7 ms·
It's funny because I think this is true of most online communities I've joined. People will say on here things like "HN has changed now that its big" or "HN is
by giancarlostoro 7y ago
It's funny because I think this is true of most online communities I've joined. People will say on here things like "HN has changed now that its big" or "HN is not how it used to be", and I'm sure some would say the same of 4chan as well, and reddit, and probably even Facebook.
- prepend 7y ago4chan was once pretty funny. I remember when they did fun things like hack Time polls [0] before they got too big and went off the rails. [0] https://techcrunch.com/2009/04/27/time-magazine-throws-up-its-hands-as-it-gets-pwned-by-4chan/ https://techcrunch.com/2009/04/27/time-magazine-throws-up-it...
- giancarlostoro 7y agoThis was around the time I left 4chan, when the gore stuff got out of control. The snuff films were being posted and other nasty things.
- iso1631 7y agoUsenet never survived Eternal September https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoNo, it never survived the late 90's campaigns against the RIAA trying to stop piracy at the ISP level. Thats when all the big ISPs yanked support, especially after alt.binaries was sharing damn near everything. And they were big bandwidth sinks due to the distributed model usenet has, so it was easy for ISPs to yank the carpet and look at the immediate gains.
- ape4 7y agoYeah, no binaries would be a start for a new Usenet
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoThe problem is that binaries are transferred in a non-binary manner. Base64 was the preferred way. Except it was also used to push images back and forth as well for pertinent conversations. For any method of communication, you can transfer content that someone else tries to prevent.
- chalst 7y agoUpper bounds on per-user bandwidth would work. Implementing this is nontrivial, but it's an essentially easier problem than spam.
- kick 7y agoWho cares about piracy? It exists over HTTP, too, and in a far greater volume than a modern USENET-equivalent could ever hope to achieve, and it's not like ISPs need to be sucked up to anymore: they've already taken their ball and went home on this matter, proverbially-speaking.
- shadowgovt 7y agoUpper bounds on per-user bandwidth would help. Though for significant messages, one still has sock-puppet accounts (or aggregates of like-minded individuals with copies of the source message pooling their resources). And, of course, upper bounds create knock-on restrictions (should the system be allowed to transmit public-domain large-volume data? A bandwidth limit blocks that "valid" use too). It's fun to game-theory how such limits can be broken.
- ape4 7y agoThey were uuencoded. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uuencoding https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uuencoding
- 7y ago
- ajross 7y agoYeah, exactly. I worked for a small employer in the early mid-90's who maintained a NNTP feed (and had for years), and ultimately had to shut it down because it had basically become a giant unmanageable firehose of porn and piracy. The actual human-written text content had dropped down to the 1% level or worse. Usenet died for the same reason Facebook won: people exploit "free" forums in ways that ruin the experience. It's simply not possible to have an unmoderated discussion environment in an unrestricted internet, which is why we're having this discussion on a moderated site.
- chungus_khan 7y agoMy ISP still includes Usenet, which is pretty cool.
- Melting_Harps 7y agoWho do you use? I had Cox because they were the only one left offering usenet (albeit capped). I was a really late adopter to torrents because of my background in usenet, sometime around 2010 all the alt.binaries I used to frequent went dead or were broken with little par2 support. It was a great time back in the early 2000s, though. If I'm honest, I don't download as much as I used to, but I do miss the niche communities based on those groups, though. They have since moved to IRC but for the most part its all gone from what I can tell.
- chungus_khan 7y agoCogeco in my case. No cap either, which is pretty cool. Those little niche communities on usenet were what originally got me so excited about the internet. Both participating in ones that interested me and just exploring all sorts of interesting little communities.
- cat199 7y agomany interesting usenet groups were long dead before that due to spam... the things you mention are more like pulling life support than the cause of death
- takeda 7y agoSpam started when Google acquired DejaNews renamed it to Google Groups, and have Usenet access to everyone without responding to any abuse complaints.
- iso1631 7y agoNot sure, wiki puts that as 2001, and I remember being annoyed with spam in the 90s. I think the rise of web-based forums is what killed off usenet as a general tool.
- kps 7y agoUsenet spam started in 1994, before DejaNews existed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laurence_Canter_and_Martha_Siegel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laurence_Canter_and_Martha_Sie...
