4 ms·
Pentagon Requests $15B for Space Force
- tomp 7y ago> The money, largely transferred from existing Air Force programs, would include $2.5 billion for operations and maintenance, $10.3 billion for research and development, and $2.4 billion for procurement. TL;DR: who cares.
- microtherion 7y agoOnce the Space Force seizes the Moon's oil reserves, this will be money well spent!
- suifbwish 7y agoDon’t you mean.. the space cash?
- papito 7y agoQuite a boondogle. What's it for? The earth camo uniforms? New letterheads? The space ops are already part of the military.
- loceng 7y agoPreparing, organizing, for potential war with China and their allies.
- fit2rule 7y agoThe more and more gets leaked about all this, the more I'm convinced that this is simply a move to set up a policing force - in Space - before the Mars colony really gets rolling. I mean, when Mars gets colonised, what's to stop Mars from becoming a superpower in the Sol system within a very short period of time? Pretty much nothing. Once humanity gets its footing on Mars - and it really looks like this is going to happen within the next few decades - there are going to be security repercussions for those of us left on Earth. I believe this Space Force effort is an attempt to make USA not only Earth's police force, but that of the solar system, too. Extraordinary times! To be actually typing this, in earnest..
- takinola 7y agoGiven that nothing we put into orbit or on another planet is going to be self-sustaining, you don’t need weapons to exert control on any residents of such infrastructure. A simple blockade will suffice
- caconym_ 7y agoFor now. GP comment is speculative in either case.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoI'd be more wary of a sneak attack from Antarctic insurgents first.
- ragebol 7y agoYou can never be too early in stopping those Laconians I guess.
- daeken 7y ago> I mean, when Mars gets colonised, what's to stop Mars from becoming a superpower in the Sol system within a very short period of time? Pretty much nothing. Aside from the enormous cost of moving the (many, many) needed resources from the Earth to Mars. I'm super bullish on a Mars colony (I will be going within 5 years of it becoming an option) but the idea that it will be even 100% self-sustaining in the next 100 years -- let alone a superpower -- is absolutely bananas.
- papito 7y agoYou expect politicians to learn from previous mistakes? LOL. Mars will eventually have its move for independence, when it's too late to stop that. Total Recall and The Expanse are on the nose.
- appleshore 7y agoThey work on Earth, not in space. And while I think the philosophy of government organizations needs to be improved, if we don’t do this, we’ll be at the mercy of China.
- 1123581321 7y agoIt’s just a portion of the old Air Force budget, so it’s, at least for now, to do things the Air Force was already doing.
- Pinbenterjamin 7y agoI'm going to try and be optimistic about this; 10b in research and development? I can't imagine that it's going to be for 'weapons' only right? Some of this has to go into the future of humankind. I would imagine they have to be interested in colonization, as it's generally in the interest of humankind to expand to the reaches of outerspace, and to do so and be confronted with opposition would require such an agency. I'd like to know too what the overlap in responsibility between NASA and Spaceforce will be. Are they both scientific ventures? Is Spaceforce actually interested in intergalactic safety. I'm cautiously optimistic.
- RobRivera 7y agoFor the record, GPS infrastructure was DoD funded. My point is: DoD funding is not all doom, gloom, weapons dev. A lot of it is logistical infrastructure that has significant benefit for civilian applications. Remember, defense funding is what fueld the tech sector's birth
- mhh__ 7y agoI guess it technically isn't (I believe force multiplier would be the term) but GPS is an extremely powerful weapon if only one side has such capabilities
- melling 7y agoSure. However, secrets are hard to keep.
- verdverm 7y agoNot so much a weapon system as an information and coordination system. It's like calling the camera that looks at stars for determining position a weapons system. GPS and astro guidance are both part of a redundant navigation system.
- sneak 7y agoRemember, “defense” funding also killed several (>5) million people since the US was founded in several wars of aggression, including about a million in the current generation. Don’t believe the hype. NASA put people on the moon and brought them back. They could design, launch, and operate GPS like they do Hubble and other satellites. It’s well within their expertise. We don’t need to accept DoD funding of violent undertakings that end up killing millions simply for the meager benefits we get as a side effect sometimes. As a counterexample: the military has had supersonic jets for two generations, and there is no civilian supersonic transport. The only one that did exist was an european undertaking. You get no benefit from any of the billions spent on fast planes by the war machine. None. Massive defense spending only trickles down to defense contractors. This is just public-to-private wealth transfer, nothing more.
