12 ms·
If you’re wondering about how common this should be: if schizophrenia occurs at a rate of 0.72% in the population (McGrath et al., 2008) and congenital blindne
by Retric 7y ago
If you’re wondering about how common this should be:
if schizophrenia occurs at a rate of 0.72% in the population (McGrath et al., 2008) and congenital blindness occurs at an estimated rate of 0.03% in people born in the 1970s and 1980s (based on Robinson et al., 1987), then the joint probability of a person having both conditions, if the two are independent, would be 0.02% or 2 out of every 10,000. Although this is a low prevalence rate, it is higher than the rates for childhood-onset schizophrenia (Remschmidt and Theisen, 2005), and many other well-known medical conditions (e.g., Hodgkin's lymphoma, Prader Willi syndrome, Rett's Syndome). Based on this estimated prevalence rate, in the United States alone (with a population of 311, 591, 917, as of July 2011, according the US census), there should be approximately 620 congenitally blind people with schizophrenia. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3615184/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3615184/
That does do rule out misdiagnosis etc, but it does seem to support a correlation.
- ocfnash 7y agoJust a moment, 0.72% x 0.03% = 0.0002%, which is about 2 out every 1,000,000.
- ChrisRR 7y agoSo even then, 600 people in the US should be both born blind and scizophrenic
- giancarlostoro 7y agoThat isn't a guarantee that 600 people will be born with both.
- ehsankia 7y agoObviously there's no guarantee, and there's also the fact that we may not have every case documented, but if it is true that we have 0 case documented, that's pretty far from 600. Even if it's not "impossible", then at the very least it's less likely.
- luc4sdreyer 7y agoIt's a simple binomial probability calculation. The probability of one or more blind schizophrenic people born in the US, assuming they're independent variables, is 1-0,999998^330000000. I don't have a calculator on hand that can calculate that, but it's more than 1 - 10^-87. So the odds that there is no link between the two is close to the odds of guessing a specific bitcoin wallet's key in one try.
- harryh 7y agoWowsers! That's quite the elementary math mistake in a journal article. I'm tempted to track down the authors and point this out to them.
- dooglius 7y agoOr the journal editor, you definitely should. This is the kind of thing that can easily get cited in future work on the matter.
- glofish 7y agoit is probably not a math mistake since, when they applied the probability the 620 people is correct. Might be a typesetting (formatting) mistake. The 0.0002 is already a percent, but someone overlooked that and turned it again into percent. Still it should definitely be corrected as the 2 out of 10,000 is a value that sticks in the mind.
- mennis16 7y agoThey also used the 2 in 10,000 figure when picking out the comparison syndromes. I believe Retts is ~1 in 10,000. It's definitely not 1 in a million.
- HourglassFR 7y agoMy guess is the editor somehow messed up the per thousand sign ‱ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basis_point https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basis_point edit: My bad. Correct character, incorrect description. It is indeed "ten thousand".
- jfk13 7y agoSomewhat ironically, I think you're off by one character here. Unicode U+2031 ‱ is actually the per ten thousand sign (check its character name). Unicode U+2030 ‰ is the per thousand (or "per mille") sign.
- primo4444 7y agoNo, the .02 is correct. If you ignore the percentages part (since both left and right side use it), you're doing 0.72 x 0.03, which is indeed 0.02 If you do it as probabilities not expressed as percentages, it's 0.0072 x 0.0003, which is 0.0002, but that's 0.02%
- rlpb 7y agoYou can't just ignore the percentage signs. 0.72% expressed as a decimal is 0.0072. 0.03% expressed as a decimal is 0.0003. 0.0072 x 0.0003 = 0.000002. Expressed back as a percentage, that's 0.0002%.
- gus_massa 7y ago> it's 0.0072 x 0.0003, which is 0.0002, but that's 0.02% No. 0.0072 x 0.0003 = 0.00000216 ~= 0.000002 = 0.0002%
- primo4444 7y agoYou're right. Not sure how I fell into that trap so easily.
- injb 7y agoI wonder if it's better to treat percentage as a unit or variable. So a-percent x b-percent = c(percent-squared), or c divided by 100 twice.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- petrogradphilos 7y agoYou could also replace % with 10⁻² and use scientific notation: 0.72% ⋅ 0.03% = 0.72 ⋅ 10⁻² ⋅ 0.03 ⋅ 10⁻² = 7.2 ⋅ 10⁻³ ⋅ 3 ⋅ 10⁻⁴ = 7.2 ⋅ 3 ⋅ 10⁻³ ⋅ 10⁻⁴ = 21.6 ⋅ 10⁻⁷ = 2.16 ⋅ 10⁻⁶ ≈ 2 in 1 million
- 7y ago
- anordin95 7y agoTo be fair, it appears they fixed the math later, or at least roughly. (2 out of every 1M) x (the US population) [they cite ~311M]. That gives 622. Not far off the 620 they report in your quote.
