5 ms·
My experience with investor-provided talent has been very poor. Historically, the problem is that VCs tend to send "subject matter expert" type consultants who
by PragmaticPulp 7y ago
My experience with investor-provided talent has been very poor.
Historically, the problem is that VCs tend to send "subject matter expert" type consultants who give advice. Startups need someone to do the work more than they need someone to give the advice. The VC-provided talent usually generated more work than they solved with questionable returns for the company.
Unless Reid Hoffman has cracked the code of sending the right people to get work done, I'm suspicious.
- pmart123 7y agoI can see that. In my experience, it works to have a subject matter expect at as a consultant/mentor to a few young and hungry employees. Essentially, the expert can help lead a team through big technical decisions or when there is a roadblock. However, the expert likely doesn’t want to put in the hours or do the necessary grunt work.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- alasdair_ 7y agoI could see VC-provided specialists, like a lawyer, CPA, perhaps also specific skills like a data scientist before a startup has enough cash to employ one full-time but I don’t see why this would be any better than the startup employing the contractor themselves with cash.
- jjeaff 7y agoI can see a much better situation where the VC gives you cash so you can hire your own CPA and lawyer. We had a VC pull this garbage once. Although it wasn't for equity. They just offered it as a service "at cost". We dropped their $90/hr Manhatten based book keeper and $800/hr attorney just as quick as we could without ruffling too many feathers.
- enra 7y agoAlso, I think VCs pick operational talent on "political" reasons, mainly people they have gotten to know somehow from previous companies they invested in or as founders. These people while might be good, do not necessarily have a good skillset or fit for your company.
- skrebbel 7y agoFWIW, I had the exact same experience, and I lost faith in the "operational VC" model. Hiring the right people is hard for everybody, and the chance that a VC can spin up an "agency" style department that somehow has the best people is really small. The entire model attracts the kind of "consultants who give advice" you describe. After all, people who want to get their hands dirty, i.e. people who are a good fit with startups, are overwhelmingly going to want to work directly for said startups. We also had this super weird mismatch with perceived value. The operational VC "billed" agency-style, so by the hour, at (to us) outrageous hourly rates. It was like 6x what we'd pay a salaried employee doing the same work. We didn't "feel" it as bad because it cost us equity, not money. But we'd have never hired that agency for that money, if it was cash. The moment we realized that this was the case, we stopped the collaboration. It was a costly distraction and nothing more. I'm curious if Hoffman found a way around this, but I don't see it in this article.
- emeerson 7y agoI suspect this is because these are wolves in operator's clothing. If you deploy true operators that are doing labor in their area of expertise, and if they can pre-empt obvious mistakes + generate reproducible playbooks, you could net out ahead.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- commoner 7y agoHoffman has no incentive to find a way around costly billing practices, since it benefits his VC firm (Sweat Equity Ventures). This kind of pricing, when implemented, is a clear case where the interests of the startup and the VC are misaligned. It's up to the founders to recognize that the "operational VC" model is a bad deal for themselves, and reject it accordingly.
- skrebbel 7y ago> since it benefits his VC firm That's only assuming he doesn't understand the VC model, which I doubt. The extremely power-law nature of VC investments means he can get better returns if he maximizes the growth trajectory of his portfolio companies, than if he maximizes the size of his share (by billing at high rates, i.e. at the cost of potentially less steep growth). Unless he's a moron, he'll genuinely want his sweat investment to cause tremendous growth more than anything else. I think that the incentives are aligned as much as they are with cash VC investments (i.e. closely, but not entirely, because the founder has all their eggs in a single basket and the VC doesn't). I just think he can't pull it off. :-)
- mike_d 7y ago> ...consultants who give advice. Startups need someone to do the work more than they need someone to give the advice. I've been on the other side of this with a few startups, and the right answer is almost never to come in and drop a bunch of code as much as founders would like an extra set of hands. A good SME can come in and have a solid whiteboard session with a team to shave off the first two iterations of development. I've done this before from a security perspective where just making the developers aware of the sharp edges and being available to answer questions was a massive force multiplier.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoWhat exactly are you whiteboarding there if this is an early-stage startup?
- brandmeyer 7y agoMinimize time figuring out how to shave the yak.
- nl 7y agoElsewhere in this discussion someone said they are finance and operations people. I think that's moderately useful - doing the work on building financial models or finding operational hacks to solve specific problems can be helpful, and isn't really a thing where it is annoying bringing a person up to speed only for them to leave.
- te_chris 7y agoMost of these people I've met in London are all ex consulting, so basically useless day to day.
- notahacker 7y agoThe area where I can see a VC's network adding a lot of value is 'person who built sales operation for growth company in related market'. That's not necessarily someone that's easy for a startup to hire, especially pre-Series A. On the other hand anyone if someone's output is aspirational pitch decks and market-scoping, at least one of the founders is already good at that to have got the VC interested, and by the time a startup's challenge is scaling operations the startup has cash to pay for the expertise.
- Nasrudith 7y agoReally even if VCs were utterly rational their model already incentivizes "go big or go home" on a grand scale. You as a founder would be perfectly fine with a "mere" 10% chance of a "just" 10M$ company to early retire, work with independence to be able to walk away at will, or bootstrap depending on ambitions. VCs would win more amortized over all of their funding a 0.01% chance for a $100B company. That fits with the current big money model of trying to pump up a given service with no business model to get user base and then have it collapse after they alienate their users trying to monetize it. It looks utterly stupid and may be a form of economic resource misallocation (both as a matter of opinion and derth of comparable data) but it benefits the VC.
- Axsuul 7y agoThis may be the case for some but not for all. There are some business models that do require funding. Many of the services and software that you use on a daily basis wouldn't be around if it weren't for VCs. Not everything is bootstrap or die (disclaimer: I'm a bootstrapped founder).
- gowld 7y ago> You as a founder would be perfectly fine with a "mere" 10% chance of a "just" 10M$ company to early retire No way. Assuming a 4 year investment that's lower pay than a low risk bigcorp job.
- Drdrdrq 7y agoBut waaaay more interesting. :)
- anthm1988 7y agoThe vast majority of people aren't making 2.5 million a year even at the biggest corporations.
- mercutio2 7y agoI was about to say the same thing, then I realized the point is that a 10% chance of $2.5M/year == $250k/year expected return, which IS lower than your expected return working for a BigCo (there’s a distribution of income depending on how you perform, there, too, but it’s much lower risk). This is a little bit disingenuous, because I’m pretty confident outside the 10% best case, there’s a pretty broad distribution where you work long hours and come away with SOME return, so I suspect the expected return may be close to even for passionate founders, albeit probably with more stress in the overall effort. Of course, the people starting companies usually aren’t guessing they have a 10% chance of success; you need to believe you’re an outlier to be successful in the startup game, it seems to me.