5 ms·
I worked on a support team for a company that that had some major financal institutions as a customer. We had remote access to their networks at times. My ve
by duxup 7y ago
I worked on a support team for a company that that had some major financal institutions as a customer.
We had remote access to their networks at times. My very first day I was amazed how much access I had at will.
One day it was announced that a customer had come to us and demanded everyone had to meet X requirements to be able to work on their networks.
Not long after another financal institution made a similar request.
Some folks inside the company were a bit riled up by the requirements (background checks, some other things). They felt the requirements were absurd.
Considering the access we had I thought they weren't strict enough. As just a lowly support dude hired during the dot com boom because the company needed warm bodies (who could do some independent thinking / troubleshooting) ... I had a lot of access.
I don't know if they were thinking about spying like this, but I'm always amazed how much access people have to data and etc just from a technical support perspective (forget developers...).
Later the company outsourced support to other countries... I'm not even sure you need spies in the US / would know anyone was spying under those circumstances.
Support teams are probabbly a hell of a lot cheaper / easier to infiltrate / they get little / poor management / oversight. I saw tons of strange choices by our outsourced technical support staff, every single time I raised concerns it was discarded by something to the effect of "yeah they suck".
And that doesn't account for all the financial institutions who outsourced their own direct ops teams to other countries ... I'd call them and if they ever were capable of following instructions 9x out of 10 they'd open up the wrong network / modems / etc.
- carlmcqueen 7y agoThis is a very common answer to these stories on hackernews but this one is from a humble point of view that truly brings home the point. My side is that I worked for a bank on the brokerage side for ten years in different positions. What always struck me was that my access was very carefully controlled, I was a background checked employee and had to meet with compliance once a year, etc etc. However when a law firm asked for anything or consultants said they needed more data they just sent massive data dumps to the network admin guy, no questions further asked. At least not at my pay grade. As I've consulted I ask for only what I need to keep my own risk down but it is always a surprise to my clients I don't want PII I don't need and only the data that my model will help enhance.
- duxup 7y agoYeah I had a similar experience in terms of security being strong in one place. .. and non existant (as I describe) elsewhere. Some of our customers did have pretty strong proesses in some places... but then zero when a process changes or something like that. Lots of: "Oh no we can't do that because <security>". Ok makes sense. It's a hassle but it is a good policy. "But you can..." All sense out the window, everything is undone.
- Zenst 7y agoIt's a tale that plays out in many forms. In the early 80's I worked for a goverment entity and had tough physical security to enter the building - however, monthly fire drill would see this large building empty onto the open carpark that was easily accessible as no perimeter fence and with that and the aspect that when re entering the building after the fire-drill, there was always one fire door open to circumvent the bottleneck at reception and with that - no security checks then. Though many instances of weak links in process due to human nature that get overlooked and only come to light once there is an incident. Which is the crux, incidents cause things to change, yet if you see that potential flaw the gravatas you have in flagging that issues is often dismissed because it hasn't happened. That is sadly often a pattern we see play out time and time again in many forms.
- murph-almighty 7y agoLiterally yesterday we had an issue with someone trying to piggyback into the office behind an employee who had badged in. Said person was intoxicated and removed his pants in the elevator, so it was immediately apparent there was a problem, but what happens when it's someone more nondescript?
- grimjack00 7y agoAbout two years after my company was bought by a larger one, I was the first person at the office one morning, only to find someone waiting outside the doors. Before I could ask, he introduced himself as an employee from an out-of-town office, and produced a company ID, so I let him in with me. We had been told to expect some visitors from that office, but I was almost hoping he was not legit, since most of us at my location still do not have a company ID, so I couldn't really say if his was real or not.
- mc32 7y agoCompanies who offshore also run across this dilemma. This is how companies can lose IP to competitors. Let’s say an IC designer offshores some work, that company has other clients as well and the off shore company has access to a lot of the R&D of the client company. Lots of things can happen in that situation and does happen.
- lkbm 7y agoI worked at a charter school for a while, and had access to the test scores and demographic data (including dob and ssn) not just for our students, but for every public school student in Texas, past and present. Data security is a myth.
- duxup 7y agoSchool's in particular are horrible. The knowledge level on those staff's is often near 0, they operate with wonky budgets (here is a gazillion dollars for ipads... no money to maintain them or the rest fo the systems), and are just making do the best they can. The IT staff at one complained to me the librarian at one elementary school kept changing things on them. In reality she had a clue and they couldn't even operate rudimentary role based access type system to stop her.
