9 ms·
Compare Google's system from five years ago.[1] (at 7:42) This new video is at n00b level compared to that. [1] https://embed.ted.com/talks/chris_urmson_how_a
by Animats 7y ago
Compare Google's system from five years ago.[1] (at 7:42)
This new video is at n00b level compared to that.
[1] https://embed.ted.com/talks/chris_urmson_how_a_driverless_car_sees_the_road https://embed.ted.com/talks/chris_urmson_how_a_driverless_ca...
- unityByFreedom 7y agoPlus Tesla still does not report disengagements to the CA dmv, right? It seems so strange to me that their HQ is there and they do not report any testing there.
- torpfactory 7y agoEither Tesla: (1) Call it a 'driver assist system' and carry that definition beyond all reasonable bounds. I've read the regulation, I don't think that defense would stand up in court. (2) Does physical testing somewhere other than California. The testing regulation is fairly onerous, and I could see them saying 'nah' we'll do this in Arizona, Nevada, etc. You're right they don't report disengagements, but they still maintain a autonomous test vehicle permit in the state, according to the DMV website. Very strange indeed. I think (2) is probably right.
- omgwtfbyobbq 7y agoIt'a (1). For Reporting Year 2018, Tesla did not test any vehicles on public roads in California in autonomous mode or operate any autonomous vehicles, as defined by California law. As such, the Company did not experience any autonomous mode disengagements as part of the Autonomous Vehicle Tester Program in California. https://electrek.co/2019/02/13/tesla-autonomous-mileage-california-report-full-self-driving/ https://electrek.co/2019/02/13/tesla-autonomous-mileage-cali...
- unityByFreedom 7y agoThey actively avoid reporting test results in CA. Nothing about that changes due to semantics (your #1) or if they test elsewhere (your #2).
- pbreit 7y agoWhy is that strange? Does Tesla strike you as conventional?
- unityByFreedom 7y agoIt strikes me as evasive.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sosodev 7y agoWow. This is what I’d expect from a large company. Full 3D representations with super smooth object recognition. Tesla’s looks like a student project compared to that. Although I wonder which is more truthful. I bet Google’s demo takes significantly more computing power, was cleaned up for the demo, etc
- cogman10 7y agoThis is sort of a natural consequence of LIDAR. Turning point clouds into objects is child's play compared to plucking objects out of cameras.
- pmarreck 7y agoI was waiting to see if someone would post this. And that was 5 years ago.
- coherentpony 7y agoHow much of the Google video is eyecandy versus actual processing imagery?
- VvR-Ox 7y agoFake it until you make it ;-) That reminds me of all the "AI power" we already use which is backed by low-wage contract workers who listen in.
- monk_e_boy 7y agoGoogle search was curated by humans for a long time. Last guy I met who was doing it, now works for an SEO firm. Things like house insurance, medical insurance etc is highly hand tweaked.
- virtualritz 7y agoThe camera is bird's eye on the google presentation. And it is a recording. So jitter/flicker can be cleaned up/smoothed out and the data can be massaged in ways that a real time system may not be able to do. This is a presentation. I'd be /very/ surprised if this animation was from RAW data as-is. Also there seems to be Lidar data (point clouds) which Tesla doesn't have. So while this means bounding boxes may have less detail in Tesla's system this is not an issue as long as they are not smaller than the physical object. Having worked in the automotive space in the last five years and seen lots of those I'd not say one is less impressive than the other.
- m463 7y agoIt diminishes the comparison when just the lidar for a waymo car costs more than the entire tesla vehicle. So, not only can you afford a tesla vehicle, you can go out and buy one today.
- keenmaster 7y agoLIDAR will get cheaper and smaller though. I think Tesla’s argument that cameras+ML+tons of data>LIDAR is more compelling.
- iamaelephant 7y agoCan you go out and buy a fully self driving Tesla today? Because that would be the relevant comparison.
- Veedrac 7y agoNote that Google's system operates in pre-mapped areas and uses lidar.
- iamaelephant 7y agoSo it operates under the conditions that we expect the commercially available product to operate under? Yeah cool thanks for the caveat.
- laichzeit0 7y agoSo where can I buy a Google car today?
- pbreit 7y agoNo, it operates in an infintessimaly small test area.
- yogrish 7y agoPlease understand, Tesla works only with only Camera & Radars (at L2 level). Where as Google Waymo works with pretty expensive and lot of redundant sensors ie., 360degree LIDAR, cameras & Radars (at L4 level). Tesla sells vehicles in volumes, Waymo doesn't (as it is exhorbitant). Hence comparison is not apple to apple. I do agree Visualisation in the google video is more appealing. I assume Tesla also has state of art visualations for their algo development.
- soperj 7y agothey're only redundant if it's actually working and they're not necessary. Nothing is actually working right now in terms of actually self driving the car. So little early to say redundant.
- ec109685 7y agoWhat are these levels you are referring to? We drive just fine with two cameras.
- ygra 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-driving_car#Classification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-driving_car#Classificatio...
- ec109685 7y agoThat doesn’t have anything to do with the technology used to implement it. I might have mis understood the OP’s point with their parenthetical remarks.
- imtringued 7y agoAnd two actuators in every eye ball and two big actuators between the head and the main body.
- ec109685 7y agoBecause our field of view stinks.
- adrr 7y agoWaymo is at least 5 years ahead of Tesla. They are running driverless self driving cars already on city streets. My Model 3 can’t even navigate a parking a lot half the time I use the summon feature.
