11 ms·
Activate this ‘bracelet of silence,’ and Alexa can’t eavesdrop
- neonate 7y agohttps://archive.md/E7Ez7 https://archive.md/E7Ez7
- bscphil 7y ago> A large, somewhat ungainly white cuff with spiky transducers, the bracelet has 24 speakers that emit ultrasonic signals when the wearer turns it on. The sound is imperceptible to most ears, with the possible exception of young people and dogs, but nearby microphones will detect the high-frequency sound instead of other noises. This is surely not actually effective against a wide range of well designed, real world microphones, and definitely not against something designed to surreptitiously record you. Strikes me as more of a gimmick than anything else. Full disclosure: I don't have any always-on microphones in my house, and probably never will, so I probably qualify as some kind of techno-skeptic.
- hinkley 7y agoI know more than a couple of older people who can still hear very high pitched whines from electrical equipment. The “only children and dogs” is some bad statistics. Also houses have dogs or kids. Or both. It’s a thing.
- xzel 7y agoI’m a bit older than average and these types of things and noises drive me crazy. I can’t even be near some old CRT screens due to the pitch they emit (especially bad with old CCTV monitors).
- hinkley 7y agoI may have lost a little at the high end or electronics have gotten better filters, but I used to grumpily stomp into the next room to turn off the tv or the VCR because it was bugging me. There was a story a few years back about stores getting rid of young loiterers by playing these tones, then later on kids setting ringtones or alerts on their phones so that the teacher wouldn’t get mad that their phones were on. Guess what? A lot of surprised 15 year olds had their phones confiscated by disgruntled 40 year old teachers who could damn well hear the ringtones.
- JonathonW 7y agoThe TV noise you used to hear is gone because CRTs are gone-- it comes from the flyback tranformer in the TV, which had a propensity to resonate at the TV's horizontal scanning frequency (somewhere in the ballpark of 15.7 kHz, the exact frequency depending on whether your TV was NTSC or PAL). I had a "I haven't heard that in ages" moment over the summer; was in some shop in the UK that had a CRT showing their CCTV cameras and could hear the thing well before I could see it. Apparently my high-end hearing's still decent.
- andrewzah 7y agoCRTs are almost gone; they’re still highly sought after in the smashbros community. :-) IIRC trinitrons are the most highly desired. Due to the shortage, a "crt vault" was created. [0] I remember visiting multiple thrift stores ~2 years ago to collect them. The most I had was 6 I think, but I ended up giving them to other players. Here's an example of what they look like at tournaments [1] [0]: https://old.reddit.com/r/smashbros/comments/3dzqd9/to_those_who_enjoyed_smash_at_evo_please_thank/ https://old.reddit.com/r/smashbros/comments/3dzqd9/to_those_... [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j_WBBeXzUcQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j_WBBeXzUcQ
- spats1990 7y agoThe other day my dad, who turned 60 last year, swore he couldn't hear a cicada that was right outside the open window. It bugged him so much he made me go outside with him and point out the cicada. I told him about the mosquito tone, which is obviously much higher, and how mostly only younger people are meant to be able to hear it and played it for him off Wikipedia. He could hear it fine and so could I (30 this year). To hell with the mosquito tone as an anti-loitering device, it's horrible.
- Freak_NL 7y agoLike those high-pitched 'mosquito'-devices installed in places where young people tend to hang out; most adults over 25 can't hear them at all. There is a school here with an apparently inviting set of steps under an awning that activates this device outside of school hours. Passing that building is really annoying. I'm 39.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- StavrosK 7y agoOh God, I saw one of those in Japan outside a store at night, we came near it and I went "what the hell is that noise?", but none of my friends could hear anything. Turned out to be the mosquito thing, which was quite effective in getting me away from that shop. I was 35 at the time and my friends were 30ish, I guess it varies by person.
- bencollier49 7y agoIt's the babies brought into the shops by their oblivious parents that I feel sorry for. Mosquito devices ought to be illegal, it's noise pollution.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- EliRivers 7y agoI used to be able to hear monitors whine and I'd have to unplug them completely. Can't anymore; I thought it was because I was getting older and my hearing at the higher frequencies was dropping off. Still got one of the monitors I used to be able to hear whine and I can't hear it anymore. Seems odd that there are older people who can hear the high-pitches when younger people can't. Maybe the kids are tuning it out.
