3 ms·
This reminds me of an incident on a bus recently. This one white guy told a black guy trying to get on that there was no more room on the bus, which was genera
by dangus 7y ago
This reminds me of an incident on a bus recently.
This one white guy told a black guy trying to get on that there was no more room on the bus, which was generally true, but it could have definitely looked like (from the tone and wording) that the white guy was talking down to him.
The black guy got very upset and claimed that the white man wouldn’t have said this to a white guy, and wouldn’t have said this if the bus was full of black people instead of the mostly-white and Hispanic bus in this instance.
Both parties involved escalated, argued, and made the situation worse.
At the end of the day, the original offender didn’t say anything overtly racist, but it’s also true that the black man’s points may have been factually accurate as well.
I guess, the reason I tell you this story is that:
1. I believe you are not correct to say that the majority of sexism is directed toward men. That is ridiculous. That’d be like the black guy on the bus being told that the majority of racism is against white people. Puh-lease, that does not pass the smell test. There are entire pieces of the English language that are used to accuse women of being less capable and stable (the linguistic root of the word “hysterical,” or the term “baby brain,” and a lot of others). If sexism in the tech industry is mostly against men I’d love to know why only 20% of women bother to enter that field and where the remaining 30% went.
2. Going along with point one, there is almost no response that the white guy could have made to resolve the situation. His people have been oppressing the person in question for centuries, so he’s not really in a position to be able to honestly say that he isn’t being racist or generally isn’t. There’s a saying goes that you make your own bed, and that’s what white people have done: made an entire race not trust them implicitly. This is entirely the white people’s fault. Back to the Uber situation, that’s what men have done, made the workplace so bad for women in the past that women are now fed up and can’t trust men, and they are justified.
3. Your use of of escalation is not helpful. I know you cited a bunch of sources but that doesn’t make the spirit of your comment any less inflammatory.
- raxxorrax 7y ago> is people have been oppressing the person in question for centuries, so he’s not really in a position to be able to honestly say that he isn’t being racist or generally isn’t. Since we dropped collective punishments a longer time ago, this statement is false. On the contrary, it a big problem on the topic of racism. I would escalate that argument any time. edit: it is additionally false, because "the person in question" hasn't been oppressed. So the statement is flawed in numerous ways.
- dangus 7y agoEscalation never helps. I think we have to acknowledge that discrimination and oppression will be followed by retaliation. Even if white people and men are treating black people and women, respectively, with perfect equity (spoiler alert, they’re still not), those groups have already been wronged and have been conditioned to understand that those people consider them to be sub-human. It is logical for women and black peoples to continue to distrust men and white people, respectively. So, we have to accept that there will not be be a world without bias and discrimination until we treat people like we would want to be treated, and stop escalating.
- raxxorrax 7y agoNo, you get there by minimizing discrimination. The black man in your case is the offender by insinuating racism. Your idea is to sanction innocents. edit: for some form karmic or historical justice that I would think is pretty flawed.
- dangus 7y agoI actually do think he’s in the wrong as well, in this particular case, I agree. I guess what I’m trying to say is that this person has already been affected by racism. The only hope there is to allow the passage of generations to ease that pain. In other words, by engaging and escalating the argument, even though the white guy was likely correct, he is reinforcing these tensions rather than reducing them. If people stop treating others badly, you’re left with the next generation scratching their heads saying “my grandma is so racist, it’s so weird, I don’t see the difference” which is what we want.
- raxxorrax 7y agoThat is something different. I wouldn't blame him harshly for reacting this way, but I would also firmly state that his statement is ridiculous. Use your judgement in the situation, but if you just accept it, he might continue to treat others unfairly. So a firm rebuff is certainly valid. Deescalation doesn't mean to fall on your knees. You won't ever end up on the same level and might just become a bully victim otherwise. That is no road to more justice in my opinion.
- ecmascript 7y agoI am not saying there is more sexism towards men forever, but right now in the IT-industry. I don't care about what happened 200-300 years ago, I care about what happens today. I have stopped listen to women complain in media about sexism because people never seem to give a shit when sexism strikes men. Just as people don't care about racism against whites. It's the same kind of shit ideology and I want to escalate that. Just read the responses to my post, many are claiming that there can't be any sexism against men or racism against white people. It's so unbelievably stupid it's hard to actually comprehend that these people actually are capable of being programmers. Most of them are probably white and men as well. Such self-hatred is just incredible to watch. As you can see from the sources I pointed out, some of them even thinks it's a good thing. This disgusts me and makes me not care about sexism against women. In your example, I think that the white is 100% right and he is correct in saying he's not racist. He isn't guilty of what other white people do. I completely disagree with your kind of thinking in other words.
- carapace 7y ago> It's so unbelievably stupid it's hard to actually comprehend that these people actually are capable of being programmers. As a general technique, when that happens, you can try to imagine a context wherein their POV makes sense. > As you can see from the sources I pointed out, some of them even thinks it's a good thing. What do [you think] they think is a good thing? "self-hatred"? "sexism against men or racism against white people"? > This disgusts me ... Okay. > ... and makes me not care about sexism against women. How does that follow? If sexism (or self-hatred or racism) is bad then it's bad, right?