4 ms·
Somebody is getting close to completing their Dyson sphere?
by adrianN 7y ago
Somebody is getting close to completing their Dyson sphere?
- tyfon 7y agoGood luck dyson sphering that star :) It's massive and very violent! It might be that this violence is causing the dimming by discharging massive amounts of dust and gas. I hope it's a prelude to fireworks but that is unfortunately not probable.
- raxxorrax 7y agoI just hope that there is nobody wanting our sun to explode for scientific curiosity.
- tyfon 7y agoBetelgeuse can not sustain life and it _will_ blow up very soon in cosmic timescales. There is nothing we do to stop it blowing up so yes, I hope to see this event in my lifetime :) Our sun is much more stable.
- detritus 7y agoHow can you know that? I mean, you're probably correct, but given we have precisely one datapoint for life, it's a bit much to extrapolate further - there might be aeons-old silicon-skinned space whales congregating around Betelgeuse for their thrice giga-millennial spawning season, or something... . Probably not. - ed 'thrice kilo or mega millennial' seems a bit less unlikely!
- tyfon 7y agoWell, disregarding radiation resistant space whales (which would be able to migrated to another star anyway), I think it's pretty clear the radiation and onslaught of solar winds from Betelgeuse will sterilise everything in the vicinity. But you are right, nothing can be ruled out ;)
- hinkley 7y agoIf we're talking hypotheticals, a tidally locked planet would lose its volatiles pretty quickly, but one could in theory bunker up on the far side of the planet and survive. But you'd be stuck there forever, right? Diffraction means that the shadow only goes out so far before you're being cooked again by one form of particle or another.
- Recurecur 7y agoGiant stars are quite short-lived, with Betelgeuse estimated to have at most a 15 million (not billion!) year life before becoming a red supergiant . If simple life did evolve in time, it was wiped out about 100,000 years ago as Betelgeuse became a supergiant. One last fun fact: Betelgeuse is about 125,000 times brighter than the Sun in absolute luminosity.
- bart_spoon 7y agoWell if Betelgeuse explodes, it technically already happened back in the middle ages and we are only just now seeing it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- perl4ever 7y agoI've started finding this sort of comment very irritating since I've converted to the idea that everything on the surface of a light cone is simultaneous. The meaning of the so called "relativity of simultaneity" appears to me to be that you just shouldn't talk about simultaneous events with spacelike separation.
- whatshisface 7y agoIf you agree that you can say Betelgeuse is far away without someone objecting with "only in a reference frame that isn't close to it!" then you should also agree that there is an implied set of reference frames that are reasonable to use in the interpretation of comments written on Earth. In the same way that "Betelgeuse is far away" means "Betelgeuse is far away from me," the claim that "an event on Betelgeuse that we are observing today happened in the Middle Ages" means that "an event on Betelgeuse that we are observing today happened in the Middle Ages from a reference frame comoving with anyone on Earth."
- lawlessone 7y agoThis is probably the last star you would want your Dyson sphere on.
- CDSlice 7y agoWhich makes it the perfect star to cover with a Dyson sphere. What better way to flex on your interstellar neighbors than by harnessing one of the most powerful, violent things in nature?
- apocalyptic0n3 7y agoI think the point being made is the size of it. To make it into a Dyson sphere would require encasing a star that, if centered on Sol, would consume at least the inner 4 planets if not Jupiter as well. It's 950 times the size of our own star and one of the largest in the known universe. There would surely be easier supernova-capturing flexes
- mnsc 7y ago"Four intergalactical-capable factions are trying to decide who holds the most power. In an average galaxy in a pretty anonymous corner of the universe one faction detects a unprecedented large star-about-to-go-nova and races to capture the imminent energy surge of a sort the universe hasn't experienced yet. Or will the galaxy implode before they have aligned it all." A back cover blurb I wouldn't mind picking up! If something like this is already written I want to know.
- speakeron 7y agoCould be a one-shot Dyson Sphere designed to capture the energy of a supernova. Like an advanced civilization's version of a nuclear explosion-pumped X-ray laser[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_laser https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-ray_laser
- adrianN 7y agoI think if you're at that level of technology you'd rather make sure that the star doesn't explode and eject a bunch of valuable fuel into deep space.
- lmilcin 7y agoIf I wanted to build Dyson sphere I would choose a star with longer estimated lifetime for bigger bang for the buck. Maybe dwarf star to save on building materials?