13 ms·
Crema Coffee in San Jose Closes Due to ADA Lawsuit
- brians 7y agoPredatory? I don’t see the problem with demanding these businesses, or their landlords, comply with the law to make them accessible.
- devnulloverflow 7y ago> comply with the law It's not a defense of a bad law to say that it forces people to by "comply with the law".
- lallysingh 7y agoExactly! The lawsuits are what's supposed to happen.
- Sebguer 7y agoSeriously. What a bizarre narrative to push.
- blakesterz 7y agoThe problem, according to the article isn't that, it's some law firms are doing this in a predatory way. "But in California unscrupulous lawyers bypass the law’s good intentions by taking advantage of the state’s generous payouts to disabled individuals who sue, often targeting hundreds of small businesses at once, according to Sacramento-based small business defense attorney Rick Morin. For many ADA cases, the minimum in statutory damages starts at $4,000."
- erobbins 7y agoDo you believe this person suffered $60k in damages by not being able to buy a coffee?
- erichocean 7y ago*By not being able to buy coffee from the vendor at this particular location, instead of the ADA-compliant location two blocks away…
- wlesieutre 7y agoIt’s not necessarily about how much damages they suffered. Statutory damages also serve as a deterrent and a way of motivating plaintiffs to pursue ADA compliance suits. In CA’s cast it looks like statutory damages are up to 3x the damages, with a minimum of $4000. That minimum can apply multiple times, as in Hubbard v. Twin Oaks Health and Rehabilitation. >Plaintiff asserts that, because the minimum statutory amount is $4,000.00 per violation, and she encountered the architectural barriers a minimum of 15 times, she is entitled to damages in the amount of $60,000. Given that defendant does not present any viable evidence to the contrary, plaintiff will be awarded the statutory minimum of $4,000.00 per violation, totaling $60,000. https://www.leagle.com/decision/20041331408fsupp2d92311235 https://www.leagle.com/decision/20041331408fsupp2d92311235
- Dylan16807 7y agoThe question is whether they were being predatory. Visiting 15 times to put a multiplier on statutory damages, which were already 500x the actual damage, is predatory. $4000 is a nice kick in the pants but there should be a large delay before the same person can get a second instance of statutory payout, if ever.
- kube-system 7y agoIf businesses only had to pay the actual provable amount of damages caused by non-compliance, few businesses would find it remotely worthwhile to comply. That's why the ADA allows for more.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- stanferder 7y agoWhen one person associated with the attorney is a plaintiff in 200 lawsuits, it does start to seem opportunistic. Nevertheless, I can't understand why someone would open a cafe in 2007 at a site that wasn't compliant with a 1990 law without budgeting for bringing it into compliance.
- Pfhreak 7y ago> When one person associated with the attorney is a plaintiff in 200 lawsuits, it does start to seem opportunistic. Wait, why? Certainly one would expect that a lawyer might have a specialization, say, ADA compliance. And you'd equally expect that a person in a wheelchair who is more likely to notice/care about ADA compliance. It doesn't strike me as that odd, it just seems like, "Hey, why is the city I live in so busted for me? I thought there was a law that was supposed to give me access? Why is no one paying attention to that law?"
- oh_sigh 7y agoBecause the lawyer allegedly had her ex-husband pretend to be disabled in order to file the lawsuits. Lawsuits require standing, which is defined as basically injury or adverse effect done to the suing party. Without that, you cannot sue(and expect to win).
- Pfhreak 7y agoThat's a different concern though. 200 lawsuits in and of itself isn't a problem. Pretending to be disabled to try and get standing is.
- oh_sigh 7y agoOP said it starts to seem opportunistic, which I think is true, even if the party is actually disabled. Because the odds that a regular disabled person would encounter 200 unique buildings over a year that they couldn't access because of their disability seems quite slim. And the opportunistic part comes in because these lawsuits are almost always "Fix the problem for $5*X, or pay me personally $X and I will drop the suit".
- c0restraint 7y agoYes, predatory. From the article: > The disabled man’s attorney, Tanya E. Moore, for years has been the subject of much scrutiny for suing thousands of small businesses across the South Bay, filing more than 1,400 ADA cases in recent years. The suits have forced mom and pop shops like Cafe Crema to close, as many owners can’t afford to bring their businesses up to code or settle. A little less than three years ago, a beloved San Jose staple, Time Deli, had to shut its doors for the same reason. > About two years ago, Moore was faced with a federal racketeering civil lawsuit for filing lawsuits based on “false allegations” of disability and injury, first reported by the Fresno Bee. I wonder how many businesses will be left when Moore is done.
- Pfhreak 7y agoI don't see anything predatory there? 1,400 businesses were potentially breaking the law and denying access to people with disabilities, shouldn't they be the subject of suits?
- BoorishBears 7y agoIf you don't see the problem, that's intentional. How many ADA complainants end up facing federal racketeering charges?
- wpietri 7y agoThe theory of the ADA is that rather than just enforce everything via bureaucracy, we'd give individuals the right of private action to push for the accommodations they need. Then we get a hopefully-good level of accommodation without a lot of the kind of waste that goes with central planning. But if somebody is going to use the legal system to make a lot of money by generating spurious complaints for every business in an area, then that's not the right mechanism. If every business should be immediately compliant, we should just make it part of the building code and/or part of the business licensing process.
