4 ms·
Seriously... I want to know the business/legal logic behind adding copyright messages to the clipboard when copying. This has happened for a long time with news
by crazygringo 7y ago
Seriously... I want to know the business/legal logic behind adding copyright messages to the clipboard when copying. This has happened for a long time with news sites, Apple Books, etc.
No user ever has ever wanted that.
So what lawyers, where, ever demanded it, and why? Short snippets fall under fair use anyways... and even if it didn't such a message doesn't prevent anything (you just delete it after pasting)... and it you were oblivious to how copyrights worked before, this isn't going to teach you.
So it's UX annoyance but why? Not only does it not provide an obvious legal benefit to any party, I don't even see how it's legally covering anyone's ass? Like, I know how under trademark law companies have to warn people against using their trademark generically or else they can lose it -- so as dumb as it is to get an e-mail from Adobe asking you not to use "Photoshop" as a verb in your press release, I get it. But copyright... doesn't work like that.
So how/why did this become a thing? I just don't understand the legal rationale here.
- CM30 7y agoIt wasn't about copyright or fair use, at least not directly. The intended purpose of this sort of code was to: 1. Make sure many people who shared content from your site would link back to the source 2. Track shares where the full link to the page wasn't copied 3. Trick scrapers/careless plagiarists into linking back to the original source, using their own carelessness to get an extra backlink or two (and tell Google your site was the original). All of these obviously only worked on people that didn't check what they were copying, but hey, those were some of the reasons behind it.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoIt's just advertising surely, like Apple's insistence on "sent from my iPhone" type footers, annoyance is the point.
- otterley 7y agoAttorney here! (Not legal advice; consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction.) I am skeptical that this is a copyright issue that raised an attorney's attention. It's far more likely IMO that this was a contractual obligation imposed by the publisher. I have no insider knowledge as to whether this is actually true, but it's quite probable that in exchange for allowing Apple Books to republish their content, the publisher required Apple to append this attribution when copying content into the clipboard. In theory, preserving such an attribution might cause more copies to be sold. Also, contrary to your assertion, not every short snippet qualifies for a Fair Use defense; there's a four-factor test that courts apply, and the length is just one of those factors. But again, I think this less to do with copyright and more to do with a business arrangement.
- pvg 7y agoI have no insider knowledge I don't either, with the added bonus of a complete lack of legal training but this clipboard thing has been a part of commercial e-reader apps for so long, if your (very plausible-sounding) theory is right, it's been boilerplate in such contracts for many years.