4 ms·
Spotify isn’t doing anything to podcasts. An audio program that doesn’t publish an RSS feed that I can subscribe to in my podcast player of choice isn’t a podca
by scarface74 7y ago
Spotify isn’t doing anything to podcasts. An audio program that doesn’t publish an RSS feed that I can subscribe to in my podcast player of choice isn’t a podcast. It’s also not something I’m going to waste my time listening to.
As far as Apple, Apple’s podcast directory and app are the very definition of “open”. Apple just indexes publicly available submitted RSS feeds. When you subscribe from Apple’s podcast app, the app itself polls the publishers RSS feed and plays directly from the publisher’s servers.
You can also subscribe to a podcast directly from the app using the url to the podcast - it doesn’t have to be in Apple’s directory.
Apple even offers a public API of the podcast directory that can be used by anyone on any platform.
- daveFNbuck 7y agoSpotify is trying to replace podcasts with the thing that isn't a podcast. You can decide not to listen to things that aren't podcasts, but if Spotify is successful, that may mean that podcasts you currently enjoy are no longer available in a medium you're willing to consume. That's the worry here. I've already seen this start happening with Parcast. Since being purchased by Spotify, they're using their existing podcasts to advertise other "podcasts" that are only available streaming on Spotify. I'm guessing the ones I listen to now will eventually go away into the Spotify walled garden.
- scarface74 7y agoThe podcasts I enjoy the most I can 99% guarantee that they will not go to Spotify: The Talk Show - the most popular (and profitable AFAIK) Apple related podcast. The chance of Gruber going Spotify only are basically 0. Accidental Tech Podcast - seeing that one of the cohosts (Marco Arment) actually developed one of the most popular podcast apps for iOS, I don’t think he is going to make a podcast that can’t be listened to on his own app. Under The Radar - another podcast by Marco Arment. Exponent - Ben Thompson of Stratechery. He doesn’t directly monetize his podcast. He has a very successful paid newsletter. He wouldn’t want to put his podcast out of reach of the most people. Manager Tools/Career Tools - the only ads they do on their podcasts are for their own products. Some developer focused podcasts Various NPR podcasts. Etc. All the podcasts I listen to have a vested interests in reaching the broadest audience possible.
- ijpsud 7y ago> The podcasts I enjoy the most [...] All the podcasts I listen to Emphasis on "I". You are not everyone, and so you don't control all the demand, and so you don't control the direction that the market moves in. Though it's not self-evident that we're headed towards podcast centralization, I think it's a legitimate concern here. Social networks like Facebook ate a decent part of the open internet's cake in the 2000s because the centralized services were easier to set up and user for the end users (compared to the RSS and SMTP hacks). I think that's what is going to matter here: If Spotify does a significantly better job than plain RSS, then they're going to be "the" place to listen to podcasts, and can start building a closed ecosystem and then use their monopoly to rent seek. And like in the social networks case, I don't think it's going to be that hard to improve on plain RSS. Some podcasting apps already have comments, user ratings, etc. and I definitely find this sort of thing useful. Maybe the path of least resistance in these sorts of situations is always some degree of centralization, but I obviously hope the tide starts going back out at some point - preferably complete decentralization, rather than just federated protocols. I think it's a bit like how native apps can move faster (in terms of new APIs and stuff), and the web slowly follows along, waiting for certain things to be "proven" before standardizing them. I think the web wins in the long run, but native apps end up being the "exploratory" instrument in our search algorithm.
- scarface74 7y agoWell, seeing that almost every stat shows that the majority of podcasts listeners are iOS users. (https://musicoomph.com/podcast-statistics/ https://musicoomph.com/podcast-statistics/) - 54% iOS users - what are the chances that Spotify can become overwhelming on Apple’s platforms? If you want to be a mass market success and reach the largest, most affluent audience, you can’t be a Spotify exclusive. How many of the top 50 podcast do you suppose would be willing to give up their broader market to be Spotify only?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- curiousphil 7y ago
- flashman 7y agoIf a publisher decides to stop offering audio through RSS because it's easier to monetize it through Spotify's streaming ads insertion, where does that leave you?
- scarface74 7y agoSee my previous comment. All of the podcasts I listen to have either been very successful at monetizing via their own ad sales for years, are very Apple centric, very developer centric, or use podcasts to advertise their own products.
- tjomk 7y agoGood for you in that case, but this sounds like the Nazi Germany when party after party was outlawed until the only remaining parties were the supporters of Hitler's agenda. A radical example, but this is what reminds me the current situation and your attitude.
- macspoofing 7y ago>but this sounds like the Nazi Germany Godwin is alive and well.
- gsich 7y agoAdblocking will start.
- mrzool 7y ago> Spotify isn’t doing anything to podcasts. An audio program that doesn’t publish an RSS feed that I can subscribe to in my podcast player of choice isn’t a podcast. You are grossly underestimating the threat. The majority of people don't even know what an RSS feed is, and a lot of users are already listening exclusively through Spotify. For them, those are the "podcasts". The change is already ongoing, and Spotify will not stop until staying out of its platform will no longer be an option for podcast producers. They will swallow up the whole ecosystem if they don't get stopped, just like Facebook did with the publishing industry.
- scarface74 7y agoLots of users == 10%. And there is a difference between people listening to standard podcasts through Spotify where Spotify just caches RSS feeds and audio (where you can still get pretty good stats from what I’ve heard.) and going Spotify only. In the former case, Spotify is just another podcatcher.
- mrzool 7y agoI really wish you were right. But you're not.