- petrogradphilos 7y agoThis is like having a weighted coin that comes up heads with probability 2⋅10⁻⁶, flipping it 311 million times, and seeing 0 heads. That's astronomically unlikely. To see this, observe that the number of heads follows a binomial distribution with n = 311 million and p = 2⋅10⁻⁶. This can be well approximated¹ by a normal distribution with mean μ = np = 622 and standard deviation σ = Sqrt[np(1 - p)] = 25. 99.7% of the time², when you sample from this distribution, the sampled value will be within 3 standard deviations of the mean, i.e., between μ - 3σ = 547 and μ + 3σ = 697. Results further from the mean are more unlikely. For example, seeing a value more than 7 standard deviations from the mean (i.e., less than 447 or more than 797) is about a 1 in 2 trillion event³. Since 0 is about 25 standard deviations from the mean, the probability of seeing 0 heads is on the order of 10⁻¹³⁸. [1] https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/2021801/conditions-needed-to-approximate-a-binomial-distribution-using-a-normal-distribu https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/2021801/conditions-... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/68–95–99.7_rule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/68–95–99.7_rule [3] https://www.johndcook.com/blog/table-of-normal-tail-probabilities/ https://www.johndcook.com/blog/table-of-normal-tail-probabil...
- paulmd 7y ago> This is like having a weighted coin Tangent: there is no such thing. You can weight a die, you cannot weight a coin. Intuitively this should make sense because even if you made one side of the coin from lead and the other from balsa wood, all you are doing is changing the center of gravity of the coin. The coin spins about its center of gravity, not the geometric center of the coin, so this makes no difference. https://www.stat.berkeley.edu/~nolan/Papers/dice.pdf https://www.stat.berkeley.edu/~nolan/Papers/dice.pdf
- 7y ago
- dooglius 7y agoDid you mean "does not rule out misdiagnosis"? Going further than misdiagnosis, how many congenitally blind people are even tested for schizophrenia? Maybe lack of visual hallucinations make it less likely someone would get to the point of a test at all?
- bildung 7y ago> Maybe lack of visual hallucinations make it less likely someone would get to the point of a test at all? (I am not a psychologist!) Visual hallucinations are not a hard criterion for diagnosing schizophrenia. They do occur, but the symptoms are more about delusions, disorganised thinking and catatonic symptoms. IIRC hallucinations are more often auditory, like hearing voices.
- dooglius 7y agoI know, that's not my point, I'm saying the barrier may be that a blind schizophrenic person may not even be aware that there's anything seriously wrong or worth bringing to a doctor's attention, so he would never get to the point of a psych evaluation.
- bildung 7y agoThen by definition they wouldn't be mentally ill, as mental disorders have to cause significant distress for the patients to be diagnosed as such.
- jacobush 7y agoIt can be distress which is missed by the doctor. I think it's far more acceptable for us to "mishear" something and think nothing of it. The seeing also have the backup sense, sight to verify much of what we hear. "I heard the sound of an elephant stomping around in my living room." This statement made by a seeing person could be made by nobody thinking much of it. I wouldn't immediately ask if they actually thought an elephant were in the living room at the time. The same statement made by a (blind) schizophrenic person could have implied that the person actually believed there was an elephant in the living room, but the clinician might have missed the significance and not asked follow up questions. A bit of a contrived example, but you get the gist. To a seeing person it might
- pelliphant 7y agowait... is this math error in the actual article? or just in the vice text?
- throwawayhhakdl 7y agoI don’t know if I believe that 3 / 10,000 people are born blind, in addition to the arithmetic errors
- candiodari 7y agoI seem to be missing what to anyone who's ever had to deal with youth services is the obvious alternative: Schizophrenia, like almost all diagnosed psychological disorders, is called a diagnosis, but is effectively a punishment. Psychiatrists feel sorry for blind patients and refuse to apply this punishment to them, for the same reason they wouldn't punish them for performing a little worse at basketball.
- DangitBobby 7y agoWhat do you mean it's a punishment?
- soup10 7y agoSchizophrenia diagnoses are generally applied to individuals with a mix of behavioral problems and "abnormal or undesirable" thought patterns. It's a broad brush that isn't applied based on hard biological data like an MRI of the brain, but on observed and reported behavior at the discretion of the psychiatrist and rough adherence to DSM guidelines. Typical treatments like Haldol, Thorazine, and Depakote have a blunting and depressive effect on the entire central nervous system. Treatments like shock therapy, cause severe memory loss and permanent brain damage. These "treatments" are often paired with coercion, involuntary injections, confinement in psych wards, and court orders. Many times LE will bring a civilian to a psych ward as a secondary or additional option to charging them with a crime. It's often seen as an additional tool in creating orderly communities, disciplining individuals that get out of line, and overall exerting control on society and free thought and action. Once a patient is admitted or diagnosed, they are strongly incentivized to align themselves and their behaviors to the values and expectations of the institutions and people that brought them there and control their release and treatment plans. Even if schizophrenia had a biological signature it wouldn't be used in practice because they WANT the ambiguity and discretion to classify and medicate patients as they see fit.
