3 ms·
> is people have been oppressing the person in question for centuries, so he’s not really in a position to be able to honestly say that he isn’t being racist or
by raxxorrax 7y ago
> is people have been oppressing the person in question for centuries, so he’s not really in a position to be able to honestly say that he isn’t being racist or generally isn’t.
Since we dropped collective punishments a longer time ago, this statement is false.
On the contrary, it a big problem on the topic of racism.
I would escalate that argument any time.
edit: it is additionally false, because "the person in question" hasn't been oppressed. So the statement is flawed in numerous ways.
- dangus 7y agoEscalation never helps. I think we have to acknowledge that discrimination and oppression will be followed by retaliation. Even if white people and men are treating black people and women, respectively, with perfect equity (spoiler alert, they’re still not), those groups have already been wronged and have been conditioned to understand that those people consider them to be sub-human. It is logical for women and black peoples to continue to distrust men and white people, respectively. So, we have to accept that there will not be be a world without bias and discrimination until we treat people like we would want to be treated, and stop escalating.
- raxxorrax 7y agoNo, you get there by minimizing discrimination. The black man in your case is the offender by insinuating racism. Your idea is to sanction innocents. edit: for some form karmic or historical justice that I would think is pretty flawed.
- dangus 7y agoI actually do think he’s in the wrong as well, in this particular case, I agree. I guess what I’m trying to say is that this person has already been affected by racism. The only hope there is to allow the passage of generations to ease that pain. In other words, by engaging and escalating the argument, even though the white guy was likely correct, he is reinforcing these tensions rather than reducing them. If people stop treating others badly, you’re left with the next generation scratching their heads saying “my grandma is so racist, it’s so weird, I don’t see the difference” which is what we want.
- raxxorrax 7y agoThat is something different. I wouldn't blame him harshly for reacting this way, but I would also firmly state that his statement is ridiculous. Use your judgement in the situation, but if you just accept it, he might continue to treat others unfairly. So a firm rebuff is certainly valid. Deescalation doesn't mean to fall on your knees. You won't ever end up on the same level and might just become a bully victim otherwise. That is no road to more justice in my opinion.