5 ms·
I once took a call with an ex-NSA guy who was a CEO selling email security software- your MX would point to them, they'd scan your incoming email for exploits,
by dekhn 7y ago
I once took a call with an ex-NSA guy who was a CEO selling email security software- your MX would point to them, they'd scan your incoming email for exploits, then deliver it on to you. When I spoke to the guy, I expressed my concern, having working for a large multinational corporate whose fiber optic lines were tapped by UK intelligence to avoid NSA laws against spying on americans, that if I couldn't inspect his software, I couldn't feel confident of the security and integrity of the scanning system.
I said, in good faith, that I would consider his product if I could inspect the running system and the code.
He said several things:
1) the NSA never did anything illegal
2) the software was too large to audit
3) it was an insult to his employment in the NSA that I was even asking these questions.
Then he hung up.
- bognition 7y agoI bet I can guess who this is
- paulddraper 7y ago> the software was too large to audit That part's probably true. Try to audit something like OpenSSL.
- rileymat2 7y agoOpen ssl has be audited and fips validated for some versions
- Godel_unicode 7y agoYou might be interested in this evidence of the incompleteness of FIPS validation as a talisman of security. Edit: more importantly, the FIPS version of OpenSSL was vulnerable to HeartBleed. https://www.engadget.com/2019/06/13/yubico-recalls-government-grade-security-keys-due-to-bug/ https://www.engadget.com/2019/06/13/yubico-recalls-governmen...
- dependenttypes 7y agoI am pretty sure that the fips validated versions could not even compile.
- justanotherc 7y agoThat's up to the auditor to decide, not the auditee.
- dekhn 7y agoAUditing is a negotiation between the auditor and the auditee. The auditor rarely gets to dictate absolute terms (and in my experience, will often listen to well-reasoned and prepared arguments and plans from auditees).
- JoeSmithson 7y ago> whose fiber optic lines were tapped by UK intelligence to avoid NSA laws against spying on americans Who did you work for? This appears to be a 180deg misunderstanding of the 5 Eyes agreement. GCHQ is not allowed to spy on Americans.
- dekhn 7y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2013/10/31/technology/nsa-is-mining-google-and-yahoo-abroad.html https://www.nytimes.com/2013/10/31/technology/nsa-is-mining-... "In partnership with the British agency known as Government Communications Headquarters, or GCHQ, the N.S.A. has apparently taken advantage of the vast amounts of data stored in and traveling among global data centers, which run all modern online computing, according to a report Wednesday by The Washington Post. N.S.A. collection activities abroad face fewer legal restrictions and less oversight than its actions in the United States." Note there's a fair amount of speculation on the specific details of how and what data is collected and shared.
- JoeSmithson 7y agoThis source doesn't remotely support what you said, in fact it explicitly contradicts it; > "pushed back against the notion that it was collecting abroad to “get around” legal limits imposed by domestic surveillance laws"
- hobs 7y agoThere's been public claims about it, and honestly thinking that they wouldnt do it once they have the power to seems naive? https://www.zdnet.com/article/thatcher-ordered-echelon-surveillance-when-pm/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/thatcher-ordered-echelon-surve... > Ex-spy Mike Frost told the CBS 60 Minutes programme that Thatcher had ordered surveillance on two cabinet colleagues according to excerpts released on Thursday. The allegation comes in the same week that a European Parliament report said Echelon, a surveillance system run by the United States, Canada, Britain, Australia and New Zealand, was used for industrial espionage.
- 7y ago
- m463 7y agoObviously he fired you as a customer. This is how the misspellings in Nigerian Prince emails market to the "right" customers.
- godelski 7y ago> 1) the NSA never did anything illegal Okay... but even if it was legal that doesn't mean what they did is "right". There's a big difference.
- solipsism 7y agoYeah, one is objective, the other is so subjective it depends not only who you ask but when and how you ask it.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoNeither is objective. There's no pretense of objectivity in the legal system. This is why you see people say things like "we'll find out if this was legal when they rule on the case".
- dekhn 7y agoThe difference is that I knew he wasn't on the level when he said it, because the NSA has been sued and it's come out they've done things that were illegal, as found by a court of law, in public. That's just one example that we know of.
- meddlepal 7y agoPlease define "right"
- PavlovsCat 7y agoSo you can distract from what they said being correct regardless of the definition of "right" they or you may have in mind?
- almost_usual 7y agothe precursor to law
- miles 7y agoOr perhaps the precursor to “just” law. Unjust laws abound.
- sdinsn 7y agoIt is just plain rude to apply his previous employer's actions, who employ over 30k people, solely on him.
- mhluongo 7y agoHe's the one asking for your data, trust, and money. A little scrutiny is warranted.
- sdinsn 7y agoThat applies to every B2B company pretty much. Did he also ask other companies for access to their code?
- thundergolfer 7y agoWho said anything about “solely”? It’s entirely reasonable to have the concerns OP had.
- dekhn 7y agoSince I was effectively the CTO for a startup that cared about the security of its messaging, I think I made a reasoned judgement about the nature of the security of their product, offered a way that he could help increase my confidence that he wasn't just sending a copy of my unecrypted email (the email has to be unencrypted for their scanner to work) off wherever. I don't really find that rude. A cloud customer certainly can go to a cloud provider, say "you know, it's possible you have rogue internal actors, I've read articles that said you've fired SREs before who snooped on user data, can I see your audits that show you deal with insider risk properly?"
- sdinsn 7y agoI encourage you to go to cloud providers and ask to see their code. They will laugh in your face.
- CWuestefeld 7y agoIf the NSA guy is selling himself based on his past experience, then he himself is the one dragging those issues into the conversation.
- HashThis 7y agoAll of your emails and text messages have been saved on NSA server harddisks, without a warrent. You are asking the right questions.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sonotathrowaway 7y agoThe NSA would never do anything illegal; if you have a problem with highly misleading and unethical actions being undertaken with flimsy pretenses established by classified memos citing dubious legal justification- then that’s obviously your problem, not theirs. Also, didn’t the director of the NSA perjure himself when he lied under oath during his sworn testimony before SSCI? No, sorry, he actually gave the “least untruthful answer” and then changed his answer when contradictory facts became public. I would have called that illegal but obviously the NSA has a legal theory and justification as to when they need to provide “untruthful” “facts” to the institutions exercising oversight.
- friendlybus 7y agoIs there no more subtle way of turning down a customer, as an ex-spook? He seemed to imply more than he needed to for someone trained.
- fulldecent2 7y ago-5 insightful. This post could turn into +5 informative if names and contact details were added for this unidentified "ex-NSA guy" and the "security software." As-is, this is post is becoming popular because people are replying with random experiences and hate they have for NSA and insecure systems. But instead it could be helpful by damaging the reputation of a specific person that is peddling insecure systems. This is why I browse with -5 insightful.
- JohnFen 7y ago> 1) the NSA never did anything illegal This is simply not true.