3 ms·
Copyright itself is broken. It's the 21st century. Copying data is not only trivial, it's a fundamental computer operation. We should not be imposing any limits
by matheusmoreira 7y ago
Copyright itself is broken. It's the 21st century. Copying data is not only trivial, it's a fundamental computer operation. We should not be imposing any limits on this activity. If these rich 20th century industries can't adapt and end up bankrupt, so be it. We should not be protecting them from irrelevance by sacrificing free computing and the free internet for the sake of their decaying business model.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- willvarfar 7y agoI’ll play devils advocate for you: Imagine I write something entertaining on my personal blog. Is it okay for somebody or some company to copy that content to their own website without my permission? If it is, is isn’t, why or why not?
- falcor84 7y agoI'll bite. I don't see any problem with the copying itself. Indeed that's what the Internet Archive does, and I don't see anything wrong with that. There only relevant problem I see here would be if they attributed the text to themselves, which is an entirely separate issue.
- michaelmrose 7y agoIt's OK because it's their computer and the electrons in their machine didn't become yours when the became configured so as to represent different words. In the same fashion if I write your words on my paper with my pen the common sense ownership of pen and paper doesn't change. Copyright is an invented right drawn from nothing that derived its legitimacy solely from utility derived from paying for creativity. Turns out that we are already rich enough as a society to pay for a decent life for everyone and most of the money sticks to the hands of greedy people with lumps of coal for souls and zero creativity. The kind of morons who would try to take down a dictionary.
- Silhouette 7y agoCopyright is an invented right drawn from nothing So are all property rights. The "common sense" ownership of pen and paper that you mentioned is that if I'm bigger than you, or I have a better weapon, or I have more friends, then your pen and paper are now mine. Fortunately for almost everyone, as a society we have learned to cooperate better than that.
- michaelmrose 7y agoWe can't both eat the same sandwich we can both read the same epub.
- Silhouette 7y agoOnly if someone wrote that epub in the first place, though.
- michaelmrose 7y agoTrue and the equipment required to create the book in most cases is now down to about $200. Access to the internet comes at a comparatively princely $60 a month. In a lot of first world nations education and health are gratis. Donations can be solicited to fund the creation of desirable works. I wonder if copyright went away people would still write books?
- Silhouette 7y agoI wonder if copyright went away people would still write books? I respectfully suggest that you're asking the wrong question. Obviously some books would still be written. More insightful questions might be whether people would still write as many books, whether the books written would be as good, and whether books would reach as large an audience as happens under copyright. I contend that it is utterly implausible that an entirely voluntary or even patronage-based system would come anywhere close to our current situation by any of those metrics. The vast majority of the cost of making a book has nothing to do with buying a laptop or paying for an Internet connection. It comes from the time and skill and creativity and understanding of the author. Depending on the nature of the book, it also comes from the time and skill and creativity and understanding of proofreaders, editors, illustrators, graphic designers, researchers...
- matheusmoreira 7y ago> Is it okay for somebody or some company to copy that content to their own website without my permission? Sure. Why not? It's just data and it doesn't actually belong to anyone. By reproducing your work and making it more widely available, I'd even say they're helping you by propagating your ideas. The most common problems with this is the subversion of the creator's business model and reputation. If people get your content via someone else's website, they won't look at your ads and might think someone else wrote it. We need alternative business models that don't depend on artificial scarcity. Advertising is becoming more and more unacceptable so we'll have to come up with something better one way or another. As for reputation, I think the way academia handles plagiarism is much more sane: misrepresenting authorship causes damage to one's own reputation. Even if the work did belong to you and someone did copy it without permission, would you sue them? Would you spend thousands of dollars and years of your life fighting against them in court? Most people wouldn't. This intellectual property stuff disproportionally benefits rich corporations with lots of expensive lawyers at their disposal.