- webmaven 7y agoThat's a bit ahistorical. The "September that never ended"[0] (aka "Eternal September") was in 1993, the Canter and Siegel Usenet spam[1] was sent the following April. The DejaNews acquisition[2] wan't until 2001. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laurence_Canter_and_Martha_Siegel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laurence_Canter_and_Martha_Sie... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Groups https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Groups
- dspillett 7y ago> RIAA ... especially after alt.binaries was sharing damn near everything While this didn't help, I don't think it was a key factor for ISPs. Most ISP NNTP services didn't carry binary groups anyway for bandwidth cost reasons. There were some issues with groups that linked to where to find copyright covered material, but the RIAA and their ilk were going more for the direct sources at the time. The public list/pointer resources were actually useful to them as lists of places to chase down. Of course this led to people paying for external NNTP services which did carry the binaries groups. These services were obvious targets for the RIAA and other such groups unlike the ISPs. > they were big bandwidth sinks due to the distributed model usenet has This was a far more important reason, even without carrying binaries groups Usenet could consume a large amount of bandwidth. As well as the incoming load, and the bandwidth used sending data to clients, back then modem access was common and NNTP lead to people leaving the line open to download a huge pile of stuff (most of which they'd discard without reading anyway) meaning ISPs would have to invest in more modem racks, impose unpopular limits, or be perpetually busy, any of which would lose them custom. Another significant issue was the cost of building and maintaining the servers required too. To run an NNTP service for a noticeable amount of users with reasonable performance you needed an arrangement with impressive IO performance stats for the time, and the access patterns (constant & random) could be murderous to the drives, sometimes chewing through them as fast as they could be replaced.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoUsenet wasn't dependent on binaries groups in the 90's. There was plenty of active discourse. Non-commercial hosts could easily drop binary groups. Commercial providers were the ones stuck in a bind. The massive cross-posting of troll threads in the late 90's is what helped kill it off. The lack of effective moderation controls is the biggest weakness of Usenet.
- u801e 7y agoThere are a number of free text only usenet providers out there. Why couldn't the ISPs simply stop carrying the binary groups instead of discontinuing their usenet service entirely?
- pwg 7y agoI don't think the RIAA's efforts had much effect on Usenet, since in that time-frame the RIAA all but ignored Usenet. They were much more in shock-and-awe over Gnutella (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gnutella https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gnutella) at the time. What I think led to the decline was at least a combination of: 1) an overrun of SPAM - Usenet was first to be hit by the spam flood, email SPAM came later as Usenet usage died off. 2) the 'newness' factor and the 'new shiny object' factor of the web drew away existing users, and resulted in new users never joining (i.e., pictures, fancy formatting, etc. all made plain text character Usenet posts look "old-fashioned"). And once you have a situation where new users don't join, and some number of existing users continue to depart, you are on a downward slope to disappearance. Both of the above helped contribute to ISP's dropping NNTP service. Bandwidth costs for #1 (plus bandwidth if they were carrying alt.binaries.*) and a drop in NNTP usage due to #2. They (ISPs) no longer saw offering NNTP as a sales factor for obtaining subscribers, and once NNTP was no longer a "hook" to bring in subscribers, it was only a matter of time before they decided to just drop it entirely. And of course ISP's dropping NNTP accelerated the issues around #2 above.
- u801e 7y agoAnother reason was due to the actions of former New York attorney general Andrew Cuomo in 2008 where he got several major ISPs to block access to Usenet newsgroups that were used to distribute child pornography[1]. IIRC, those ISPs discontinued Usenet service not too long after that. [1] https://www.cnet.com/news/n-y-attorney-general-forces-isps-to-curb-usenet-access/ https://www.cnet.com/news/n-y-attorney-general-forces-isps-t...
- gspr 7y agoIs perhaps the article author's name – October First – a reference to Eternal September? :-)
- inviromentalist 7y agoThe cycle- >New users, new ideas. > Mods ban these new ideas because they don't comply with existing culture > Mods get heavy with their justice >Core users are mistaken for newbies, and face mod wrath > Core users migrate to new websites Guess where HN is on this timeline
- microcolonel 7y agoHN is kinda dying as a community, though moderation isn't the whole story. There are also some long-standing bugs, and misbehaviours of the voting system. Being able to downvote replies without any refutation, to me, seems like a massive mistake; it just teaches people not to say anything interesting, because they won't get a response anyway, even when they're wrong in a subtle or interesting way. The formatting available to users is maybe close to the right amount, but the implementation is broken (for example, it doesn't end URLs when it sees >, so you end up with broken URLs when you go out of your way to protect them). It could probably also do with proper first-class block quotations, people end up putting them in <pre> blocks or italics, and it's not always clear.
- 300bps 7y agoHN is kinda dying as a community As someone who’s been on HN for about 9 years, it’s funny to read this. I don’t see how it’s gotten any worse during my time here. I think HN’s community is fantastic but you either get it or you don’t. I really enjoy the signal to noise ratio and I’m happy that silly comments and jokes are downvoted or moderated. I read HN with showdead on and personally I think the moderation is spot-on.
- microcolonel 7y agoI get HN's community, and I enjoy it. That said, I often think twice about posting anything meaningful; I know I'll get a bit frustrated when I put myself out there in good faith, and people have nothing to say, but downvote anyway. I know that some very bright and lovely people have been totally turned off of the place by this, and this behaviour of the system doesn't really help anything. > I read HN with showdead on and personally I think the moderation is spot-on. I too use showdead, I think the moderation is generally good (though I think at times I've been handled somewhat unfairly). The times when there's a dead post that I don't think should be dead, it's usually from a person who has worn out his welcome with other comments. This is why I say moderation isn't the main problem, contrary to the parent reply.