- kranner 7y ago> Full disclosure: I don't have any always-on microphones in my house Does this include smartphones, computers, or other such devices capable of becoming always-on microphones in software?
- agildehaus 7y ago> I don't have any always-on microphones in my house, and probably never will, so I probably qualify as some kind of techno-skeptic. That you know of. Every smartphone has a microphone, as do most laptops and desktops.
- h4waii 7y agoThat you know of also ;) Many privacy-concious people opt for software that allows them to verifiably control their hardware, be it desktop/laptop or smartphone. Some will go the extra step to physically remove or disable microphones and speakers.
- drewbug 7y agoverifiably?
- saagarjha 7y ago> Many privacy-concious people opt for software that allows them to verifiably control their hardware, be it desktop/laptop or smartphone. I know a fair number of privacy-concious people, and not one of them have any sort of verifiable control of their hardware. It's surprisingly hard to do this, it turns out…
- endless1234 7y agoIt's an one off art project, not an actual product they're aiming to start selling. Of course it's a "gimmick", that's not the point.
- dijksterhuis 7y agoDolphin Attack used ultrasonic amplitude modulation against a variety of devices with some success [0]. Page 9 for the results table. I believe they were taking advantage of the non linearity of microphones. 0: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1708.09537.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1708.09537.pdf
- endorphone 7y agoI suspect that it would only work against MEMS microphones. Normal "analog" magnetic microphones physically filter high frequency noise.
- justinjlynn 7y agoYikes, please don't do or encourage using these in public - there are many accessibility devices (hearing aids, cochlear implants, etc.) which depend on MEMS microphones to function. You could inadvertently make the world much worse for people who already have a difficult time of things. Imagine carting a cellular and WiFi and bluetooth jammer around outside of a Faraday cage - it's insanely irresponsible and inconsiderate.
- btbuildem 7y ago> Imagine carting a cellular and WiFi and bluetooth jammer around outside of a Faraday cage - it's insanely irresponsible and inconsiderate. Really? Causing temporary, localized connectivity outages, that's an inconvenience at best.
- kekebo 7y agoIt's also illegal in a lot of countries.
- closetohome 7y agoYes, blocking 911 calls is inconsiderate.
- paxys 7y ago> it's insanely irresponsible and inconsiderate It would also be incredibly illegal
- Freak_NL 7y agoAlso tempting. This is probably something that should be tested against. Critical systems should be able to handle connection loss, and society should be able to deal with situations where no cell signals are available with no more than a shrug. Anything that fails miserably because of some joker jamming signals is a liability.
- justinjlynn 7y ago
- fxtentacle 7y agoIf this actually works, then the Alexa engineers forgot to add an analog pre-filter to their ADC. And most likely, adding digital filtering through one of those horrible unsupervised software updates will also circumvent it. Plus I'd say they chose by far the easiest target. A squirrel's sneezing is enough to confuse Alexa beyond recognition. In my personal experience, the Google and Baidu speech to text algorithms are much more resilient against background noise.
- Traster 7y agoI'm not so sure, a reasonable low pass filter is probably not going to very aggressively attenuate 25kHz, so you can be pretty confident that pumping at a very loud 25kHz tone will screw up the mic. Remember, once the microphone is clipping the job is done - you're not going to recover the signal, so it'd be very hard to recover using digital filtering after the ADC.
- mrob 7y ago>once the microphone is clipping the job is done Try adding a loud ultrasonic sine wave to speech in your favorite audio editor, and then hard clip it. Most of the distortion can be filtered out without too much damage to the speech by looking at the spectrogram and notch filtering unwanted frequencies. I imagine modern AI could do the same thing automatically. But high-pass filtered white noise + clipping will make the speech unrecoverable if it's loud enough.
- dijksterhuis 7y agoThen it’s possible to use Adversarial Examples to get around any AI implementation. Turns into more cat and mouse at the end of the day.
- Anarch157a 7y agoIn my conspiracy theorist opinion, they didn't forget. They left it out on purpose, so the mic can detect ultrasound embeded on tv transmissions to track which tv shows and comercials you're watching[0]. [0]https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/11/beware-of-ads-that-use-inaudible-sound-to-link-your-phone-tv-tablet-and-pc/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/11/beware-of-ads-th...
