4 ms·
> It seems these kinds of discoveries -- people were more advanced at some point in time than previously believed -- happen quite frequently. I think part of i
by tzs 7y ago
> It seems these kinds of discoveries -- people were more advanced at some point in time than previously believed -- happen quite frequently.
I think part of it is that we operate on a different timescale now.
We are used to being able to build big things quickly, or make things that require precise machining quickly. And so of course we can also build small things, or make less sophisticated things, even quicker.
If it would take a lifetime to build something or make something, we don't do it. Pretty much everything we need can be done way quicker than that.
We forget that for many of these things what makes them difficult is the doing them quickly part. If you are willing to take decades or even lifetimes, those things can be done with much simpler technology than we are using.
For example, I remember reading about some sort of geared mechanism from a couple thousand or more years ago. I don't think it was the Antikythera mechanism, but I don't remember for sure. Anyway, it had gears to a precision that was not seen afterwards until something like the 15th or 16th century, and so many people wonder how such ancient people could have produced such a thing.
But precise gears aren't hard if you have time. All you need is some kind of fine file that can work on the metal you want to make your gears out of, and someone who can spend a lot of time doing a "file a little bit/check the fit" loop.
You might need a workforce of 100 apprentices working for a lifetime to make something this way, and so those things are are. We see the scarcity of such items in the archaeological record, and unjustly assume it is because they didn't know how to make them.
- rebolek 7y agoPrecise gears are hard, as you need a metal that is good enough for your gears and tools to craft that metal. It's not just about time.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoThey only need to be hard if you intend them to last a long time under high loads. Plenty of watches and clocks managed to keep time with gears that are butter compared to tool steels.
- kragen 7y agoThere are lots of clocks made with wood gears, including almost all clocks made in what is now the US from 1600 to 1850 or thereabouts. Wood has some significant advantages in precision — although it unavoidably swells and shrinks substantially across the grain, as humidity and temperature rise and fall, its variation in length along the grain is much smaller, in the 1ppm/° neighborhood of Invar, an order of magnitude smaller than brass or steel. This makes clocks timed with a wooden pendulum an order of magnitude more precise than clocks timed with a plain metal pendulum; this knotty problem evaded generations of clockmakers until finally falling to legendary horology hacker John Harrison and his gridiron pendulum. Imprecise gears don't keep bad time; what they do is increase friction and wear out. Your gear ratio isn't going to change from 51:20 to 51:21 because the gears are soft, flexible, and vary in size with humidity, unless they vary by so much that the gears come out of mesh. As long as they're in mesh, each tooth on one gear is followed by precisely one tooth on the other. Rather, what will happen is that the depthing of the gears needs to include extra backlash to allow for the imprecision, and that imprecision causes deviations in the pressure angle and the like. This is a terrible problem if you are gearing down a steam engine to pump water out of a coal mine, but at the much lower loads encountered in horology, it just means you need to wind the clock more often. Chris on Clickspring has convincingly shown that even the primitive triangular tooth form used in the Antikythera Mechanism is quite adequate. The cycloidal tooth form used in modern clocks was only invented in the 1600s to 1700s, while mechanical geared clocks built in the 1300s still exist today, like the one in the Sarum Cathedral, which is iron: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KbJb92H5gy8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KbJb92H5gy8 — the clock uses a square tooth form with rounded corners on the large gears, meshing with smaller pinions whose "teeth" are round dowels. (This part of the mechanism is believed to be original, but the escapement has been replaced.) By contrast, the tooth form depicted in the 1364 Il Tractatus Astrarii is triangular, like the Antikythera Mechanism. The clock at Chioggia, also from 1386, seems to be made in precisely the same way from what I can make out from these photos: https://www.adjora.it/altro/curiosi/vari/orologio-antico-Chioggia.html https://www.adjora.it/altro/curiosi/vari/orologio-antico-Chi... Note that the Sarum clock is held together with tusk tenons like those in the 7000-year-old well discovered in 2012, but in wrought iron rather than wood. That's because in 1386 the screw was about 2000 years old but not yet in use as a fastener.
- 7y ago
- aksss 7y agoI find a similar analogy in the idea of the bronze age vs iron age. It's not as if people in the bronze age didn't know how to make iron or even steel goods; but it was really, really damn expensive. It just wasn't cost effective until they found new methods of production and/or new energy sources to fuel those methods of production.