8 ms·
Volume of a Sphere
- gus_massa 7y agoNice post. The graph of the sphere, the cone and the cylinder probably needs a 3D version just before it, so it's clear that they are 3D objects. (With a small doll or plastic eye to show the point of view?) [Request for someone with a lot of Blender capabilities: Make a 3D version of the graph, where the back half of the objects are opaque and the front half are transparent. Since you already have the 3D model, bonus points for another version where the top third of the objects is transparent and the bottom two thirds are opaque.]
- ColinWright 7y ago> Nice post. Thank you. > The graph of the sphere, the cone and the cylinder probably needs a 3D version just before it, so it's clear that they are 3D objects. Sadly, my skills aren't up to that, and I don't currently have time to acquire them 8-( > Request for someone with a lot of Blender capabilities: Make a 3D version of the graph, where the back half of the objects are opaque and the front half are transparent. That would be cool. > ... bonus points for another version where the top third of the objects is transparent and the bottom two thirds are opaque. Even cooler. Sadly, the post is sinking without trace, so I doubt anyone will see the request.
- howling 7y ago> It was only 282 years ago that Euler presented in his textbooks the exact formula for the volume of a sphere It's strange that Fermat's Library stated this since the formula for volume of sphere was discovered by Archimedes more than 2000 years ago. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_the_Sphere_and_Cylinder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_the_Sphere_and_Cylinder
- ColinWright 7y agoYes and no. My understanding is that Archimedes didn't, and never could have, produced the actual formula, because that way of writing formulas didn't exist. That's discussed in the sub-thread here: https://twitter.com/daveinstpaul/status/1213469023461138432 https://twitter.com/daveinstpaul/status/1213469023461138432 Additionally, the result was probably known before Archimedes, but again, writing that formula in that form probably didn't happen until Euler.
- quietbritishjim 7y agoThat tweet is merely about the way the formula was expressed, not about its mathematical content: > Archimedes discovered the formula many centuries before Euler, although he could not express it in modern algebraic notation. If Archimedes was able to express the formula in natural language (e.g. "take the radius of the hypersphere, multiply it by itself as many times as there are dimensions, ..." etc.) in a way that was unambiguously understood by other mathematicians (or natural philosophers) of the time, then that formula has definitely been discovered. Writing it in modern notation with one-character symbols for addition, multiplication (typically zero symbols!) etc. is nowhere near required for it to count as being discovered.
- Cybiote 7y agoYeah, the subtle difference is that discovering a geometric concept and being able to express it in a compact and flexible notation are not quite the same. It's very easy to take for granted the sheer amount of innovation and ideas that went into being able to express that formula just because they are grade school topics today. The concept and acceptance of irrational numbers, the relationship between geometry and algebra, the use of symbols in algebra and even assigning symbols for special real numbers took centuries and a steady stream of creative leaps of genius. An excellent and detailed explanation I highly recommend can be found here: https://hsm.stackexchange.com/a/1872 https://hsm.stackexchange.com/a/1872.
- ilovepyramids 7y agoVery interesting! It's not clear to me why it's so obvious that doubling the height of a pyramid while keeping the side constant would double the volume of the pyramid. The reason it is not obvious to me is that the proportions of the pyramid would change. The author of the post seems to think this is so obvious that it doesn't bear explanation. Can anyone explain to me why this works?
- ilovepyramids 7y agoOkay, maybe I can accept this readily. Easy enough to prove that doubling the height of a convex 2-d shape will double the area if you stretch all of its vertical proportions to double. If that shape is on a graph, the x axis is what it normally is, and the internal height of the shape for a given value of x is given by f(x), when you double the height it will be given by 2*f(x). The integral of a function times a constant is that constant times the integral of the function, so the area inside the shape would double. I don't remember multivariable at all, would someone be willing to offer a 3-d proof?
- ColinWright 7y agoImagine that the pyramid is made up of a very large number of very thin slices. Now take two copies of each slice ... they are thin enough that you really haven't changed the shape, except to double the height. You've doubled the height, and doubled the volume. It's a little like performing a riffle-shuffle on two identical packs of cards. If they aren't simply cuboids, but are identically interestingly shaped, riffling them together results in something that's the same shape, but twice the height. Does that help?
- ilovepyramids 7y agoTook me a moment. Interesting! So you're saying: Divide the pyramid into very thin slices, parallel to the base (horizontal). Above each slice, insert a duplicate of that slice. If using infinitely small slices, you have effectively doubled the height of the pyramid, and obviously you have doubled its volume. Yes, that makes sense, and I think it's very clever! Thank you.
