4 ms·
Naysayers can CYA by saying “X will be difficult because of A, B, and C” rather than “X is impossible.” Seriously, it isn’t just CYA, but the former provides us
by seanmcdirmid 7y ago
Naysayers can CYA by saying “X will be difficult because of A, B, and C” rather than “X is impossible.” Seriously, it isn’t just CYA, but the former provides useful and perhaps actionable context while the latter doesn’t. The main issue with discarded feedback is when someone said X would be a problem, it was ignored, and X turned out to be a surprise problem (rather than an unsurprising one).
And then there is the opposite CmdrTaco comment, where he thought the lack of X (WiFi, larger storage) would be a problem and it wasn’t.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y agoThat's also true. In a transparent decision-making machine, hopefully the response is, "We think A will be a small problem, and B and C won't be a problem at all." Of course, we can still be wrong, no matter what form our decision-making process takes. Perhaps the group that set up this contest expected some PR risk, but didn't expect it to be as severe as it was. If they were not aware of the possibility of PR risk, that would indicate a pretty severe error in their thinking. But we just don't really know whether that's the case or not. It's not observable from outside the system.