6 ms·
The problem is that the "just" is an unsolvable problem. Your phone and to some extent tablet are limited screen estate with the finger as the primary method o
by dmitriid 7y ago
The problem is that the "just" is an unsolvable problem.
Your phone and to some extent tablet are limited screen estate with the finger as the primary method of interaction.
Your desktop is nearly unlimited screen estate with high precision input methods (mouse and keyboard).
The "just different UIs" mean "entirely different UIs tailored to specific interactions and completely changing behaviour of an app in all but the simplest cases"
- jdminhbg 7y agoAll of this is true, but with processing power and disk space increasing, you could envision a world where a phone simply has a copy of a desktop OS that it could boot into for docking, like a Mac with a Windows partition. I’m sure you could do this with Linux now, it’s just such a niche use case nobody has mass produced it.
- dmitriid 7y agoExactly: it's such a niche thing, no one is mass-producing it. Because you would still have a problem. Let's say, you started editing a document on your phone. You then put it in a dock. Now what? The separate desktop OS starts, and?...
- coldtea 7y ago>Let's say, you started editing a document on your phone. You then put it in a dock. Now what? The separate desktop OS starts, and?... And you edit the document in a desktop UI now. Apple already has this feature (moving data and open files and apps and such from mobile to desktop transparently), called Continuity.
- dmitriid 7y agoYes. And it's different apps (one on desktop, on on mobile), and both apps have to support Continuity. So a phone in dock would have to run two OSes in parallel, and the apps in both OSes would have to run and support continuity-like hand-off.
- MR4D 7y agoIf MSFT can make Excel run on my iPhone, then I have a lot of hope. When I can edit a freaking PowerPoint presentation on an iPhone (in a pinch - I wouldn't want to do it all day), then I have to think it's not only possible, but already done. Email is probably the best example. Every major email app is on multiple platforms, and I'd be very surprised if most of the code is not already the same among platforms except for the UI. So I'd submit that it is a solved problem.
- dizzy3gg 7y agoMicrosoft seem to be heavily invested in react native (and possibly election?) as their UI layer.
- dmitriid 7y agoYou're confusing the technology to create UI with the UI itself.
- 1123581321 7y agoI believe you misunderstood. The issue is not whether software can be ported to a touch platform. It is that keyboard/mouse-oriented UI and ergonomics and a touch-oriented UI and ergonomics cannot successfully co-exist. It’s not a programming challenge.
- Reason077 7y ago> "keyboard/mouse-oriented UI and ergonomics and a touch-oriented UI and ergonomics cannot successfully co-exist" I'm not sure that's necessarily true. Are you aware of Mac Catalyst? https://developer.apple.com/mac-catalyst/ https://developer.apple.com/mac-catalyst/ (Of course, the user experience will always be somewhat different on a small phone screen compared to a big Mac screen. But that doesn't mean you can't build an app that works well on both from one code base. And certainly an iPad app is not all that different from a Mac app.).
- 1123581321 7y ago