- DanCarvajal 7y agoSo just a few F35s worth of funding.
- mhh__ 7y agoAbout 150 of them?
- otoburb 7y ago>>"Space Force technically only has one member right now, Chief of Space Operations Gen. John Raymond, though thousands of airmen are working for the service on assignment." I know this may seem like an esoteric budgeting question, but does this mean that other departments are essentially funding the Space Force and don't expect to recover their labour costs, or will they be accrued and cross-charged back to the respective departments when (if?) Space Force's $15.4B funding is approved?
- jessaustin 7y agoAt the Pentagon, it doesn't matter. They don't have to balance the books. The adjustments swamp the actual spending.
- gizmo686 7y agoSpace force is fundamentally a reorganization. Work that had previusly been done by other branches (mostly airforce) is being moved to its own branch. During the transition, work (hopefully) continues without interuption. As I read the proposal, the airforce will recieve a corresponding drop in funding to reflect their reduced scope.
- Damorian 7y agoThis is interesting, I'd have expected it to be much higher. I know that the Air Force Space Command employed more people than NASA, which has a $20B+ budget. I assume more is massaged in elsewhere.
- elicash 7y agoIf I were to add a new branch, it wouldn't be a Space Force. It'd be a cyberwar force.
- duncan-donuts 7y agoDoesn't this already exist through the NSA and friends?
- Namrog84 7y agoThere is a difference between the military and government agencies. It's like asking why not get rid of military in favor of militia, Hired guns, And police forces? Who had what authority. Funding. Jurisdiction and related. And plenty of other things.
- otoburb 7y agoUS Cyber Command was elevated to "full and independent unified combatant command"[1] in May 2018. I think Space Force is somewhat different in that they're not a unified command and are meant to be a separate standalone military branch. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Cyber_Command https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Cyber_Command
- psychometry 7y agoRemember this moment when Trump, McConnell, and various other horsemen of the apocalypse tell us we can't afford food stamps or health insurance for poor children.
- endorphone 7y agoFundamentally this entire post is "politics", so what you broached is entirely within the purview. And it's absolutely correct. The Republican party is deep underway on a policy of "starving the beast", rolling up $1T+ deficits during the pinnacle of the economy, when arguably it should be coming close to slaying the deficit. These are extraordinary times, and many of the people who were screaming bloody murder before about every cent of government spending suddenly have gone quiet. The next budget is already beginning the process of dramatically reducing the few social programs the US does offer. All of this is fascinating given that Trump promised that he would eliminate the deficit (he has exploded it, while at the same time rolling out an enormous middle-class tax hike courtesy of tariffs). He is destroying the US just enough that when the Democrats do take power they'll be between a rock and a hard place, with extraordinary little option to do anything. But hey...space force!
- psychometry 7y agoNo informed and literate person ever thought Trump would reduce the deficit. Much like during W's presidency, it will balloon and they will leave it to the next administration to deal with. Meanwhile, Trump's cronies will enrich themselves at our expense.
- suifbwish 7y agoME: So there are absolutely no aliens? GOVERNMENT: looks at paper um no absolutely not. ME: But you need a space military? GOVERNMENT: yes that is correct ME: may I ask why? GOVERNMENT: I’m sorry that is classified Lol no
- wongarsu 7y agoWe established a sea military despite nothing from the sea attacking us, and an air military despite birds being fairly friendly
- jedberg 7y agoI wonder how long it will be until they decide to reorg NASA under Space Force.
- Shivetya 7y agoI would be more of the belief that by its existence that Space Force will further separate NASA from the military. It provides much more separation that what NASA currently has, if anything the real question becomes how much will the other branches give up to Space Force. The Air Force has the most to lose; unless of course this becomes something similar to Navy and Marines
- pastor_elm 7y ago>The budget documents released Monday anticipate 6,434 active-duty Space Force members Seems like incredible bloat for this agency to have any sort of 'active duty' military personal at the moment. What are they exactly going to do that civilians can't?
