3 ms·
> The physical models we have are causal ones. The question is do you need a detailed causal explanation you can understand. In the case of lift, you can simu
by nabla9 7y ago
> The physical models we have are causal ones.
The question is do you need a detailed causal explanation you can understand.
In the case of lift, you can simulate aircraft model and calculate the change of vertical momentum in particles going above the wing and below the wing. Usually 80% of the lift comes from above the wing. If you are modelling a brick, it's the other way around. But do aircraft designers need to know that or are they just satisfied with less?
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoNo I don't think that is the question. The questions (plural) are whether you need detailed explanations or intuitively understandable explanations or explanations at all, as well as whether you have to build a detailed causal model or an intuitive causal model or establish causation at all. Aircraft designers are happy to test something in a wind tunnel and establish that the change in shape caused a change in performance. But they knew to try that particular new shape that because of all the physical (causal) models at various levels of intuitive understandability.
- joe_the_user 7y agoThe thing is the article is starting out with the sort of network of semi-causal explanations that aircraft designers have and pointing out that this isn't simple causality, isn't just a line of causal events. But then the article indeed jumps from that observation to the claim that causation isn't something we should worry about - which feels just wrong to me (and I think a lot of people). I mean, all sort of intuitive explanations feel like causal explanation but, of course, are much more sketchy. But this feeling like causality matters imo, the whole network of explanations that satisfy a human together seems to make things robust, not fragile, whereas AI predictions and models are renown for being fragile. But still, I think a big part of the situation is we haven't characterized fully what humans do here.
- taeric 7y agoThen would it be better to say that these models allow you to make causal changes? That is, sure, they don't tell you why the specific lift properties are there. However, they do enable a practitioner to make a change and know what impact it will have on the lift.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y ago>The thing is the article is starting out with the sort of network of semi-causal explanations that aircraft designers have and pointing out that this isn't simple causality, isn't just a line of causal events. I'd argue that it absolutely is simple causality. Sure we have to flail around in the dark a little to get to a better plane, but they physically test things during development. That's simple causality right there. I guess I'm arguing that engaging in active (not watching someone else do it) trial and error is a case of causal reasoning.