4 ms·
Nuclear is the only feasible way to scale electricity to the globe at an affordable price, over the next few centuries. Wind and solar are great supplemental so
by chrisco255 7y ago
Nuclear is the only feasible way to scale electricity to the globe at an affordable price, over the next few centuries. Wind and solar are great supplemental sources but they can't run a modern economy.
- trimbo 7y agoI agree with you, but it will never happen. I lamented with a few reasons why in this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19167207 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19167207 The best we can do is get behind solar and wind and pray for a fusion breakthrough.
- chrisco255 7y agoGood post. I don't share your pessimism but I get why you feel that way. I think people just need to be told by a good leader that there are real trade-offs with taking "the nuclear option" but we have to embrace it. People accept trade-offs all the time. We understand some jets crash but we still don't give up air travel. We understand cars crash but we don't give up automobiles. I just think nuclear meltdown risk is overblown. If it happens four times a century, is that acceptable? I think it is. All things considered, how many people have died from nuclear meltdowns versus coal extraction?
- v7p1Qbt1im 7y agoMy amateur opinion is we need to get fusion before fossil runs out or we‘re fucked. Then it also needs to be shared among all humans (for free hopefully). Or we are fucked as well. Either energy collapse or war or both might result otherwise. If we manage to avoid either (seems unlikely so far), then we just need to solve climate change and we’re almost at type 1 civ. /speculation
- vl 7y agoAnother way to meet energy demand is to reduce population. Which already started to happen by itself in many developed countries. As standard of living raised globally, it’s probable that population will plato or decline. (With this said, I still think nuclear energy is the best option until fusion comes through).
- Dylan16807 7y agoPower plants need to be built, maintained, and rebuilt in proportion to the amount used. Which is proportional to population. So the per-capita effort spent on power plants is roughly constant, whether you have 1 billion people or 10 billion people. Reducing population doesn't make it all that much easier to meet energy demand. The efficiency of power use and the types of plants we choose to build are much more important.