- sytelus 7y agoQuick question: if you summon Model 3 and car gets in an accident, would Tesla pay for the repairs?
- jaxn 7y agoNo. You agree that you are in control of the car.
- nostoc 7y agoHow do you control the car if you're not even in it?
- MarioMan 7y agoIf you release the summon button, the car comes to a stop. You are supposed to be able to see the car visually at all times so you can release the summon button and avoid problems.
- jaxn 7y agoIn addition to stopping when releasing the button, it also shows you the path it plans to take on a satellite map on your phone. So you know where it is going. Some people have problems with it, but it works great for me. It's pretty awesome to have the car pull up to me on a rainy day. Part of it is parking in a smart place on the way in.
- sgerenser 7y agoThis already happened several times after they first rolled out the feature a few months ago (minor accidents). No, Tesla did not pay (nor would I expect them to).
- travisoneill1 7y agoI don't think that the videos contain the information necessary to make this judgment.
- pbreit 7y agoA simulation vs actual?
- _pmf_ 7y agoWell, there's no harm for Google in publishing more since the project will inevitably be "sunset" and is an uneconomical research prototype, while Tesla's is a production version that people actually use.
- legel 7y ago"Inside Waymo's Secret World for Training Self-Driving Cars" -The Atlantic https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/08/inside-waymos-secret-testing-and-simulation-facilities/537648/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/08/insid... This was a really really good read, especially into how Waymo simulations could generate data like seen in this video. It's from 2017 but still an extraordinary article for the quality of engineering insight.
- pritovido 7y agoOn the contrary. When you know the Tesla system is running on real time on a hardware accelerated card IN the car, it becomes way more impressive than a google presentation made with supercomputers after a long time of processing.
- thdrdt 7y agoAfter seeing reviews of the Tesla Autopilot vs Openpilot it became clear to me it is way to early to trust Tesla's Autopilot (and Openpilot). They both use visuals only and are easily confused when situations are a little different than 'normal'. I even think Openpilot performed a little better than Autopilot but because Openpilot only has a forward looking camera it fails often on tight corners. Google on the other hand is aware of the complete 3D surrounding. So even if road marks are gone or are unclear it still can estimate where the vehicle should be on the road.
- jiofih 7y agoTesla’s system can still estimate where the car should be without markings, just like humans do with their vision.
- thdrdt 7y agoWell it you look at some videos you can see that there are times Tesla thinks repair lines are road marks especially when the sun is reflected by the lines. When the car has no real idea of its position in 3D space this gives problems.
- jiofih 7y agoSame as humans, except it has GPS, radar and other sensors to help.
- jiofih 7y agoYour comment makes no sense. Besides the fact that this is showing Lidar scans with depth and 3D textures (does look cooler), the relevant part which is feature detection is a lot poorer. It doesn’t seem to detect lane markers or boundaries, sidewalks, traffic signs, or show path estimates like you can clearly see in the Tesla video. Plus the texturing implies the route is pre-mapped while Autopilot is doing all the work in real time.
- hokkos 7y agoIn the Waymo video there are vector narrow lines added on top of the broken white line of the image view, there are also a vector boundary of the centered line and boundaries, and 3D box for cones. You are clearly not looking closely enough, or might not want to.
- PietdeVries 7y agoBut still - there are Tesla's driving everywhere, including ones with autopilot enabled, and I have yet to see the first Waymo car on the road... The technology might be/seem superior, commercially Tesla has cleary won the race..
- aguyfromnb 7y ago>Tesla has cleary won the race.. But Waymo is pilot-testing autonomous taxis and Teslas have a "greater than zero chance" of making it to your destination without intervention.
- Infinitesimus 7y agoFirst Mover Advantage is still pretty important though. Tesla is selling cards today, Waymo is not. Tesla's cars are good-enough for most of the buyers so Waymo's technical superiority has to bs much much better warrant the attention and change in public perspective. On very important thing is tesla has established that your will get better with software updates over time. Other cars have nice adaptive cruise control and self-driving tech but the thought that the car you bought today can in a few months drive better is a massive psychological advantage imo. I don't think Waymo can compete on self-driving features anymore. They have to make the better car and driving experience as a holistic package to stick
- unexaminedlife 7y agoI have mixed feelings about this. I realize the number and types of sensors that exist in Waymo's cars provide far more data to the driverless car. But then when I really think about it, humans have been driving with only 2 sensors (eyes) for a long time with relatively good success. With the improvement of computer algorithms to help the cars make better decisions than humans, I'm not 100% sure if the long-term solution will require all the extra sensors. My guess is the added sensors may get Waymo to market sooner, but if Tesla can commoditize this technology for far cheaper they will win in the end.
- lawlessone 7y ago>humans have been driving with only 2 sensors (eyes) for a long time with relatively good success. 1.25 million die a year in road accidents. We should try to do better than human.
- prestonh 7y agoSure, but if we can match that number of fatalities with self driving cars it will inarguably be a success from a utilitarian standpoint.
- vbezhenar 7y agoBut also keeping speed high enough. You won't have many fatal road accidents with speed limited to 5 km/h. But it won't be very useful transportation. Those timid cars might be safer but people might prefer more aggressive style to reduce travel time.
- vbezhenar 7y agoHumans also have 20+ years of experience living in human society. You need to develop AI as strong as humans to match that.