- takeda 7y agoImagine instead of writing it in your blog, telling it someone. Does he/she have right to tell it to others? This is how we, humans, functioned for ages, you are basing your opinion on already artificial constructs. We as humanity, achieved most thanks to copying information and constantly improving and building on top of it. Copyright was meant to provide short time for the authors to make money, before releasing it to pubic domain. Initially copyright, protected the work only for 14 years, now it is 100 years after the death of the author and it is extended perpetually, because our constitution says that copyright needs to expire, it doesn't specify when, which is being exploited. Company like Disney, built their empire on public domain works, but fiercely fights to prevent them to become public domain. Every time copyright for Mickey Mouse is about to expire, our Congress extends it. We need to get back to sensible time frame. 14 years was more than enough to make profit from your works.
- matheusmoreira 7y agoI completely agree with you. The original idea behind copyright was "we'll pretend your intellectual work is scarce for a couple decades so you can turn a profit and then it'll enter the public domain". When was the last time something entered the public domain? Probably the early 20th century. All the great films we grew up with? They were supposed to have entered the public domain a long time ago but Netflix still has to pay for them and as a result they're unavailable. After all these extensions, we'll probably be long dead by the time they become public property. If it ever happens -- I have no doubt they'll try to make their copyrights last forever. The copyright industry isn't really keeping up their end of the deal. People should respond by voiding the social contract. There is no reason to recognize copyright as a legitimate concept much less lose any sleep over any infringement.
- est31 7y agoPeople are working weeks, months, years, often under extreme conditions to create a work of art, like, say an episode of Game of Thrones. Not just one person, but hundreds of them. Getting such large teams to work on a project would not be possible if people could just donate for that work or something, because you'd get much much less money from it. Sure there are issues with copyright, for one terms are decades too long, but your extreme view of it is as wrong as the extreme view of Sonny Bono.
- hutzlibu 7y ago"Getting such large teams to work on a project would not be possible if people could just donate for that work or something, because you'd get much much less money from it. " Currently yes. Because the normal person is conditioned to only pay if he or she has to. But imagine if there is sudddenly no more copyright and ... oh my god, no more episode of series xyz because of no money ... you really believe all those hardcore fans would not quickly adopt to pay freely if the result is more of the content they want, if the alternative is no more content?
- mjevans 7y agoYes, I do believe that. However I actually would love to switch to a more kickstarter/etc like system where fans fund the creation of works they enjoy and then those works are just in the public domain / culture as a result. The creators and everyone else involved would be paid before, not after, making something.
- est31 7y agoThey will pay, and for big famous pieces of art like GoT they'll pay lots of money, but even then it will be off by an order of magnitude of the production budget, not even calculating the marketing budgets needed to keep that fanbase.
- hutzlibu 7y agoWell then GoT would go away, if not enough people are willing to pay for it. The world will move on. More critical would be medical research, but I believe there is actually already lots of freely donated money for example in cancer research involved. But surely much more is needed, so the change would be with friction ... but if suddenly all the medicine can be made freely, the benefit for the current world population which mostly cannot afford expensive medicine would outweight it, I believe. (anyway all hypothetically anyway)
- raverbashing 7y agoUnfortunately, in comparison to the patent trolls, the bigger copyright trolls are also the biggest producers of "copyrighted content" (not that content produced by anyone doesn't have copyright, but they often forgot this fact) and they push for damaging legislation.
- Silhouette 7y agoIf these rich 20th century industries can't adapt and end up bankrupt, so be it. How should the many millions of people around the world who contribute to creative content enjoyed by many millions more every day then put food on their tables, in your version of the future? Arguments about the ease of copying information in the Internet age are easy to make, but that's just the marginal cost of distribution. These arguments almost invariably ignore the issue of creating that content in the first place, and that the main economic role of copyright is to amortise that cost over many people who ultimately benefit from the work rather than just relying on some extremely wealthy patron or the equivalent to fund it philanthropically. So far, other business models that have been tried have rarely come even close to supporting the same quantity and quality of creative work that our current copyright-based regime does. Until someone proposing to revoke copyright and allow everything to be copied freely comes up with a viable alternative model, most people are going to continue not to take them seriously.
- christiansakai 7y agoIn your world, Siraj Raval is a messiah