4 ms·
Reading the following: > “No longer are tech companies the underdog upstarts. They have become titans,” Barr said at a public meeting held by the Justice Depar
by sneak 7y ago
Reading the following:
> “No longer are tech companies the underdog upstarts. They have become titans,” Barr said at a public meeting held by the Justice Department to examine the future of Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act.
> “Given this changing technological landscape, valid questions have been raised about whether Section 230’s broad immunity is necessary at least in its current form,” he said.
...all I can think of is “well, here comes the state-sponsored moat.”
If they weaken these protections, the big four will just hire a few more entire buildings of minimum wage content moderators (like most of them already have running) and it’s curtains for small entrants.
It makes me really sad to see the US thinking about shooting its only real growth industry in the foot.
Edit:
> while a few Democratic leaders have said the law allows the services to escape punishment for harboring misinformation and extremist content.
It’s also terrifying to think that parts of our government want to explicitly punish people for hosting legal content that they don’t like to read.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y agoMy big Q is what problem they are trying to solve here. As a not entirely impartial observer, it seems like what's actually happening is that Barr wants a way to punish tech companies for declining to broadcast certain far right voices. Like, does anyone actually believe the world is going to be a better place because these companies have to defend themselves against an infinite stream of proxy libel and tort lawsuits? Is user generated content viable at all in a world where the hosting provider takes on liability? Could this site exist in a world where these rules are implemented fairly?
- sneak 7y agoWell, it’s not just far right stuff they’re censoring in bulk, so in a weird way I can see where he’s coming from. For example, YouTube has been taking down legal instructional gunsmithing videos (one of my hobbies) because guns. Other things that scare people but aren’t associated with a US political axis position, like the lockpicking lawyer, stay up. They are absolutely editorializing (see also: Apple’s squirt gun emoji, which I would find unconscionable even if I weren’t a firearms enthusiast because I am an accurate communications enthusiast first and foremost) and their behavior needs to change before it hurts our society even more. My friend, for example, lost a meme page he ran on Facebook with hundreds of thousands of readers for posting a male nipple (the man was wearing makeup). The censorship is not just political. They are burning books and destroying value: art, teaching, literature. It’s not okay. I just don’t think this is the right approach to it.
- jaywalk 7y agoCensorship on Facebook and YouTube also goes beyond simply removing content. If the almighty algorithm decides your stuff shouldn't be seen, it won't appear in peoples feeds, drastically reducing your reach. That's another huge problem.
- sneak 7y agoI deleted my Instagram account on Valentine’s Day this year for this exact reason. You can’t prioritize content without deprioritizing other content. https://sneak.berlin/20200211/instagram/ https://sneak.berlin/20200211/instagram/
- azinman2 7y ago“They are burning books and destroying value: art, teaching, literature. It’s not okay.” What are you referring to, specifically? “ their behavior needs to change before it hurts our society even more.” What specific harm to society occurs when using a toy gun for an emoji?
- sneak 7y agoI’m talking about censorship of legal content. These companies serve as sort of a web host, but also an application service provider. I have friends and acquaintances who have worked hard to build audiences, and then these platforms took that away from them via censorship. Of course, you can make the argument that it was really Facebook’s audience the whole time, but that ignores the content being generated by my friends which drove the whole thing. Useful instructional videos and webpages I liked watching/reading and wanted to revisit had been deleted in the intervening time. It’s destroying value, because these sites function as content-neutral hosting... until suddenly they don’t one day as the censorship hammer comes down. I have been telling people to start hosting on their own domains instead. This is the only way we can disintermediate our audience we work so hard to build. The gun emoji one is more subtle. Emoji are, recall, plain text. Changing the rendering of plain text to alter its meaning is really, really bad. Here’s an example scenario as to why such ambiguity is harmful: Imagine you’re a parent. It’s summer, and it’s hot. You have a squirt gun battle with your child. The next morning, you take them to school. (You’re a parent in the southern hemisphere, probably.) An hour later you get a text from them: johnny brought a (gun emoji) to school The rendering of this image is platform-specific. Their message is either harmless context-referencing fun, or cause for the most major of alarm. Which is it? Depending on the sender’s device, they could be indicating a toy gun or a real one. Depending on the receiver’s device, it could render the same or differently. Regardless of how you feel about weapons, surely you can recognize that introducing that communications ambiguity introduces a safety issue because it just impaired communications. Now realize that they did so as a political statement. That’s not okay, any more than changing the rendering of any other letter of plain text. I really, really do not want my text handling and rendering systems editorializing to me. Ever.