- dsego 7y agoDo you have a diagnosis or have anyone in you family with this debilitating disease? Where do you find the nerve to post such misinformation as this? From personal experience, my family member who suffers from this condition has been hospitalized several times in psychosis and every time he comes out he is glad and happy that it's over and he is back to his normal self. The pharmacological therapy has horrible side effects but spreading FUD like this is way over the line. You also only list the older generation of medication, there are many new ones with less side-effects. Learn a bit a about the alternatives, the neurotoxic degenerative effects of the disease and the prognosis without treatment. With every new psychotic event there is less chance of getting the person back. And, yes they do MRIs and there are visible changes in the structure.
- prostheticvamp 7y agoJust so we are clear: the approach taken in the studies described is “we looked at a bunch of blind people and couldn’t find a schizophrenic”, and “we looked at a bunch of schizophrenics and couldn’t find a blind person.” The appropriate question is: can such an approach, in a wildly fractured series of data sets, overlook 600 people?
- Uhhrrr 7y agoIt sure can, but the odds are against it overlooking all of them. Of course, maybe the genes leading to blindness and schizophrenia together also lead to some other defect that results in miscarriage or some other kind of early death.
- ajross 7y agoTo be clear: the odds are against it assuming no confounding interference. And given that, I don't know that an error of 600 is really that much of a statement. I mean, just to invent an example (not the only possible one, obviously!): Congenital blindness is likely diagnosed with near 100% certainty in early childhood. It's easy to spot. The same is very much NOT true of mental health problems. Schisophrenics are diagnosed, almost always, when their condition manifests in such a way to interfere with their life (or someone else's) to the extent that the doctors get called in. There are widely assumed to be LOTS of undiagnosed mental health cases in society, simply because the sufferers live in situations where their disorder can be managed (or suppressed!) in an ad hoc way. Now, the question becomes: are blind people more likely to be living in a circumstance where their mental health troubles are more easily managed/ignored/suppressed without the involvement of doctors who would otherwise diagnose schizophrenia? That seems not at all unlikely to me. And frankly: this kind of confounded measurement strikes me as MUCH MORE likely than a heretofore unrecognized link between vision and schizophrenia. Significant results require significant proof, and I don't think this is it.
- sophacles 7y agoThere are other links between vision and schizophrenia - e.g. https://www.wired.com/2009/04/schizoillusion/ https://www.wired.com/2009/04/schizoillusion/ (although that may better be described as a link between visual processing and schizophrenia. vision -> visual processing is a fairly well accepted link however, so vision -> visual processing -> schizophrenia seems plausible enough to look at a bit more.)
- screye 7y agoWith odds like that, they would have to sample a much larger population directly for the results to be statistically significant.
- listsfrin 7y ago> population of 311, 591, 917, Is this a thing? People write numbers like that?
- billforsternz 7y agoI found the absurd over-precision more problematic. There probably were exactly that many people in the USA at some instant in time in this century. For a minute or two at most. 310 million is a more sensible way to report the population.
- rhacker 7y agoI wonder if there's no genetic correlation, but rather a brain input correlation. There is more brain input from vision than any other input possible. Since the brain is mostly a device that builds connections based on prior input, a condition like schiz may not develop simply because of the type and amount of data going in may not be enough to trigger the autistic, multiple personalities, and other depression related conditions.
- jdironman 7y agoThen we should be looking at the occipital lobe, no?
- lucideer 7y ago> There is more brain input from vision than any other input possible Is this really true? I would've imagined it to be hearing, though tbh I'm unsure how one would begin to approach measuring them in isolation.
- sitharus 7y agoYou have, at birth, around 3,500 auditory hair cells per ear (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hair_cell https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hair_cell), so 7000 inputs to process for sound. Sure your brain does a lot with that information to project a 3D sound field from two ears, but that's the limit of the input. The adult human eye has around 70 million cones and 75-150 million rods (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retina https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retina). There's a bit of crazy data compression that goes in to this, but the amount of information to process from the eyes is several orders of magnitude greater than from the years.
- jxramos 7y agonice technique to focus on the raw transducers/sensory cells counts! That's fundamentally the raw inputs we're dealing with.
