5 ms·
Does anyone know of a “set it and forget it” alternative to Let’s Encrypt? I’m all for making things more secure, but they’ve broken all of my certs in the las
by hedora 7y ago
Does anyone know of a “set it and forget it” alternative to Let’s Encrypt?
I’m all for making things more secure, but they’ve broken all of my certs in the last 12 months (in different ways, at different times), and I’m sick of it.
- wiremaus 7y agoSame here. I had them running for a small informational website, and they took the site down for several days via surprise cert problems. I may switch to a paid provider.
- Crosseye_Jack 7y agoIf you give an email address to your LE client you should get an few emails from LE advising you when a cert is due to expire giving you some time to get it sorted before your old cert expires. Edit: personally I also have a script that runs every day and checks the validity of all the certs in my live directory and pings me when they are due to expire as a second measure.
- LukeShu 7y agoI most of the LE/ACME breakages I've seen, the issue was that something broke in certbot (or other client) when rotating in the new cert, not that it was unable to get a new cert issued. LE won't email you about that.
- Crosseye_Jack 7y agoWhich is why I monitor the live certs expiry dates as well. But that’s a bug with the client then with LetEncypt.
- Crosseye_Jack 7y agoNot used them in production (only in my toy projects) but I’ve heard decent things about this https://www.buypass.com/ssl/products/go-ssl-campaign https://www.buypass.com/ssl/products/go-ssl-campaign They use the same acme system as LE so depends on what failed for you for it to be a viable alternative (if the certbot failed for example then it might of failed using buypass in the same way as it would of failed under LE)
- sandGorgon 7y agoa regular certificate. For example you could buy a Sectigo (previously Comodo) certificate for 2 years for like 17$ or so. Wildcard for 2 years is like 100$. Its worth less than a broken certificate.
- ridhoq 7y agoI’ve had a pretty terrible experience with Sectigo/Comodo over the last few months, especially thru their acquisition. At the moment, I have certificates that are managed in two different portals, one for their previous brand and one for their new brand. Customer support told me that there is no migration path to manage my certs all in one place. We are going to repurchase all of our certs in Digicert this year with which I’ve had a much much better experience. They are well integrated with Azure Key Vault which allows us to automate certificate renewal and our AKS clusters will automatically get the new certs without us doing anything.
- sandGorgon 7y agosure - i will take temporary usability issues (as comodo transitioned into sectigo), over fundamental security issues. https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/03/01/trustico_digicert_symantec_spat/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/03/01/trustico_digicert_s... if you are using your cloud certificates (built into lb, etc), then this is a moot point. You dont even need letsencrypt then.
- krenel 7y agoThose prices look promising. I don't seem to find where those prices are in their webpage[1]. All I'm seeing is 359/719 USD a year for a wildcard certificate. Am I looking in the wrong place? [1] https://www.comodoca.com/ssl-certificate-comparison?key5sk1=c147eebcd9fd6d57566e0c69838a2d324ceb2f01 https://www.comodoca.com/ssl-certificate-comparison?key5sk1=...
- sandGorgon 7y agoi usually buy from https://www.namecheap.com/security/ssl-certificates/ https://www.namecheap.com/security/ssl-certificates/ or https://www.gogetssl.com/wildcard-ssl/ https://www.gogetssl.com/wildcard-ssl/
- stevekemp 7y agoRegardless of what you end up using you need to have your own monitoring if you care about availability. My own monitoring always alerts if certificate chains don't validate, HTTP->HTTPS redirection is dead, or if the certificate is due to expire in less than 10 days. The various tools for interacting with Lets Encrypt might fail sometimes, but if you have monitoring you can fix them up as required - and without monitoring you'll in trouble regardless of who you use.
- certera 7y agoCompletely agree. The emails you get from LE are nice, but often not enough and hard to manage at scale. I created Certera to help manage LE at scale (helps with rate limits, has monitoring and alerting of expiring certificates as well as failure to renew), also helps with key storage and rotation. I'm hoping to keep iterating and adding more features and functionality. Think of it as PKI for LE certs. https://docs.certera.io https://docs.certera.io
- tialaramex 7y agoAnother thing to consider if availability is crucial for you would be OCSP Stapling and accompanying monitoring for the stapled result. OCSP out of the box is a call back to the issuing CA to verify that your certificate is still valid. Let's Encrypt like a lot of popular CAs implements this by having a CDN answer all live OCSP queries with bulk produced generic "This is still fine" answers for all the still-good certificates. But that means for any clients which check OCSP (some browsers do) that CDN is now on your critical path. You can instead have your web server obtain (and periodically refresh) OCSP answers and "staple" them to its certificate when it answers HTTPS connections so that CDN isn't on your critical path any more. However, some popular servers (most notably Apache HTTPD) do such a bad job of implementing OCSP Stapling that you're more likely to destroy your availability than improve it by enabling stapling (this is one of the things IIS actually gets right for a change), so make sure you understand what you're getting into. You will also need monitoring of the stapled response, because now if it's bad that might be a problem with your systems that you need to fix - whereas if Let's Encrypt OCSP is broken for the world you can be sure somebody else's on-call engineers are wrestling with it.
- raxxorrax 7y agoThe big cloud services offer solutions for that, although with some caveats. AWS for example creates a cert free of charge with automatic renewal, but it won't give out any private keys. So TLS is terminated at their load balancer, which you would have to use to my knowledge. I just hope Amazon is too rich to conduct widespread industrial espionage. I actually don't know if that works with domains not managed by them, but I believe so. Sadly, certs from big CAs are pretty expensive these days... Let's encrypt is really awesome service to counter that.
- Crosseye_Jack 7y ago>I actually don't know if that works with domains not managed by them, but I believe so. Yeah you can use domains not managed by them, just have to throw a txt record given by them on on to the DNS for the domain to validate that you have control of the domain.
- puzzlingcaptcha 7y agoI wonder how did it break for you? I've set it up once and it has been running off a cron job for months now (ACMEv2 + DNS auth plugin).
- driverdan 7y ago> but they’ve broken all of my certs... What happened? Was it their fault or yours?