5 ms·
In Europe this would be very straightforward. The car is not "as described" in the sale. Return it to the dealer who has to make it right: add the missing featu
by Symbiote 7y ago
In Europe this would be very straightforward. The car is not "as described" in the sale. Return it to the dealer who has to make it right: add the missing feature, agree a discount, or give a full refund.
e.g. https://www.consumereurope.dk/menu/laws/danish-laws/danish-sale-of-goods-act/ https://www.consumereurope.dk/menu/laws/danish-laws/danish-s... § 42 onwards.
- yayr 7y agosame would apply to the sale between Tesla and dealer.
- greatjack613 7y agoof course, but the burden of proof is on the dealer
- eloisant 7y agoAnd I'm pretty sure Tesla will have lawyers who will pull their general sales conditions saying that the $8k self-driving option is a nominative, non-transferable software license and will likely win in court.
- papermachete 7y agoI'm not sure some EULA overpowers the law.
- tarsinge 7y agoAlso the validity of software EULA in the EU is still blurry for me (definitely not expert), to my knowledge they are not more enforceable than conditions of how you are permitted to use any object you bought. You own it, you are free to use it as you want basically (at least it was right during retail CD years). SaaS circumvent this because these are conditions to use a service.
- Hamuko 7y agoI don't think there's just one answer to EULA validity in the EU, but rather there's a bunch of shit in EULA's that is enforceable in the US but have absolutely no basis in all/some EU countries. For example, shrink wrap EULAs have not been considered binding here.
- huffmsa 7y agoAnd any lawyer who wasn't bottom of his graduating class will say they it's a one time upgrade, tied to that VIN, in the same way that an upgraded interior or larger set of wheels is. If this optional upgrade can be renegotiated at time of future sale, then any and all other upgrades must necessarily be renegotiable too. I don't think Tesla wants to have to replace interiors every time someone resells a vehicle.
- _ph_ 7y agoExcept that it is a transferable software license, as Tesla owners sell their cars regularly and of course the autopilot and the self-driving option stays active. Whatever exactly went wrong in this case, this has to be a very individual thing where it is unclear whether the car ever had a valid license for the autopilot.
- fxtentacle 7y agoThe whole approach of making software unsellable is very American. Here in Europe we have a guaranteed right to sell used software. For example, Autodesk turned their 3ds max from $5k once into a $6k annual subscription. As a result, people started buying used perpetual licenses to avoid the overpriced subscription. Autodesk is denying those used license transfers in the US, but they have to tolerate it in the EU. As a result, advertisement, movie and CGI studios in Europe gained a competitive advantage over US companies because the weak US laws failed to protect their own studios from predatory pricing. And for a CGI animator making $3k monthly, those $6k in annual software fees really add 16% to the gross price, so enough to drive customers elsewhere.
- anovikov 7y agoAnyone actually pays those exorbitant prices? I thought they were just for bribery-fueled wholesale deals, everyone else just pirates them. Know a lot of animators and no one ever paid for those.
- __m 7y agoI doubt that. Maybe they don’t have a license personally but the studio they work for sure has, or they are just one disgruntled employee away from getting a friendly reminder from Autodesk
- anovikov 7y agoLOL i know a media rendering farm, a big one, that uses pirated Adobe software of all kinds. Asked how do they deal with licensing they just say "but well we are a Russian company, we are not concerned with this, licensing is a Western concept". The notion of "registering an app" ("зарегистрировать приложение") in Russian means "finding a crack".
- retSava 7y agoIt's a lot of money, but if you are making a living professionally, in such a specialized profession too which can warrant charging more, you should pay for the tools you use. A plumber has the choice of buying the MegaPlumberPlus (making it up) for a high price but that makes them 10% more efficient, or weld together their Plumbathon. Doesn't matter what the cost of the MPP(tm) is, it can not justify stealing (pirating in sw) it. Not in a moral, nor legal way. For a private person doing private stuff on their own computer perhaps many would say morally this is grey, but if you live from it? Pay'em or don't use it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoThat's exactly how this should/would work in the US. I'm not sure why the owner didn't raise hell with the dealership when the car was not as described.
- zamalek 7y agoWhen you buy a car in America (some states?) you get a Lemon Law disclosure explaining your rights in these types of situations. The Tesla owner should be able to return the vehicle (I'm not sure if a refund for the feature alone is written into the law).