4 ms·
Um, no. You can't take a public domain image and claim you own it and are thus due licensing fees, that's both immoral and .. save this ruling which I'd hope wo
by pbhjpbhj 7y ago
Um, no. You can't take a public domain image and claim you own it and are thus due licensing fees, that's both immoral and .. save this ruling which I'd hope would be over turned, tout de suite .. should be illegal.
This is a serious problem. If companies can take public domain images and claim them as their own that's going to seriously curtail the public domain. What benefit is there to the pubic in that, the balance of copyright would be entirely broken by such a ruling of it held.
Now claiming $1B? Not sure. But the sum would need to be a significant portion of Getty's global revenue to make sure they didn't claim they had ownership of other public domain works.
- koboll 7y ago>Um, no. You can't take a public domain image and claim you own it and are thus due licensing fees Yes, you can. You would be wrong. And you would lose in court when attempting to extract those license fees. But the act of making such a claim is not itself something that can be sued over, because no one has rights to the photo once it has been released to the public domain, and thus no one has standing to sue.
- lonelappde 7y agoeveryone has the right to use the photo. The standing would be harassment and fraud and SLAPPing, for threatening to sue on false pretenses.