6 ms·
My main reasons: * number of homeless people (they are everywhere) * safety in general * poor public transport * cost of renting and buying * density (it i
by baby 7y ago
My main reasons:
* number of homeless people (they are everywhere)
* safety in general
* poor public transport
* cost of renting and buying
* density (it is quite an empty city and is designed for cars)
* a bit too cold
- thrway239043 7y agoMy reasons (left in 2019, moved there in 2011): * Unsafe. 2 vehicle break-ins, 1 apartment intruder while I was home. Fortunately I own a handgun. * Dirty * The proportion of creepy weirdos I met got too high. When I first got there, it was something like 1 out of every 20 people I met. By the end, it was something like 1/4. * Overpriced * Bad transit * Corrupt city government * NIMBYism Why I stayed longer than I should have: * Rent control. I'm paying twice as much in rent now. * The issues didn't appear all at once, they got a little worse each year. * Cost of moving. It cost me around $15k and it took a lot of energy to pack/apartment hunt/unpack/drive with trailer.
- jerkstate 7y agoI left Oakland last summer after 20 years in the Bay Area. I had noticed a gradual decline especially over the past 5-6 years in cleanliness and public safety in my area, including frequent car break-ins (about every 3 months for the last 2 years), visible symptoms of drug addiction and homelessness everywhere, and so on. The disdain for law enforcement as well as individual rights of self-protection is a dangerous combo. When I started a family and realized that I had to make school district decisions in the next few years, I could no longer square the extremely high taxes, decrepit quality of living (including my 90 year old highly energy-inefficient dwelling as well as the well known public sanitation issues) AND the likelihood of private school tuition a few years down the line and started looking for a way out. I hope the Bay Area will right itself (although I don't have any suggestions for how that could be done), but I fear that some of the most impacted areas are going to go through a cycle of urban decay and flight and hit "rock bottom" politically before things get safer and cleaner again.
- inferiorhuman 7y agoThe disdain for law enforcement as well as individual rights of self-protection is a dangerous combo. It takes two to tango. Wanting police to be held accountable for their actions is not disdain for police. Wanting to be treated like a human being doesn't mean being soft on crime (nor does it mean there's disdain for police). On the other hand Oakland PD rather famously pimped out a child (Celeste Guap) not that long ago (2017), so perhaps they have earned whatever disdain you're referring to?
- thrway239043 7y agoSome members of Oakland PD, who were removed years ago, being bad does not mean that Oakland does not deserve the rule of law now. You're part of the problem. I moved away from the Bay Area to get away from people like you.
- inferiorhuman 7y agoSome members of Oakland PD, who were removed years ago, being bad does not mean that Oakland does not deserve the rule of law now. Removed years ago? We're talking 14 OPD officers alone (Guap was used by a variety of bay area police departments), maybe 2-3 years ago, not yonks. If you want to talk eons ago, let's talk about the Oakland Riders. OPD is under federal receivership not because the citizens of Oakland "don't deserve the rule of law" but because the federal government thought that the Oakland police department was simply that fucked up. For a brief moment in time OPD had a chief (Batts) that was reform oriented and did engage the community. He got thrown under the bus and landed at a research gig at Harvard. Now we're back to this utterly dichotomous rhetoric that police simply can't do anything wrong. But if you'd like to talk about Guap, let's. The chief resigned and one of the cops committed suicide. As more evidence came to light one candidate for chief decided to remain at the rank of captain instead of seeking a promotion to chief. By 2018 charges against all but three of the officers implicated were dropped. OPD did not clean house. The rule of law does not mean that you simply give carte-blanche to the cops. As long as you've got structural issues exempting the police from oversight you don't have rule of law. And as long as you shut down any discourse that isn't in lockstep with the police, you don't even have a facade of rule of law. Police aren't the (only) problem, but they are very much part of the problem. You're part of the problem. I moved away from the Bay Area to get away from people like you. You're certainly welcome to move wherever you want for whatever reason. But, please, let's not pretend that not wanting police officers to pimp out a teenager is some dog whistle for agitating against the rule of law (or against law enforcement in general). Lemme guess tho. In your free time you post blue lives matter nonsense to facebook?
