5 ms·
"ditches" definitely not the word that should describe this (this is towards the article and not the HN submitter since it's the article's title); it could lead
by judge2020 7y ago
"ditches" definitely not the word that should describe this (this is towards the article and not the HN submitter since it's the article's title); it could lead those who don't click to think it's another project Google has shut down.
> “We are transferring our Station operations in South Africa to Think WiFi who will now carry out the project independently,” a spokesperson told Business Insider SA.
> “We'll work with Think Wifi on a plan to transition the service to them, and continue to support them until the end of 2020. We remain committed to looking for ways to make the internet more accessible to users around the world.”
- xeromal 7y agoIf I hand my child over to someone else to raise forever, I'm ditching them. :p
- booi 7y agoA 3 month old at that
- pcdoodle 7y agowtf?
- cma 7y agoBut if you sell a car to a new owner, you aren't ditching it in the woods.
- xeromal 7y agoIf you owned it for 3 months, I'd think you were nuts.
- daveFNbuck 7y agoNotice that you had to add "in the woods" to make it clear that ditching is negative here.
- chii 7y agobad analogy. There's no parent/child relationship between this service and google. As long as the service is continued, there's no issue as to who is owning and operating it. Using children makes it seem like google is providing essential operational expertise to keep the child alive, and the child would die if stopped.
- xeromal 7y agoNah, my analogy between a kid or a car is that if you get thing that is meant to be decently long term, car at least a year or a kid at least 18 years, you wouldn't give up in 3 months. There's not many things a person would own or have that giving up in 3 months wouldn't see like ditching it. Even giving up a cell phone in 3 months is pretty daft
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> Using children makes it seem like google is providing essential operational expertise to keep the child alive, and the child would die if stopped. In the same way that when a child is adopted, it instantly dies?
- rvnx 7y agoWhen you are Google, you have millions in funding, almost unlimited engineering ressources, political connections and many good reasons why a project would be successful (journalists, audience, users, accounts, etc) Once you transfer the responsibilities; all of the support that kept the project stay afloat disappears. It's not sustainable anymore, there is much limited growth, all the business model for exploiting data for advertising cannot exist anymore, etc. Well, it's dead you know.
- jbc1 7y agoProducts often die when transferred to another organisation. They never say that they will die in the announcement. See https://ourincrediblejourney.tumblr.com/ https://ourincrediblejourney.tumblr.com/ It's entirely reasonable for people to assume this is basically Google shutting down the free WiFi service but with extra steps.
- tmpz22 7y ago
- zapita 7y agoIn all likelihood the “transfer” is just a way for Google to save face and avoid yet another “Google kills project” news cycle. Good on the editors for not falling for it.
- Covzire 7y agoAnother possibility is that the legal landscape was more hostile than Google anticipated and they essentially got squeezed out.
- bootlooped 7y agoIsn't "this didn't go the way we thought it would and we're not willing to fight for it" the reason why all their products die?
- beatgammit 7y agoNo, it seems their products die because there's more prestige in launching a product than maintaining one.
- libria 7y ago"This went poorly because we care far more about launch than execution" is really the same spirit as the gp's paraphrase.
- spicyramen 7y agoMany products from Google die because is a bottom up company: many ideas that make it into products come from Engineering directly, (guys who wants o solve challenging problems), to later find out that the business analysis was poor...and an internal performance system that advocates for launches
- justinclift 7y ago