4 ms·
You can stretch the term AI to refer to a lot of things, but not as far as I think you're implying. Even today, the vast majority of software written is unambig
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
You can stretch the term AI to refer to a lot of things, but not as far as I think you're implying. Even today, the vast majority of software written is unambiguously not AI, and the substantial majority of startups couldn't be called AI companies even as a dumb marketing tactic.
- whatshisface 7y agoAlso, some of the competition for most overstretched buzzword is pretty stiff. For example all of those "block chain" applications that are equivalent both philosophically and practically to one trusted party with an SQL database. I don't think IoT is stretched at all, the name implies "refrigerators but with GSM" and "cars, but they report your every move to the manufacturer," and that's what we have. They're "things" (objects) on the "internet" (a data collection system for marketers).
- graycat 7y ago> practically to one trusted party with an SQL database. Nicely put. For some months I posted essentially this description to Fred Wilson's AVC.COM. Good to see that I'm not the Lone Ranger in this view. IIRC I also mentioned that SQL database could be both fault tolerant, including redundant, and distributed. Also last time I read on SQL (e.g., Microsoft's SQL Server) it seemed that the opportunities for security, authentication, capabilities, access control lists, and encryption were good.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoMajority of software written today is code bureaucracy, linking together people and decisionmakers. "AI" can be stretched very far. If I apply linear regression on user-entered numbers to suggest them something, I can call it "AI" and be less dishonest with it than a lot of startups on the market. (LR at least isn't a glorified RNG, which a DNN can become if one's not careful, or apply it to a domain that doesn't give obvious, visual feedback.)
- column 7y agoNo dataset, no training, no layers = not AI
- gwd 7y agoClassically speaking, any time you gave computers a goal to optimize for, it was called "AI"; a large amount of AI research in the 80's and 90's was about how to optimize search. Thus SQLite's website, for instance, (correctly) says: "The query planner is an AI that tries to pick the fastest and most efficient algorithm for each SQL statement." Optimizing database queries was a common topic for artificial intelligence research in the 80's and 90's. It's just that now we're so used to the idea of a computer searching for the best flight, the best map, the best way to optimize your code, the best way to execute your SQL query, that it doesn't seem like "magic" any more. When you say "no dataset, no training" you're talking about machine learning. And when you say "layers", you're talking about deep learning. [1] https://sqlite.org/queryplanner.html https://sqlite.org/queryplanner.html
- VBprogrammer 7y agoGenetic algorithms might have fallen out of favour recently but I don't think anyone would exclude them from AI as a category. The field in my experience has always contained a lot of planning and inference which you seem to be excluding.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoLR absolutely has datasets and training. You train a regression model in much the same way as you train any other ML model, DNNs included - you use some data to derive its parameters, use the rest to validate. LR typically has number of layers = 1, though I bet someone imaginative enough could create "deep linear regression", if that was useful for anything.
- sacado2 7y agoThe guys who coined the term "AI" strongly disagree.