7 ms·
The fact it removed 4 dictionary entries for the word "did" including Merriam Webster is really the worst part. DMCA is completely broken and the accounts abus
by dmix 7y ago
The fact it removed 4 dictionary entries for the word "did" including Merriam Webster is really the worst part.
DMCA is completely broken and the accounts abuses are endless. We had an entire subreddit with 25k subscribers taken down by a person using fake DMCA requests. For months we had random completely innocuous posts with zero copyrightable content taken down do to "copyright infringement" by an off-kilter person who people on the subreddit pissed off at some point. Then eventually the entire subreddit went down due to "repeat copyright infringement".
Remember kids, if you see something you don't like on the internet (or even more relevant to this era of intolerance towards free speech: anything that "offends" you) just spam DMCA requests. Almost all sites like Reddit, Youtube, and Google don't actually care if it's legitimate or not, and they always automatically take the side of the person who filed it. And if they do push back there will be 10 more waiting by the time the system figures one out.
- andrewprock 7y agoIt's not DMCA that's broken, it's the people that run those companies implementing the policies that are broken.
- dmix 7y agoIt was always economically impossible for Google or Youtube or Reddit or any major website with thousands of new user-generated posts a day (let alone millions) to review each of these cases. I'm not even blaming the companies like Reddit, it really is an unrealistic thing to ask of them. What is going to stop these professional "copyright companies" or people exploiting it from existing? Better laws against people who file "false" claims? Maybe... but even then only people with the funds and time and jurisdictional ability (a very important one for anyone who knows civil law) to file the suits will ever get justice. Still something needs to be done here obviously.
- tmpz22 7y agoIf you’re going to allow internet bullies to curbstomp your user bases maybe your product sucks and you should go out of business. “There’s nothing we could’ve done” - bullshit. You sent that message from your fourth Lake Tahoe vacation this quarter. (You as in the metaphorical person who said “there’s nothing we could’ve done” not the comment above me).
- dmix 7y agoI think the important thing here is not many people have figured this out yet where it's a major problem on Reddit, one probably only a threat to smaller subreddits but certainly possible with individual posts on bigger ones. There's probably thousands of angry users getting banned every day with way too much time who would love to know this fact. I was quite impressed by how clever the person was for figuring out how to take down an entire subreddit he didn't like, but the implications were quite scary and it made me realize how dangerous DMCA is. Especially in an age where political groups and sites like Twitter encourage outrage mobs looking for mob justice. But I agree Reddit, Google, etc should be working towards solving this, through lobbying or whatnot. I haven't figured out a good solution I just know it's a massive problem.
- matheusmoreira 7y agoAnyone with significant social media influence can take down subreddits they don't like. All they have to do is make enough noise on social media until advertisers notice. When they refuse to associate with Reddit because of the controversial community, it will be summarily neutralized by either quarantine or deletion. If a website has a business model at all, it's safe to assume it has no integrity and will censor anything if that business model is threatened.
- tzs 7y ago> It was always economically impossible for Google or Youtube or Reddit or any major website with thousands of new user-generated posts a day (let alone millions) to review each of these cases. The only review required is that the notices and counter-notices are signed, identify the work in question, have the filer's contact information, include a statement that the filer has a good faith belief about the infringement or lack of infringement, and include a statement (in notices) that the information in the filing is accurate or (in counter-notices) that you consent to jurisdiction of the Federal District Court in the district the address in your contact information is in. This level of review should not require much effort, and the people doing it just need basic literacy. They don't need any legal training.
- matheusmoreira 7y agoThe DMCA doesn't just enable abuse, it also prohibits security research, reverse engineering...
- matheusmoreira 7y agoCopyright itself is broken. It's the 21st century. Copying data is not only trivial, it's a fundamental computer operation. We should not be imposing any limits on this activity. If these rich 20th century industries can't adapt and end up bankrupt, so be it. We should not be protecting them from irrelevance by sacrificing free computing and the free internet for the sake of their decaying business model.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- willvarfar 7y agoI’ll play devils advocate for you: Imagine I write something entertaining on my personal blog. Is it okay for somebody or some company to copy that content to their own website without my permission? If it is, is isn’t, why or why not?
- falcor84 7y agoI'll bite. I don't see any problem with the copying itself. Indeed that's what the Internet Archive does, and I don't see anything wrong with that. There only relevant problem I see here would be if they attributed the text to themselves, which is an entirely separate issue.
- michaelmrose 7y agoIt's OK because it's their computer and the electrons in their machine didn't become yours when the became configured so as to represent different words. In the same fashion if I write your words on my paper with my pen the common sense ownership of pen and paper doesn't change. Copyright is an invented right drawn from nothing that derived its legitimacy solely from utility derived from paying for creativity. Turns out that we are already rich enough as a society to pay for a decent life for everyone and most of the money sticks to the hands of greedy people with lumps of coal for souls and zero creativity. The kind of morons who would try to take down a dictionary.
- 7y ago
- rstupek 7y agoA provider like reddit, youtube, google, etc can't "push back" and not then themselves become party to the infringement. Don't blame them blame the law as written. Providers don't get to choose a side. Counter DMCA exists though so legitimate content can be restored pretty quickly with a counter claim
- matheusmoreira 7y ago> Counter DMCA exists though so legitimate content can be restored pretty quickly with a counter claim When people get arrested after a false accusation, they shouldn't be happy just because they can prove their innocence in court later. Unjustified preemptive punishment should never happen in the first place. The accuser should have to prove beyond doubt that the accused is guilty in order to justify the intervention of any higher power. If they can't do it, absolutely nothing should happen.
- not2b 7y agoIn this case, a counterclaim was filed long ago and Google has not acted. See the article. Edit: oh, I see that the content has now been restored (from another comment).
- lern_too_spel 7y agoYou do not have to be proven to be guilty beyond reasonable doubt to be arrested. That happens after arrest and before prison. Someone who is falsely arrested or whose works are wrongly taken down by DMCA can sue in civil court. The remedy is exactly the same in both cases.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zozbot234 7y agoWhat infringement? The 'infringement' of using 'did' in a dictionary definition, of all things?
- wolco 7y agoHow does one file a DMCA takedown request? Is it just an open form on the internet or is there a charge per request?