- unnouinceput 7y agoWalls and ladders, nothing more. Pretty sure a bigger ladder will be discovered very soon following this
- eyegor 7y agoNah, it's physically jamming the spectrum. Unless someone can come up with a microphone that only resonates in the audible range, this technique will always work. It's akin to pointing a really bright light at a camera.
- unnouinceput 7y agoWhile really white bright will jam your eyes too, an ultrasound will not jam your ear, hence this is actually easier to overcome. Just use dumb microphone, that will cut frequencies over 10Kz and have the unintended secondary effect that Alexa will be even cheaper.
- Alpesh5757 7y agohttps://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1228948305326948353.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1228948305326948353.html
- _-___________-_ 7y agoWhy not just have similar device adjacent to the device that you're worried might eavesdrop on you?
- DyslexicAtheist 7y agowhy not have any eavesdropping devices in the first place. when somebody invites me around, I usually ask if they own one of these things and I regretfully decline the offer if that's the case and instead invite them to my home.
- _-___________-_ 7y agoyeah I agree. my question was, more completely, "if you have one of these things, why carry the countermeasure around instead of putting it next to the device?"
- DyslexicAtheist 7y agogotcha! that would make more sense yeah. Maybe they trying to pitch it as a fashion thing - like a social/personal statement. All these mitigations seems strange to me since mitigations are always an attack surface too.
- eyegor 7y agoMost people own smartphones these days, which will also record and analyze everything they can hear.
- _-___________-_ 7y ago> which will also record and analyze everything they can hear Do you have a source for that blanket statement?
- nico_h 7y agoI can’t figure out why we are not switching to active listening devices , star trek badge style instead of enduring this permanent surveillance thing. We’re reaching the point where it becomes feasible in terms of electronics density and battery efficiency.
- ghaff 7y agoThat's sort of what an Apple Watch is, isn't it? You have to press the button to activate Siri.
- archi42 7y agoThis only fights a symptom, the real problem is that these smart assistants need to stream the input to a company. Of course I understand that this allows for better recognition, but while I personally would like to have a well-working voice assistant, I personally do not want to have someone else (potentially) listening in on me (if others care less, that's perfectly fine). Maybe I'll find some time to setup a self-hosted voice assistant. Recommendations?
- diamondo25 7y agoGet a human, like a maid?
- dijksterhuis 7y agoMycroft turned up on HN a while back [0]. Think there’s another one that was posted in the last few months, but can’t find the link. Pretty sure you can hook it up to Mozilla DeepSpeech for completely offline stuff. 0: https://mycroft-ai.gitbook.io/docs/ https://mycroft-ai.gitbook.io/docs/
- dillonmckay 7y agoIs Mycroft self-hosted? It seems like you have to register to create an account? There is also a ‘skills’ marketplace, so not sure how private it is.
- dijksterhuis 7y agoCan run in a docker container, on Linux etc etc. You do need to pair it with an account to activate basic skills, but: > By default, Mycroft will not store your usage data or keep any recordings of your voice https://mycroft-ai.gitbook.io/docs/using-mycroft-ai/pairing-your-device https://mycroft-ai.gitbook.io/docs/using-mycroft-ai/pairing-...
- dillonmckay 7y agoSo, why is that part not self-hosted?
- ThePhysicist 7y agoThis is a cool and super creative project, but I think the simpler solution would be to not buy a device that listens to all of your conversations at home, or at least switch it off when not needed. And if you're exposed to such a device as a guest in someone else's home or office, kindly ask the owner to switch it off and explain why you think it's not good to have such a device listening to all conversations you're having. It would also not be so hard to make such devices more privacy-friendly e.g. by giving users are clearer indication of when they're listening to you and when they transfers data to the cloud. I think Amazon already allows you to review and download all audio conversations they have from you (in theory this is mandatory in the EU).
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoEvery phone has a microphone, and it too is always on. Are you going to ask everyone to turn off their phone?
- Thriptic 7y agoThis is what I don't understand. Everyone runs around terrified of these smart speakers but have no problem talking around their phones which have mics, their computers which have mics, other devices which have mics, CCTV cameras which are ubiquitous, etc Do people realistically think attackers are going to start burning zero days against these things to listen to the average Joe's kitchen conversations or bedroom chatter? What is the threat model here?
- ThePhysicist 7y agoYou confuse privacy with security I think. Smart home assistants might be secure but they are not privacy-friendly, that's a difference.