- mkolodny 7y agoI recently left SF, and feel a little differently, so I'll share my take on your points: * Homeless people are rare in most of SF, but super common in the middle of downtown (Market St area). So if you live/work near Market St (especially near Tenderloin), you'll feel like homeless people are everywhere. If you don't, you probably won't * I felt super safe in SF. Even in the Tenderloin, I never felt unsafe or heard of any of my friends being mugged or anything. Stolen bikes, yes. There are parts in and around the Tenderloin that feel very sketch, even if they're safe. You can find neighborhoods like that in most any big city. The difference in SF is that they're in the middle of downtown * Public transportation isn't anywhere near as good as NYC, but you can get most anywhere on a bus and/or muni (metro/subway). Where I lived most recently (Haight Ashbury area), I thought public transportation was pretty convenient. I took ubers to get to my office in Dogpatch though * I agree with point #3 - rent is expensive, and buying costs are prohibitively expensive (even with a well-paying job) * Almost none of my friends in SF own cars. They even recently closed down the main downtown street (Market) from cars [0]. You do need to take buses/ubers to get most places * It's sweatshirt weather pretty much year-round. Although it does get shorts-warm around October/November. If, like me, you like sweatshirt weather, you won't mind it. If you prefer seasons or hot weather months, you probably won't love the weather For me, housing prices were the biggest issue. Buying a house in a good school district in the Bay Area is ridiculously expensive. Looking on Zillow, you see a sad number of foreclosures on people's homes who probably had a $1M+ mortgage. If the housing costs stay at these prices or go up, I'd be surprised if you don't see more and more people leaving the Bay Area. I hope that Google/Facebook's plan to build more homes actually brings prices down some [1][2]. We'll see [0] https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2020/01/market-street-car-free-san-francisco-bike-lanes-transit/605674/ https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2020/01/market-street... [1] https://www.blog.google/inside-google/company-announcements/1-billion-investment-bay-area-housing/ https://www.blog.google/inside-google/company-announcements/... [2] https://about.fb.com/news/2019/10/facebook-commits-1-billion-to-address-housing-affordability/ https://about.fb.com/news/2019/10/facebook-commits-1-billion...
- inferiorhuman 7y agoHomeless people are rare in most of SF, but super common in the middle of downtown (Market St area). So if you live/work near Market St (especially near Tenderloin), you'll feel like homeless people are everywhere. If you don't, you probably won't I saw comments (perhaps yours?) along these lines on the last HN post about San Francisco I read. This doesn't jive with my experiences in San Francisco at all. In fact a couple weeks ago I took the 38R to the outer richmond and was just shocked both by the number of vacant storefronts along Geary and the number of homeless folks around. I felt super safe in SF. Even in the Tenderloin, I never felt unsafe or heard of any of my friends being mugged or anything. Stolen bikes, yes. There are parts in and around the Tenderloin that feel very sketch, even if they're safe. You can find neighborhoods like that in most any big city. The difference in SF is that they're in the middle of downtown I've never had a problem in the Tenderloin and I've plenty of opportunity to, but Turk & Taylor definitely earned its reputation. It's a dirty and poor neighborhood but the junkies generally put me less on edge than the folks with more outward facing psychiatric issues like you find in Potrero. Public transportation isn't anywhere near as good as NYC, but you can get most anywhere on a bus and/or muni (metro/subway). Where I lived most recently (Haight Ashbury area), I thought public transportation was pretty convenient. I took ubers to get to my office in Dogpatch though New Yorkers will happily kvetch about their public transit (last time I was there I ended up talking with these women on the subway who were grousing about having to transfer or walk a few blocks because late night service was upended by construction/maintenance). And, quite frankly, you'll have trouble getting to the outer reaches (especially outer Queens + Brooklyn) on a bus/taxi/subway car. The Haight is incredibly well served by buses and streetcars, but the Dogpatch is not. The metro past embarcadero is a shit show (by design).
- PascLeRasc 7y agoWhere do you go to though? I'm trying to leave Pittsburgh because it's so car-centric and the weather is awful. I'm not sure there's a city in the U.S. where you can bike commute every day of the year and be comfortable. San Francisco seems like the best available.