- creaghpatr 7y agoUser-generated content can be viable if the users host/publish it themselves. That's usually the response when tech companies boot pages or accounts (ie. private companies exercising their rights)
- jeffdavis 7y agoMaybe we should just get rid of liability for authors and publishers, then, also? It's fair to ask how big of a problem libel is. It's hardly enforced now, anyway. False accusations fly, with no consequences. Reporters at major outlets repeat accusations with no evidence ("sources say that ... did ...").
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y agoThe reason to connect liabilities to publishers is that publishers have the ability to respond to those incentives. This is not like UGC websites. UGC websites can't practically respond to content liability proactively in their current economic model, since the marginal unit of content has such low value but imposes such high risk. Therefore, if we tried to connect liability to the UGC business, the semi-democratized form it currently has would have to die. Instead, you'd have a situation much more like the broadcast model where producers and content would need to be vetted beforehand. Small-time producers without much economic value would not be permitted onto UGC sites because the risk of liability would outweigh the benefits of hosting. (I don't see YouTube going in the direction of 8chan. It would be too damaging to the brand. So the idea that there should be no moderation is right out the window.) That's the reason why these provisions exist: without them, the businesses cannot exist. Now if you think it's a problem that teens and mommy bloggers and small time streamers can upload home movies to YouTube, you might applaud this result. But personally I don't think there's a problem with that segment existing on UGC sites, so I think it's a terrible idea to connect liability to UGC sites.
- alharith 7y ago> sad to see the US thinking about shooting its only real growth industry in the foot. It appears you are not from the US. Can you elaborate more on your perspective on why you think this to be the case? I am genuinely curious. (Just for full disclosure, the top 10 industries experiencing large growth at the moment are mostly related to construction or engineering in the traditional sense, not much hyper growth coming from web apps these days)
- sneak 7y agoI was born in the US, and I spend about half each year there. I think it is tradition in the US that whenever there is a new market or opportunity, to both celebrate the early entrants (in the case of tech, the persistent “two founders in a suburban garage” meme) and then also ignore the fact that it’s routine to make it as difficult as possible to replicate the conditions that lead to new companies or new people having wealth creation opportunities. I’ve heard it described as “pulling the ladder up behind you”. A lot of people play the game as if it’s zero-sum. It could also just be that I’m somewhat bitter because I have about five great ideas for companies that would make the world markedly better and more useful, and they have all recently been made either de facto or de jure illegal. I hate that we’re almost always stuck with large incumbents who rent-seek based on their position, or seek for the government to make it harder/illegal for others to use the same general wealth-creation methods that they did. Witnessing that level of selfishness hurts my soul, especially leveled against those who are most able and willing to build new businesses, cool products and services, and jobs.
- alharith 7y agoThanks for the reply, apologies for the incorrect assumption, but it's the internet.
- icheishvili 7y agoFAANG will need to decide if they're platforms or publishers. They currently moderate the communities, albeit selectively, while enjoying the protections granted by being a platform. This can lead to abuse of power where only select viewpoints are moderated out because unaccountable corporate leadership says so. It's correct to be thinking about this, notwithstanding the fact that I place little faith in the federal government to produce the correct outcome.
- nnq 7y agoWhere did people unearth this "platforms" vs. "publishers" argument from? It looks like a political tool someone with a dark agenda diged out of some dark swampy corner of polytics... Everything is both! Of course you'll have more and more proprietary-algos / blackbox-ML/AI-systems filtering content. And of course the content can't be manually reviewed (because SIZE) and you can't have the platform be responsible for it (what does it even mean to "be responsible for content"?!). It's sad there's not much we can do to regulate away some of the toxic infos (like the "platform vs publisher" meme currently floating around...), but here it's actually a case where doing nothing and stomacking some of the bad consequences is 1000% better that doing something! Because that "something" whatever it may be will limit fundamental freedoms simply by having something exists in this space!
- heavyset_go 7y ago> Where did people unearth this "platforms" vs. "publishers" argument from? It's a red herring.
- lallysingh 7y agoI think they have to move to purely mechanical moderation. It's the only way. Keyword and user reporting. Everything else is a mess politically (and that will end up being a political mess).
- nradov 7y agoThat has never worked, and never will work. Keywords are meaningless without understanding the surrounding context. User reporting fails when activist users engage in brigading to flag posts that they don't like even when those posts don't violate any laws or terms of service.