- Thriptic 7y agoI follow, but what exactly is the real privacy threat here? If we look at an echo for instance: * The device is hardwired to light up whenever it is listening so you can't be eavesdropped on without some indicator. * The device only transmits when it is in listening mode. This has been validated independently by multiple people. * The device has a mute function (granted, software). * The device can be registered under a bogus account. * You can turn off all phone call capabilities / external listening capabilities. * You can pihole it so it won't reach back to Amazon's ad services. * You can delete any conversation you don't want stored manually, including one click deleting your entire history. * You can have all content automatically deleted after X days. So what exactly are people concerned about? Out of all the convos someone could have, a negative one just happens to probabilistically be recorded, you don't notice, and within 90 days someone in law enforcement or entity X figures it out and uses it against you? Someone at Amazon decides to look through your stored conversations and sees you turn on the lights at 5 PM each day? I'm not saying there are 0 privacy implications with this device, as any device that has a mic and can record remotely has privacy implications. I just feel like the level of angst generated by smart speakers isn't warranted in the grander scheme of things.
- steventhedev 7y agoHow is this not filtered out by a lowpass filter? Wouldn't this only block the ultrasonic beeps they embed in ads?
- QuarterDuplex 7y agoAssuming you mean a digital lowpass filter; this won't work. The ultrasonic input is saturating the microphone. In this situation, no amount of digital filters can recover the desired signal (the speech). If there was a physical low pass filter (not sure if these exist) that was placed over the microphone, that would work
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- znpy 7y agoSo now One has to opt out from being spied upon, and wear a piece of hardware too?
- bitcurious 7y agoThis sounds like a device designed to torture animals. If someone brought this into my house and turned it on around my dog I would probably ask them to leave.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 7y agoLikewise. And I am sympathetic to the idea, but this is the wrong way to go about it. Too many innocent bystanders. It does reignite the debate over what is acceptable. Cost of putting microphone in anything is negligible. Connection to internet in many things is assumed so even if microphone is unused, it could be turned on with an update. Then again, my social circle met yesterday and they have multiple devices controlled by voice. It didn't stop anyone from saying things that would not look good if broadcast in public. It is weird, how easy it is to forget about it. Probably because you think it is your space. I would not dream of messing with their devices. I am a guest. I opted to be there. I tried to think about it rationally. I can't give them too much shit. Between me and my wife, we have 8 devices in house now that have microphones and/or cameras in. Ok google is off. Siri is off on phone, but on watch it is activated by a button, so there is semblance of control.
- Havoc 7y ago>The sound is imperceptible to most ears, with the possible exception of young people and dogs That seems pretty cruel
- jonny383 7y agoThe fact that this article exists actually makes me sad. When did we as a society give up our privacy for such a small amount of convenience? Or has it been gradually chipped away until we have reached this point? I feel sorry for my children and the future in which they are going to live in. I also feel a sense of shame for participating in a society that has normalised these things. Sorry kids. We got greedy. We boiled the planet and normalised blanket spying for profits.
- wodenokoto 7y ago“Privacy is a currency for which you do not know the exchange rate” Read it on a Mozilla blog a few years ago and I think they quoted it too from somewhere else. But I feel like it sums the whole thing up nicely. For many, it does not feel like somebody is watching us. Just that data about us is dumped in a huge archive too vast for anyone to dig around in. This (Wrong) sentiment makes many assume that the currency is probably cheap.
- Tijdreiziger 7y agoWhy is this sentiment wrong?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gtfratteus 7y agoThat didn't answer the question at all.
- wodenokoto 7y agoBecause data is not too vast to be mined
- discordianfish 7y agoThe fact that this article exists actually makes me sad as well. But because Alexa isn't eavesdropping on us and believing this is the tech equivalent of antivaxxers: "If you don't believe it, you're part of the conspiracy"
- BiteCode_dev 7y agoIs it just me or the article has been taken down ?
- ronyfadel 7y agoJust you
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI could see this being used in e.g. the white house, just in case a foreign adversary has somehow managed to slip a bug in there. Or maybe because the president insists on using an unsecured Android phone.
- tareqak 7y agoI am interested in the Reflectacles, but I’ve already bought glasses this year. Is there a way to coat / paint an existing glasses frame with a material that would interfere with IR cameras and visible light cameras?
- eyegor 7y agoLink to the actual work: http://sandlab.cs.uchicago.edu/jammer/ http://sandlab.cs.uchicago.edu/jammer/
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]