- 7y ago
- magicalhippo 7y agoGeneralizations to higher dimensions[1] also have some fun properties. For one, the volume of a n-dimensional sphere (ball) goes to zero as n goes to infinity. But not in a trivial way: given a radius r, you can find the number of dimensions n that maximizes the volume of the n-sphere. For r=1 it's 5 dimensions, but for r=3 it's 55 dimensions. Numberphile[2] has a video on higher dimensional spheres which talks about this weirdness. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volume_of_an_n-ball https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volume_of_an_n-ball [2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mceaM2_zQd8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mceaM2_zQd8
- ironSkillet 7y ago> For one, the volume of a n-dimensional sphere (ball) goes to zero as n goes to infinity Just to provide extra clarity: for a fixed radius r, the volume goes to zero as n goes to infinity
- magicalhippo 7y agoYes important detail, was a bit sloppy there, thanks.
- Retric 7y agoI am going to sugest something about that analysis is flawed as r=1 is unit less. Suggesting measurements in feet and nD feet would favor 55d, but yards / nD yard would favor 3D. Though I just woke up so I may be missing something obvious.
- IgorPartola 7y agoThe idea is to measure relative sizes. So if your first sphere has radius r and the second sphere has radius R, where R = 3r, you can then reason about which n maximizes volume for each. Remember that volume is going to be in units of r (and R) to the power of n.
- vitus 7y agoA 5-dim yard and a 6-dim yard convert to a different number of n-dim feet (243 vs 729). - A 5-d sphere with R=1yd would have volume of ~5.264 yd^5 or 1279 ft^5. - A 6-d sphere with R=1yd would have volume of ~5.168 yd^6 or 3767 ft^6.
- zokier 7y agoHammer and nails, but to me the intuitive derivation of the volume formula would be through integration. Approximate slice of sphere as a cylinder, and sum up the volumes of those cylinders as their thickness approaches zero
- ColinWright 7y agoThis was all done before calculus had been developed, and the ideas here are clear precursors of the ideas later made precise by Newton and Leibniz. The intuitive derivation is by thin slices that are thin enough to see why it's true. The trained and sophisticated version is "Well, it's just calculus, isn't it."
- FabHK 7y agoAs an aside, if you take the area of a circle, A = pi r^2, and take the derivative wrt r, you get the circumference 2 pi r. Similarly, the derivative of the volume of a sphere, V = 4/3 pi r^3, is the surface area A = 4 pi r^2. It's sort of obvious, when you think about it, but it wasn't obvious to me before thinking about it :-)
- stevefan1999 7y agoYeah, back when I was first introduced to calculus and integration, I was surprised to see ∫4pir^2 dr = 4pi ∫r^2 dr = 4pi*r^3/3. Then I learnt about the Cavalieri's principle and it comes clear in mind.
- ColinWright 7y agoIt's cool ... I mention that in a different (but related) post here: https://www.solipsys.co.uk/new/ConsideringASphere.html#toc_name003 https://www.solipsys.co.uk/new/ConsideringASphere.html#toc_n...
- fctorial 7y agoIsn't it the case that integral of surface area is volume, that seems more obvious to me. The derivative happens to be reverse of integral and hence area happens to be derivative of volume.
- suifbwish 7y agoThe simplest way to get the volume of a sphere or any other solid 3d object under a certain size is to fill a bucket of water to the brim, put the object in until it is completely submerged, take it out, then measure how much water is now missing. Obviously only works with smaller objects.
- commandlinefan 7y agoBut you’d never get an exact measurement that way, since pi is irrational.
- bmm6o 7y agoThe precision of the instruments is a much bigger obstacle than the representation of the value. You would be just as uncertain that the unit cube has volume 1.000000...
- anonsivalley652 7y agoExperimentation can be an important tool in gathering data & error estimations to build and test a hypothesis. Reasoning is another way. There's no One True Way™ to solve a 3D geometry problem if the resulting hypothesis is demonstrably correct.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- arh68 7y agoWow, I might finally grok this. At h=0, the area of the dome's slice = the cylinder's slice (πRR). As h increases, the dome slice gets smaller, but by exactly πhh. I picture that smaller circle in the plane of my screen, perp to the dome slice. Somehow, for any given h, that πhh makes up for the lost area at the edge. The bit about the Hat Box theorem still just makes me blink.
- lurquer 7y agoI like his proof of a the volume of a cone. I usually considered it via Euclid XII, prop 7, which was always hard to visualize. Starting with 6 pyramids in a cube is ingenious. https://mathcs.clarku.edu/~djoyce/java/elements/bookXII/propXII7.html https://mathcs.clarku.edu/~djoyce/java/elements/bookXII/prop...
- bumbledraven 7y agoThe volume and surface area of a ball are about 1/2 that of the box it came in. This comes in handy for back-of-the-envelope calculations. Source: http://www.vendian.org/envelope/dir0/ballbox.html http://www.vendian.org/envelope/dir0/ballbox.html
- cmurf 7y agoMakes me think of the steradian. This is used in photometery for basic things like the lumen (1 lumen = 1 candela per steradian), where there's the concept of a light source emitting in all directions uniformly, and also what amounts of that arrive at what distances onto a surface, and what amounts are absorbed or reflected, and so on. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steradian https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steradian https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lumen_(unit) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lumen_(unit)
- censorshiptest 7y ago4/3pir^3