4 ms·
The title isn't supported by the underlying data. The key chart in the Tweet thread is this: https://twitter.com/oren_cass/status/1230505794686373888/photo/1 ht
by rayiner 7y ago
The title isn't supported by the underlying data. The key chart in the Tweet thread is this: https://twitter.com/oren_cass/status/1230505794686373888/photo/1 https://twitter.com/oren_cass/status/1230505794686373888/pho...
This looks at "major household expenditures" versus "median male income." Right off the bat, that should be a red flag--why are we looking at just male income? The percentage of women working since 1985 has only increased a little bit. But women's wages have gone up 50% adjusted for inflation.
Of course, when women have been bringing more money into the family, people will spend more. For example, the chart shows expenditure on housing increasing. But the average American house today has twice as much square footage per person than in 1985: https://azgolfhomes.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/American-Enterprise-Institute-Housing-Data.jpg https://azgolfhomes.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/American-.... Expenditures on housing are increasing--but the number of vehicles per household has also gone up since 1985. The cost of college has gone up, but the percentage of people attending college has also doubled in that time frame. Colleges, moreover, are far more luxurious than in 1985. (The community college where my mother in law works now has far nicer facilities than Georgia Tech did when I attended just 15 years ago.) College itself has become something of a luxury consumption good--with large numbers of young people attending, drinking and having fun for four years, but getting degrees of questionable utility.
There are a lot of sound bites (and Twitter-level analysis) on this subject, but it's actually extremely hard to figure out how to precisely measure changes in standard of living over time. For example, even just looking at the "median" is misleading. In 1990, when I came to America, the percentage of foreign-born people was 7%. Today it's double that. Even in an economy that provides tremendous upwards mobility for immigrants, doubling the share of the immigrant population is going to make the median income seem lower. The median household is also much smaller than in 1985, and less likely to be comprised of married couples. Since 1985, the percentage of people 18-34 living with a spouse has decreased by 2/3. (That observation is particularly significant because the percentage of women participating in the workforce hasn't changed significantly since then.)
Accounting for these differences is important. When people think of the "median" they think they're comparing like with like. "Two-income middle class American-born family with two kids in 1985 versus 2015." They don't think you're comparing a married young couple from 1985, where both spouses work and share household expenses, to unmarried individuals maintaining two separate households in 2015. But unless you account for changing demographics, that's exactly what you're doing.
- kelnos 7y agoI wish this comment of yours was higher up-thread. I started writing a rebuttal, but then realized my rebuttal was turning into the same argument you're making. More income just increases consumption. People feel they need to "keep up with the Joneses". If everyone in your neighborhood is a two-income household, and yours is too, you're not going to spend like you're a one-income household. If anything, the key chart in the thread might suggest the opposite: that people are actually better off, or at least basically the same. If we account for a wage gap and assume two-income households (heterosexual households... yes, this is all very hand-wavy), then those four categories of things "only" cost 26.5 weeks of a two-income salary. And if the people buying all this stuff are getting more than they would have (maybe not twice as much, but at least more) in 1985, then perhaps this is ok. The only thing that gives me pause is the increasing costs of healthcare, and perhaps college. I really don't think households are getting more for that money now than they were in 1985 (especially with healthcare costs, which look to have ballooned 7x or 8x in that time). It is a shame that it's starting to feel mandatory for a married couple to both work in order to be "successful". Honestly, I think the rise of the two-income household has been a net negative for society... and I mean this in a gender-neutral way; it'd be so much better if both men and women could take long stretches (years) of time off work while their partner wins the bread. I will note, as a sort of weak counterpoint to what you said: the bulk of the cost increases in that chart are college and healthcare, by far. Yes, the cost of transportation and housing have increased, but nowhere near to the same degree. You can (correctly) argue that people are buying more (and better) cars than they used to, and are buying more house than they used to, but the increases in college and healthcare costs easily dominate that chart. (Also, how is the cost of food not being considered at all?!)
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> Also, how is the cost of food not being considered at all?! I have complained about this in the past. (If there's no food in it, it's not "the cost of living", it's "the cost of buying stuff while you die of starvation", which is not a number that I actually care about.) But, if I understand correctly, the feds took food out of the CPI calculations because it was noisy, and because it was running less than the rest of inflation. At the time, that was not a clearly unreasonable thing to do. But, um, I'm not sure food has continued to run less than the rest of inflation...