- jtbayly 7y agoIndependent blogs still exist, too. Just like actual podcasts (rss feed to podcast player) will still exist even if Spotify takes over. But I can tell you as somebody deeply involved in podcasting that we get requests to put our content on Spotify because that's the only app many people use for listening to things (whether music or whatever). We're talking about dedicated fans of our shows that took the time to let us know that they stopped listening because of the transition that took place unintentionally in their personal life to being Spotify-only. This is exactly what happened when FB took over content distribution. People didn't necessarily like it, even as they adopted it because of the convenience.
- scarface74 7y agoPutting your podcast on Spotify is completely different than putting your podcast exclusively on Spotify. The former is like creating AMP pages for Google.
- macspoofing 7y ago>An audio program that doesn’t publish an RSS feed that I can subscribe to in my podcast player of choice isn’t a podcast. For now. But we've seen this game before. When a critical mass switches to a closed ecosystem, you're either going to be forced to move with the herd (because most of your podcasts will move and new podcasts will start-up exclusively within the walled garden), or you'll be left behind.
- scarface74 7y agoYet three of the podcasts I mentioned have survived for well over a decade. If you target a high income demographic. It’s a lot easier to get direct response advertisers selling either expensive items or subscription based products where the lifetime value of the customer is high. Back in the day people said the definition of a podcast was two guys talking about tech sponsored by SquareSpace.
- macspoofing 7y ago>Yet three of the podcasts I mentioned have survived for well over a decade. That's because podcasts are still part of an open ecosystem. I think the current system works very well and I don't want it to change, but I can see a walled-garden arise and lock the majority of content away behind proprietary podcast clients (much as video content is locked inside the YouTube garden).
- scarface74 7y agoHow much of that is because delivering video is expensive. Most analyst think that Youtube is still not profitable.
- chungus_khan 7y agoAs much as I want that to be the case, "A television broadcast that doesn't come in free over the airwaves isn't a broadcast show" type sentiments didn't stop cable, and while cable started with a nicer, often ad-free offering, the advantages faded as it grew, balkanization of channel offerings eventually came, etc. Operating a local television station in the US today now requires collaboration with these companies, and they have little incentive to work effectively with smaller local players. They can get nationally syndicated shows through their originating networks, and only really need to bow to local interests at all for highly localized things like news (and even that's dying rapidly). These open spaces and preferred arrangements have to be defended or they will die.
- scarface74 7y agoCable was never an ad free alternative. That’s a popular meme.
- chungus_khan 7y agoA large number of premium, cable-exclusive channels were at one point. Broadcast channels weren't, but that wasn't a disadvantage, and those premium channels brought a lot to the table. https://www.nytimes.com/1981/07/26/arts/will-cable-tv-be-invaded-by-commercials.html https://www.nytimes.com/1981/07/26/arts/will-cable-tv-be-inv...
- scarface74 7y agoThose few premium channels that you paid extra for on top of your regular cable build were ad free and still are.
- chungus_khan 7y agoSome of them are, especially movie-related ones, but special interest and news channels generally run ads now. This also isn't really relevant to my point and I never said that cable used to be ad-free, but rather that there used to be a more prominent attraction to it due to some ad-free content offerings.
- mumblemumble 7y ago> Spotify isn’t doing anything to podcasts. An audio program that doesn’t publish an RSS feed that I can subscribe to in my podcast player of choice This seems like the kind of thing that can flip very suddenly. For Spotify users, who are already used to streaming everything, listening to podcasts through Spotify might offer a fair amount of convenience. For podcasters looking to monetize, Spotify can offer something special: The ability to get paid for your work directly, without having to deal with hawking mail order razor blades, which I imagine can feel degrading to some creators, or take on the extra work of maintaining an attractive set of Patreon incentives. It might be that the only missing ingredient is a critical mass of Spotify users to give the first few podcasters reason to feel confident taking the plunge. Maybe they don't even need to get anyone to jump in feet first. I could see a more prolific podcaster such as Aaron Mahnke perhaps being willing to give it a shot with one of his projects. But a few initial successes might be all it takes to kick off a chain reaction. Sort of like how, at the party we were hosting last night, it seemed like people were settling in for the night, but, once the first person left, our house was empty within 20 minutes.
- rchaud 7y ago> An audio program that doesn’t publish an RSS feed that I can subscribe to in my podcast player of choice isn’t a podcast. I think the risk is that Spotify can throw a big bundle of money to a podcast that is currently listed on a feed, and bring them into a walled garden where the only way to hear them is on Spotify.
- scarface74 7y agoHave you seen Spotify’s financials? They are a public company now, they can’t get round after round of VC money and have make believe valuations.
- zouhair 7y ago> Spotify isn’t doing anything to podcasts. An audio program that doesn’t publish an RSS feed that I can subscribe to in my podcast player of choice isn’t a podcast. Well that's just bad faith use of semantics. Spotify bought companies that produces podcasts. As of now you can still enjoy said podcasts outside of Spotify, using your preferred player but if they decide to force you to use their software will those programs suddenly stop being called podcasts?
- scarface74 7y agoSpotify bought a company that created money losing over produced shows where the most successful podcasts are just the opposite. One of the most successful podcast over the past decade is “Stuff You Should Know”. The hosts go out of their way not to talk about the subject before hand to make the show seem more organic. Would you call something that couldn’t be viewed in a browser a “web page”? If you told me I should listen to this great podcast. I’m going to search on Overcast (which uses Apple’s podcast directory API), if it’s not there, it doesn’t exist. I can’t put it in my playlist, control it from my Watch app etc.