- mopsi 7y agoIf you're not aware, the GPS is and has always been brought to you by active duty military personnel. Establishment of Space Force renames the organization that has existed since 1982. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iIuqVeSL6Ss https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iIuqVeSL6Ss
- HenryKissinger 7y agoWorking at: Combined Space Operations Center, Vandenberg AFB Missile Warning Center, Cheyenne Mountain AFS Joint Overhead Persistent Infrared Center, Buckley AFB Joint Navigation Warfare Center, Kirtland AFB Joint Task Force-Space Defense, Schriever Air Force Base, Colorado Springs, CO - JTF-SD is responsible for protecting military satellites from aggression National Space Defense Center - Co-located within JTF-SD, NSDC is a joint effort between the Department of Defense and the United States Intelligence Community responsible for detecting, warning, and defending against threats to military space systems, particularly those of the National Reconnaissance Office
- melling 7y agoI like to compare expenses to the interest on the national debt. Looks like it's about 3% of that: https://www.thebalance.com/interest-on-the-national-debt-4119024 https://www.thebalance.com/interest-on-the-national-debt-411... Of course, rates are historically low.
- davidw 7y agoI think radio or TV discussions of the Spaaace Foooorce should be required to pronounce it like so: https://clyp.it/mznwbuxq https://clyp.it/mznwbuxq
- pbiggar 7y agoSounds like they've identified $15B in wasteful spending that they can just eliminate.
- LatteLazy 7y agoNo money for nasa, gold plated ships for the military...
- HenryKissinger 7y agoThe Trump administration calls for big budget increases for NASA to fund Moon-to-Mars program https://www.theverge.com/2020/2/10/21131361/nasa-administration-president-trump-budget-request-25-billion-moon-artemis https://www.theverge.com/2020/2/10/21131361/nasa-administrat...
- caublestone 7y agoFor the first time in my life, I’m excited for a new government initiative. I’ve realized that the there is a link between home security and military budgets. I’m optimistic about the space force because we the people are bought in to spending on insurance premiums which is a defined margin above calculable risks. And so if we want government funded space exploration we can sell it as insurance and actually make it happen.
- nabla9 7y agoOrganizational structure influences policy. US just created an organization who needs to work against demilitarization of space to stay relevant. Just operating spy satellites for NRO or satellite communication network is is not enough.
- ARandomerDude 7y agoDoes anyone know the proposed monicker for someone in the Space Force (granted there's only 1 person right now)? They aren't "airmen," nor are they "astronauts."
- dTal 7y agoSpace Marines? Space Ranger? Starship Troopers? Defenders of the Earth?
- _threads 7y agoI can only imagine a French president announcing even 1 single billion for a « space force » project. All he would get is an instant a civil war
- masonic 7y agoIn other words, he'd surrender?
- FillardMillmore 7y agoWhether the Space Force actually achieves its goals remains to be seen (goals which remain somewhat nebulous, though the article points out the following): > The new service is aimed at protecting U.S. assets in space, such as satellites, from earthly threats, including U.S. adversaries Russia and China. I am no expert, but I'm fairly certain that the Air Force and NASA were charged with the responsibility of protecting government assets in space. It would seem that this Space Force is being created to carry this duty out as one of its core responsibilities (the Air Force is already responsible for a lot) as some countries around the world accelerate their space research and space ventures (not to mention that our own private sector has companies accelerating space research as well). As far as I understand it, China already has an equivalent to the US Space Force - besides China, there are other countries with galactic ambitions and they are not all friends of the US. That said, claims of the US 'weaponizing' space may be exaggerated, or at least it would seem so to me. The US obviously wants to protect its interests in Space and it doesn't want China getting a strong enough early foothold so that they can operate from a position of greater leverage in matters of space diplomacy. Again, I'm no expert, but I think what the US needs to do to ensure future prosperity for others in space (both private and state actors) is to pursue diplomacy and establish an international coalition for space governance. Of course, this is easier said than done, but starting on the right path could be the difference between tense confrontations in the future vs. clearly communicated and shared information.
- Seenso 7y ago> I am no expert, but I'm fairly certain that the Air Force and NASA were charged with the responsibility of protecting government assets in space. It would seem that this Space Force is being created to carry this duty out as one of its core responsibilities (the Air Force is already responsible for a lot) Which isn't so odd. During WWII, the US didn't have an Air Force, it had the Army Air Force. It didn't become totally independent of the Army until 1947. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Army_Air_Corps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Army_Air_Corps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Army_Air_Forces https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Army_Air_Forces