3 ms·
I hope they don't end up in court. I've been a fact witness in 3 patent troll cases. The side I was a witness for won one, forced a settle-out-of-court for the
by PaulDavisThe1st 7y ago
I hope they don't end up in court. I've been a fact witness in 3 patent troll cases. The side I was a witness for won one, forced a settle-out-of-court for the second, and lost the last one. The last one was the biggest and most egregious. There was clear prior art, at least to anyone with a solid understanding of the field (in this case, adding state to otherwise-stateless HTTP interaction).
I remember looking the jury in the eye during my testimony and thinking "these people are tired, they are bored and they don't really have a clue about any of the technology involved here". Sure, it's the lawyers job(s) to try to make sure they do, and that they decide in the "right" direction. But seriously - taking a semi-random set of 12 jurors, sitting them them for 1-2 weeks of court room "education" in network technology, protocols, filesystems, cookies, URL structure and so much more, and then expecting them to come to an "informed" decision?
This is not a justice system worth defending. In the last case, no jury of "peers" - ie. other engineers who actually understand what the patents are about - would ever have found for the plaintiffs. But you end up in court with a very different jury than that, and at that point, the battle has just started.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoUSA used to have an expert patents court AIUI, anyone know why things were changed?
- basilgohar 7y agoI don't know if it will validate or invalidate your assertion, but I recommend watching Patent Absurdity [0]. It helps to explain how this all came to be, some history, and why the current system is so b0rken. [0] http://patentabsurdity.com/ http://patentabsurdity.com/
- brlewis 7y agoNo, nobody knows why things changed. There was a U.S. Supreme Court case called Diamond v Diehr such that if its precedent were followed, software patents like the one in the comment above would never be granted. Somehow lower courts confused things enough that software patents started being granted again. Once you open up patents to a super broad and prolific field like software, it's impossible to maintain enough expertise to assess novelty and non-obviousness. And at that point the system completely breaks down. A presumption of validity when the USPTO cannot reasonably be expected to judge validity basically means that people are being denied due process when sued for patent infringement.
- faintrain 7y agoAs anyone who has suffered injustice in a court will tell you... We have a legal system not a justice system. Those in poverty and without power have known this for sometime. Read: Gideons Trumpet by Anthony Lewis Follow: @innocence