4 ms·
The answer to that is more like: I have a serious medical condition. I have two special-needs kids. I was a military wife and the military has a track record
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
The answer to that is more like:
I have a serious medical condition.
I have two special-needs kids.
I was a military wife and the military has a track record of being hard on the spouse's career. Last I checked, military spouse's had a 30 percent unemployment rate at a time when general unemployment was around 5 or 6 percent.
Etc.
There is lots of research into this with lots of popular terminology, such as Pink Collar Ghetto and The Second Shift, that describes how women are expected to be the primary child-rearers and do the lion's share of the "women's work" at home even if they have a full time job. All of this significantly impacts the careers and earning capacity of women, and not in a good way.
Women and men generally do not face the same options. They simply don't.
- heartbeats 7y agoWell, someone's got to do it. At the end of the day, you're just shifting labour around. Then you might as well specialize, since that's where the efficiency is at. Many people in careers find it deeply soul-crushing. I sincerely doubt a homemaker would have the same feelings, even thought they might consider it regrettable for other reasons.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoSome facts: Women don't really need to do anywhere near as much housework as they do. The amount of hours worked by a homemaker has stayed steady at 60 hours per week for about 300 years while we have increasingly created household technology to make the job easier. Meanwhile, the demands on her have crept up to keep her working that many hours. Source: More Work For Mother Historically, when jobs are male dominated, they pay well and have good benefits. If they become female dominated, the pay drops and it becomes a dead end job that is no longer held in high esteem. You can look up terms like "Pink Collar Ghetto" if you want to explore that further. Plenty of women find it soul crushing to be a homemaker. Women were routinely prescribed Valium for depression when, arguably, they should have been told to get a divorce -- but they weren't in part because leaving often doesn't improve your situation. Trying to establish an adequate income after being a homemaker for years can be a very hard row to hoe. Adult men (married with kids) typically choose colleges that serve their career goals and move the family there. Adult women (married with kids) typically attend whatever school happens to be conveniently nearby and not too expensive. Unsurprisingly, men tend to have better credentials that are more career enhancing. Men who start businesses are much more likely to start as a full-time thing with adequate funding as their new career focus. Women who start businesses are much more likely to be starting "lifestyle businesses" that will accommodate the demands on their time as wives and moms, often because they have special needs kids or because the details of their husband's career make it impossible for them to pursue a serious career or regular job. Unsurprisingly, businesses founded by men tend to be much more financially successful than those founded by women. I soaked up a whole lot of such stats over the years. While dismissive replies are par for the course on HN, it remains rather aggravating to have decades of reading up on the subject dismissed so casually and by a new account that was about two minutes old when you left the comment.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mises 7y ago> Women don't really need to do anywhere near as much housework as they do. The amount of hours worked by a homemaker has stayed steady at 60 hours per week for about 300 years while we have increasingly created household technology to make the job easier. Meanwhile, the demands on her have crept up to keep her working that many hours. This is the story of every other job, too. Increased productivity doesn't really lead to shorter hours worked in any other field, either. Children today enjoy more opportunities and a higher standard of living, which necessitates some parental care (no one was driving kids to soccer a hundred years ago.) > You can look up terms like "Pink Collar Ghetto" if you want to explore that further. I did, and I noticed it uses the typical "men vs. women" stuff. "Men have/women have" statements, presenting them as diametrically-opposed factions. Your source has good stats, but I can't say I like this sort of rhetoric. > Plenty of women find it soul crushing to be a homemaker. I mean, lots of people hate their jobs. Change jobs. As you said, get a divorce. Maybe that wasn't acceptable a hundred years ago, but it is today. > Trying to establish an adequate income after being a homemaker for years can be a very hard row to hoe. Well, yeah. Those people have been out of whatever profession for usually between a dozen and two dozen years; I know others who've had medical absences of just a few years and had serious difficulty re-entering their professions. The people I know who had an easy time of going back to work stayed somewhat engaged with their professional communities. They attended some events, maybe did a little freelance work. Doesn't have to be much, just enough to remind people that you still exist and keep up-to-date on the happenings of the industry. > Adult men (married with kids) typically choose colleges that serve their career goals and move the family there. Adult women (married with kids) typically attend whatever school happens to be conveniently nearby and not too expensive. Unsurprisingly, men tend to have better credentials that are more career enhancing. Are you referring to going back to school? For young undergrads, they don't base their decisions on this as they aren't married and don't have kids. This was different with older generations (especially with, say, soldiers who came back, married, and went to school on the GI bill.) As far as I'm aware, most people who go back to school do so at either a local community college or online, often part-time, regardless of sex. > Men who start businesses are much more likely to start as a full-time thing with adequate funding as their new career focus. Women who start businesses are much more likely to be starting "lifestyle businesses" that will accommodate the demands on their time as wives and moms, often because they have special needs kids or because the details of their husband's career make it impossible for them to pursue a serious career or regular job. Unsurprisingly, businesses founded by men tend to be much more financially successful than those founded by women. You claim that, "Women who start businesses are much more likely to be starting lifestyle businesses" that will accommodate the demands on their time as wives and moms". While this is true, "lifestyle" businesses aren't the only available options. I know a guy whose wife has more "rigid" career. When they had kids, he quit his job and started a chemical import/export business. He makes good money, has lots of flexibility, but no "lifestyle" business. There's nothing that stops a lady from doing the same. > While dismissive replies are par for the course on HN, it remains rather aggravating to have decades of reading up on the subject dismissed so casually and by a new account that was about two minutes old when you left the comment. While dismissal is rude, account age is one hundred percent irrelevant. I'd like to address your above comment: > Women and men generally do not face the same options. They simply don't. No one forced ladies to get married, have children, or stay home with them. At least, not in the past decades. What opportunities to men have that ladies do not?
- celticmusic 7y agoyou spent most of your post complaining about being a military wife, which is the very definition of a life choice, both in the choice to get married and the choice to stay. And before you go 100% offended, keep in mind that I learned the lesson of the importance of decision making as a life skill when I was living on the side of the river in a pup tent due to a string of decisions made by my abusive father in law and my mother (in late fall/winter). Yes, I can also throw out facts about my life to try and garner sympathy points. But none of that matters because at the end of the day, you own your own decisions. Anything else is just you sitting in a puddle of your own shit and piss and crying about how the world has treated you because you refuse to stand up and go clean yourself. And a part of that decision making is standing up for yourself. If you feel the world and your husband is forcing you into a gender role you don't want to be in, tell them to go fuck themselves.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoYes, I can also throw out facts about my life to try and garner sympathy points. My initial post was in no way whatsoever some attempt to "garner sympathy points." The amount of shit I have to put up with on HN for posting as openly female means, no, I absolutely am not here with some completely deluded agenda to get some kind of sympathy from anyone at all. I fairly frequently post to provide a female point of view backed up by data and personal first-hand experience and I generally explain who I am when I am doing that because when I don't, it is all too common for someone to assume I'm male and to accuse me of some ridiculous bullshit -- like being a rapey, misogynistic bastard -- for holding some of the views I hold. Marrying a soldier was standing up for myself. It was my ticket out of an abusive situation where I had been molested and raped by relatives. It got me the hell out of Dodge very quietly without any public drama or need to file restraining orders or other shit that just keeps you a prisoner of your abusers. That also isn't me looking for some sympathy vote. I'm quite open about having been sexually abused as a child. If that's news to you, well, sorry. It's not anything I haven't said a zillion times on HN and elsewhere.
- hunterjrj 7y ago> I fairly frequently post to provide a female point of view backed up by data and personal first-hand experience... Please continue. It’s sorely needed here.