- Loughla 7y agoThis is a function of how schools are funded in the US. This is the system you asked for through voting and tax policy (maybe not you, but you being the broad citizen). Living inside the beast for my entire career - We have just enough funding to keep the doors open, and remain staffed at a minimal level. Additional funding, above what we can raise through local taxes, ALWAYS comes with an asterisk. So we can get access to $50,000 supplemental funding this year, awesome. But we have to buy I-pads. Nevermind that literally every other piece of technology in the building is windows based. Oh, and we cannot spend that on infrastructure upgrades to the wi-fi system to support the extra capacity. And it has to be spent in six months or you lose it. It's the way we're funded in the US. It isn't necessarily a function of the schools or the staff therein. Those people are generally trying to do their best. It's the shit system and it needs to be burnt to the ground.
- simonw 7y agoThat thing where US schools are paid for by property taxes is so gross. Talk about a policy designed to maintain inequality.
- Aachen 7y ago> My very first day I was amazed how much access I had at will. Another branch where you might expect security awareness is anti virus companies. I'm a pentester and in smallish companies everyone knows everyone, but nobody knows me, yet most days I can tailgate into the office without question. This morning a lady asked suspiciously "are you looking for someone?" and I just replied that I know where to go, thanks. I walked on and she didn't pursue. Free rein. I don't have to mention any specific company, this happens everywhere. Helpful, trusting that everything will be alright, clicking links... Vulnerabilities help but they are optional.
- BiteCode_dev 7y agoCurrently reading snowden book, "Permanent record". At one point he says that private companies do a huge amount of work for the NSA & Co, and have ridiculous level of access to vast arrays of personal data, which they proceed to give to their employees or subcontractors for processing. I expect FAANGS to do the same.
- chaostheory 7y agoYears ago, the key code to one of the back doors of a very large and well known financial institution in SF was extremely simple and consequetive and 4 digit sequence that everyone including contractors knew. I wonder if they ever fixed it?
- onetimemanytime 7y agoNot being a smart ass but how do background checks work for foreign persons? Say for a former student that came to USA 5 years ago and is 23 years old? Odds are that he will look clean in every way. Even if he's a spy all traces are covered. My other comment was sent to oblivion because it is politically incorrect, but the reality is that a lot students have loyalties to the old country. Also when you add the family back there and corruption being a normal way of getting things done, these things are bound to happen. I don't suggest to freeze them out, just don't be surprised.
- Aachen 7y agoYour other comment says different things though. I think it's a fair question "how do background checks work for foreign persons" vs "IMO, it's wayyy much easier to corrupt people from second or even third world countries, there corruption is the norm".
- onetimemanytime 7y agoIt is wayyyyyyy much easier, I'll repeat. To get things done corruption is used and the government can make or break, virtually everything in your life. Or your families'. A lot of things are broken in USA but it's light years away in that department compared to a lot of countries.
- Aachen 7y agoI mean, you're not wrong that corruption is a bigger problem in many countries than it is in the USA (which I guess you see similar to how I've heard many Chinese see the CCP). But saying all "second or third world countries" (whatever would even fit that definition) is quite a generalisation. Even within your definition of first world countries where there isn't (much/any) corruption, why should an Austrian be loyal to Sweden and pass any background checks?
- nl 7y agoNot being a smart ass but how do background checks work for foreign persons? Note that there are many different types of background checks, varying from things like "working with children" checks, to financial status checks, to security checks of different kinds. You are correct - it's very hard for a foreign person to pass some types of these. In some cases that means it's very difficult for them to get one of these jobs.
- dwild 7y agoA few months ago in Quebec we got a big cooperative bank "hacked" that way by an employee that got offered money by some insurance reseller.. He was able to export the data of 4.5 millions persons out and sell it to them. We recently found out that they were offering 40k$ to get it. Sure you could infiltrate them, but seems like even buying the data is quite accessible too.
- blaser-waffle 7y agoIs that Desjardins? They got hit November 2019. BMO and another org in 2018. BMO's security was atrocious, for a while they had you use your 4-digit pin to log into online banking. One of the reasons I ended up switching to Tangerine...
- benibela 7y agoAfter growing up reading BOFH, I believe the admin always controls everything
- steven_is_false 7y agoI kinda worry about this. I wish I could tell people that having that much access raises legal issues for me. It's not enough to have them sign a contract limiting liability because as a business they have far more lawyers than I do. When I work on a contract I want to be able to say in court that I couldn't possibly be in any way related to the event of a bug, security breach or data loss because I simply do not have access. It is genuinely worrying on my part to carry around credentials with that much data. What if my laptop is hacked or stolen? I do not want to be sued (again it doesn't matter if they have a valid case or not, I don't want to deal with legal fees or anything.) This is what I wish. Obviously things are far from that.