5 ms·
I don't understand the sarcasm: if teachers and mail carriers were liable when their pensions were invested in terrible things, they would demand more say in wh
by pessimizer 7y ago
I don't understand the sarcasm: if teachers and mail carriers were liable when their pensions were invested in terrible things, they would demand more say in where their pensions were invested.
- vorpalhex 7y agoThe police were unkind when they cuffed Ms. Wilson, and they ended her screaming and resisting by smacking her head into the classroom door. "That'll be enough of that! This is for all those dolphins you murdered with your oil spill!" The kindergarteners looked on in horror - they liked dolphins. They couldn't believe their teacher was a dolphin killer. "I swear, I just chose the default fund allocation! My rep said it was the most stable set of funds for retiring at 65!" Ms. Wilson made no attempt to choke back her tears. The officer was having none of that nonsense. "You should have been an active investor in your own future and chosen the 35/5 fund instead. I guess you'll have plenty of time to read up on retirement planning in the clink."
- luckydata 7y agoI’m sure sarcasm will fix the irreparable damage corporations are doing to society and the planet.
- bpt3 7y agoIt will do just as much good as the suggestion to hold individuals responsible for decisions they didn't make and in some cases have absolutely no control over (including the decision to invest in the company).
- luckydata 7y agoWhat if investing in a company was in fact an act that bears consequences? Would it make people invest more wisely in things that are less damaging? Would we hold corporations to a higher standard of responsibility? A faceless corporation won't keep you warm at night, no matter how much love you profess to them.
- vorpalhex 7y agoWhen you bought your shoes - regardless of which shoes you bought - you also contributed to 3M corporation, which makes the adhesive which holds almost every modern shoe together. When your paycheck is deposited, you used the ACH clearing houses propping up your bank's ability to make transfers. When you applied to buy a mortgage, or for renters insurance on your apartment, you supported credit check companies like Experian. Did you do this because you love Experian and 3M? Did you make a critical evaluation of each of their offerings, investments, subsidiaries, owners, share holders and stated outlooks? Did you factor the environmental impact of the aerosol which powers Super 77 glue when you decided to buy shoes? Since you're a major supporter of 3M and Experian, I assume you also attend their quarterly briefings by phone. Do you feel they will continue to act in an appropriate and moral way for the foreseeable future? If not, do you intend to return your shoes and find a new dwelling?
- bpt3 7y agoWell said.
- bpt3 7y ago> What if investing in a company was in fact an act that bears consequences? The investing market would shrink. > Would it make people invest more wisely in things that are less damaging? People are incapable of investing "wisely" enough in a company where they don't have any meaningful access to data or control over employee behavior, so I would say the answer to this is no. > Would we hold corporations to a higher standard of responsibility? Probably not, as holding corporations to a higher standard isn't really the job of individual, passive investors. Institutional investors might try, since they do so already, but you can see how successful that has been. > A faceless corporation won't keep you warm at night, no matter how much love you profess to them. I don't expect them to do so, so I'm think I'm fine here, but thanks so much for your concern.
- perl4ever 7y agoPeople rant and rave about government and corporations; about capitalism and socialism, but it's weird to me that people almost universally take sides. They are symbiotic, and their flaws are pretty much shared. You have any large organization and nobody has much influence over it; it mainly acts to preserve itself, and can cause all sorts of bad consequences. Criticizing government or capitalism makes it sound like there is some alternative, but it never quite comes into focus for me. Maybe it's because I can imagine going back to pre-modern times? Or, I should say, being left behind as one of the vast majority not suited to them.
- LeifCarrotson 7y agoThe rep wouldn't consider Exxon stable if it could result in their clients being cuffed.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoIt’s not necessarily about Exxon, but whatever company people do end up investing in. There’s no due diligence process that can guarantee a company never does and will never start doing bad things.
- bpt3 7y ago1. Teachers and mail carriers are by large incapable of adequately understanding what their pensions are invested in and each risk associated with each investment. 2. Individual teachers and mail carriers have literally no control over how their pensions are invested in most cases, so why should they be liable for those decisions?