What do you mean by that? I moved last year from macOS to Windows 10 for my personal machine, and I don't see what administrative features I could be missing.
- raxxorrax 7y agoFor example pretty much everything regarding update settings. You get mandatory diagnostic information in exchange. Really bad deal.
- dgellow 7y agoFor updates, I guess you mean the fact that you cannot block them completely. Or do you mean something else? So that would be the only difference. For the vast majority of people, how does that have an impact? People get their security updates that they otherwise don’t install. Seems to be an ok-ish trade off IMHO. My main frustration is the automatic reboot, but I’ve seen this behavior since at least windows 7.
- m_fayer 7y agoFor anyone looking at my HN history, apologies for being a broken record. For the elderly variety of normal people this is a disaster: All the behind-the-scenes UX and setting flipping, the forced installs, and the performance dips that comes with all this means that low-confidence users feel like they're working on quicksand. The experience becomes unpredictable and scary and the iPad gets more and more use and the PC gathers dust. I don't get why this all is worth the cost of squandering the good will MS has built up elsewhere.
- ubermonkey 7y agoTo be fair, the shift-to-iPad happens even when the desktop isn't awful. My mother now only touches her Macbook Air if she needs to use her bookkeeping software, or transfer embroidery files to a USB drive to use with her sewing machine. She's much happier being able to do everything else on her iPad -- plus, she can take it with her more easily, and the battery life is ridiculous.
- reaperducer 7y agoPerhaps for the next holiday, you can buy her an adapter so she can plug her USB drive into her iPad, and remove one more reason to device shift to her computer.
- ubermonkey 7y agoAlas, the embroidery world still ships things on CD-ROM.
- bregma 7y ago> For the elderly variety of normal people this is a disaster that's pretty wretchedly ageist. I know people up and down the age spectrum for whom this is an identical unmitigated disaster with the same effects. I also know a lot of greybeards who will just go in to some "registry" thing and rip out the cancer at its source.
- 7y ago
- zzzcpan 7y ago> Windows 10 is a total catastrophe for business and private use. There is just no real competition, so business and private users don't have a say in it anyway. MacOS requires different hardware and only has to be a little bit better to compete with Windows, so it's progressively getting worse as well. Linux distros lack in other areas and are also heavily corporate driven and low quality, sure if you invest time in it you won't be able to tolerate Windows and MacOS, but you might need a lot of time, as usefulness and freedom of Linux only really exists for programmers. There is also pressure from iOS and Android, people do not care as much about desktop OSes, they live within their phones, and forgive desktop OSes a lot more crap because of that. On the other hand maybe someone will see an opportunity for a high quality desktop Linux distro that addresses many problems of other OSes now that other OSes are getting so much worse.
- Silhouette 7y agoThere is just no real competition And we have a winner! We have voluntarily allowed much of our society to become dependent on IT facilities where a key element was provided by a de facto monopoly. We are now learning a hard lesson in why that is a bad idea. The geeks among us may flee to Linux. The quirky or curious might try Apple (though they don't exactly have a stellar reputation for looking after their desktop OS either in recent years). But for "normal" people, if you buy a new PC today, you get Windows 10 and all the negative baggage that comes with it, and that's just how it is. I have been convinced for some time that statutory regulation with real teeth is now the only way to protect normal people from the nasty, greedy parts of the tech industry. I suspect the most plausible alternative -- and that doesn't mean actually plausible, just less wishful thinking than anything else -- is for popular sentiment to turn sharply against these practices and make it a liability for Microsoft to continue down its current path. We've seen a couple of issues recently in my area that went from the general population being ignorant or ambivalent about issues that really should concern them to quite suddenly becoming much better informed and demanding action. However, it usually requires some very obvious catalyst for people to rally behind. It's not hard to imagine what that could be in this sort of scenario: a massive data leak resulting in huge inconvenience for lots of people, a bad Windows update bricking millions of laptops, a security vulnerability in phones or cars that leads to widespread damage and real people getting hurt or worse. It's sad that I suspect it would take such a damaging event to really wake people up to what's happening, though.
- agota 7y ago>And before anyone mentions that "normal people" like it and it is just the icky nerds that have reservations I'm one of the "normal people". I absolutely hate Windows 10 . I used it for a few years because switching to Linux seemed overwhelming. I have finally ditched Windows 10 for Elementary OS, it's just so much better.