- nordsieck 7y ago> You have, at birth, around 3,500 auditory hair cells per ear (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hair_cell https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hair_cell), so 7000 inputs to process for sound. Sure your brain does a lot with that information to project a 3D sound field from two ears, but that's the limit of the input. > The adult human eye has around 70 million cones and 75-150 million rods (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retina https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retina). There's a bit of crazy data compression that goes in to this, but the amount of information to process from the eyes is several orders of magnitude greater than from the years. While you're technically correct, that's not the whole story. There is a substantial amount of image processing that happens in the eye (I suppose it's possible that's true of the ear as well; we know much less about hearing than sight). I'm not familiar with all the research in the area, so I can't throw out numbers, but you can't just compare numbers of raw sensors meaningfully.
- ajuc 7y agoBeing blind since birth likely reduces the probability of being diagnosed with schizophrenia if you have it - because you will know that everything you "see" is hallucinations so you won't act on them. That changes the math significantly.
- wysinwyw 7y agoThat would be true if visual hallucinations were the primary symptom of schizophrenia but that is not the case. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schizophrenia#Positive_symptoms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schizophrenia#Positive_symptom...
- zfell 7y agoCould there be a much simpler explanation? The most recent study the article sites (Morgan et. al, 2018) states that out of 468k people in the population "1870 children developed schizophrenia (0.4%) while 9120 developed a psychotic illness (1.9%). None of the 66 children with cortical blindness developed schizophrenia or psychotic illness." If we don't assume there is a relationship between schizophrenia and cortical blindness, it's not surprising that none of the 66 people who had cortical blindness developed schizophrenia. Simple binomial approximation will yield a 77% (0.996^66) probability. Am I missing something? Also I find the difference in prevalence rates of schizophrenia of 0.4% in the Morgan et al. paper vs 0.72% in McGrath et al. 2008 odd. Morgan et al. 2018: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0920996418304055# https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S09209...!
- zfell 7y agoFound a link to the full paper here: https://www.gwern.net/docs/psychology/2018-morgan.pdf https://www.gwern.net/docs/psychology/2018-morgan.pdf It explains the difference in prevalence rates: "While median lifetime morbid risk for schizophrenia is estimated to be 0.72% (Saha et al., 2005), many of our young cohort had still not passed through the window for schizophrenia onset." However, their claim for a relationship is indeed very weak: "In our data, this dropped to 0.2% for congenital or early peripheral blindness and was zero for congenital or early cortical blindness [0 cases out of 66]. Our data further suggest that the protection offered by cortical blindness may extend to a broader range of psychotic disorders and that risk of psychosis may effectively be reduced to zero." It's ironic that they start the discussion stating "The results from this whole-population cohort, although possibly underpowered, lend confidence to findings from smaller case studies". Yes, it is underpowered, and I'm surprised it was published.
- Fomite 7y agoI mean, if it is genuinely a whole population cohort, there's a legitimate question to what "power" even means in that context, because there's no statistical uncertainty. It simply is. Whether or not hypothesis testing in registry data is justifiable was once the topic of a legendary fight in my graduate department during someone's defense.
- amluto 7y agoIf the authors of the study can’t multiply percentages, I don’t see why I should believe the study at all. Taking their numbers at face value: .72% * 0.03% = 0.0072 * 0.0003 = ~0.000002 = 0.0002%. That’s 2 per million, not 2 per 10k. Nice try. edit: somehow they did get the expected number in the US right, but they seem to have flubbed the comparison to other conditions.
- tikiman163 7y agoYour math is wrong. The probabilities you listed for the 2 events is correct, but you multiplied 0.72 by 0.03,but probabilities aren't stated that way. 0.72% is a probability of 0.0072 and 0.03% is 0.0003. So the correct probability of coincidence is much lower than 0.02% it's 0.0002% or a probability of 0.000002. So that rate wouldn't be 2 in 10,000 it should be 2 in 1,000,000. This pravelance rate is therefore 25 times lower than that of childhood onset schizophrenia (1 in 40,000). You did however get the number of people who should have it in the US correct at roughly 620 cases if the two conditions are independent. Although that only includes the reported population numbers, as a better population estimate to account for people who won't answer the census is more like 340 million. This portion of the population that doesn't answer the census could easily be hiding all 670 potential cases because they also don't tend to trust doctors and would never be diagnosed. I'm not saying that this is a guaranteed scenario, but schizophrenia does have a genetic component, so it is possible that we simply haven't seen the cases in the general population because their families have hidden the affected family members. The "closet" syndrome when it comes to mentally ill family members is well documented, and some groups have even been known to hide family members with physical disabilities such as blindness or deafness. We believe this is happening less today, but that's difficult to prove and may simply be our way of coping with the fact that we will never be able to help people trapped in that situation.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Retric 7y agoThat’s another possibility alongside misdiagnosis, normal privacy, etc. I personally doubt any single factor is going to hide discovery of blind from birth vs blind as a young child globally. But with populations this small a few is all it would take. PS: That’s a direct quote from page 2 of the link. It’s got some other interesting information about this topic you’re interested.