- Pfhreak 7y agoAre there federally enforced building codes?
- awinder 7y agoWhat is being labeled as predatory was the scheme being led that had the lawyers husband fake a disability in order to launch these lawsuits (200 in one year, over 2000 total). And that it was specifically targeted at small businesses of a size/condition that they would really be susceptible to the lawsuits. There was also some light witness tampering and evidence destruction as a part of the RICO case against this attorney, so yeah, I think in this one case, there really was some wild stuff going on.
- Pfhreak 7y agoIn this case the specific lawsuit against this coffeeshop was labeled predatory which was filed by "a disabled San Jose man", which seems to be someone other than the attorney's ex husband Ronald.
- wang_li 7y agoThey're apparently asking for something on the order of $60,000 for not being able to go into a cafe and get a cup of coffee. That seems quite far beyond the damages incurred. sounds predatory to me.
- astura 7y agoThat is statutory damages, not compensatory damages. Statutory damages are written into the statue, not a payment for damages actually incurred. The ADA is mostly enforced by private plaintiffs, that's the way the law was written. Nationally the ADA doesn't allow for private plaintiffs to profit from ADA lawsuits, however, a few states (like California) have statutes that do. Of course, a big problem is the businesses don't have a mandatory warning with a grace period to become compliant, it's just now you have a lawsuit. This can create "professional plaintiffs." Then again, the ADA is a civil rights law, and other civil rights laws aren't like that, you don't get "one free racial discrimination," and I don't think that many people would want that.
- wang_li 7y ago
- wpietri 7y agoI don't think there's anything wrong with customers demanding ADA compliance. But the accusation here is that the lawyer involved is creating rafts of complaints, possibly false ones, to extract settlement cash. That would indeed be predatory. I think the ADA on the whole is good, but the burden can fall disproportionately on small businesses. An awful lot of people's favorite neighborhood businesses are more or less break even; as here, a sudden, large expense can be fatal. I'd prefer it if there were programs to help existing small businesses convert. Making society available to everybody is everybody's business.
- zip1234 7y agoYes, it sounds like in this case there is systematic targeting of certain sized businesses in order to extract the maximum amount of cash. Big companies can afford compliance and lawyers. The little companies may not be able to.
- jxramos 7y agoMight even be a business possibility for someone knowledgeable with the law and how to demonstrate objective compliance. I thought in an earlier comment maybe a chamber of commerce could develop something, or some locals with disabilities who would like to be part of the process and maybe even used as witnesses.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- triceratops 7y agoYes and no. Businesses that aren't ADA-compliant are violating the law. But the motives of many of those filing are also suspect. From the article: "The disabled man’s attorney, Tanya E. Moore, for years has been the subject of much scrutiny for suing thousands of small businesses across the South Bay, filing more than 1,400 ADA cases in recent years...The attorney who filed the lawsuit, Moji Saniefar, claims Moore’s ex-husband Ronald, who is a plaintiff in more than 200 filed cases, faked a disability in order “to collect quick settlements." So in this case, the filing attorney is being sued for fraud? (I'm not a lawyer). Not a good look. But going on.. "...in California unscrupulous lawyers bypass the law’s good intentions by taking advantage of the state’s generous payouts to disabled individuals who sue, often targeting hundreds of small businesses at once, according to Sacramento-based small business defense attorney Rick Morin. For many ADA cases, the minimum in statutory damages starts at $4,000." Sounds like patent troll tactics. Damages large enough to add up to serious money at scale, but small enough that they aren't worth fighting for the defendant. "These “shakedown” lawsuits, added Morin, are often based on small, “technical violations” that can be easily fixed if a letter is sent to the business owner. But under California law, a disabled person cannot claim money if they send the business owner a letter with their complaint first." Which means the money is more important than fixing anything. A business that couldn't afford to become ADA-compliant can definitely not afford to fix it after paying a settlement. And it's very well possible that money that could have gone into fixing the problem for all future disabled customers (surely the actual point of the law) is instead going to attorneys and plaintiffs. Bottomline: no one comes out looking good in this particular case. If this cafe's ADA retrofit is going to cost $100k then it wasn't an easy fix and the business owner should have done better research into the law before renting/buying that location. But there also seems to be a non-zero number of BS lawsuits incentivized by the way the law is right now.
- BurningFrog 7y agoWhat you hear from people "on the ground" is that ADA is written in a way that makes it very difficult to comply with. An experienced ADA "predator" can find some technical violation in most any place of business, and make a profit suing for it. Normally, these technical flaws have no real impact on accessibility for actual disabled people. It's just a legal quirk. Or so I've read/heard in a few places. I have no personal insight, so take this post FWIW!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- eadmund 7y agoThis is what is known in the common law as barratry: lawsuits filed not for justice but for profit.
- 1-6 7y agoYup, it sounds similar to an ABC7 investigation over another man who sues over 100 businesses over ADA violations. https://abc7.com/723665/ https://abc7.com/723665/
- jonathankoren 7y agoDo any of these businesses contest the facts of the case? I'm unaware of any that do, but I don't follow ADA cases very closely. So is the outrage is more that someone is advocating for compliance with the law, by bringing civil suits... as required to enforce the law? Did this "serial plantiff" hit a quota limit or something? I understand the empathy with the business, but I don't understand the animus towards the disabled person.
- mlyle 7y agoThe disabled person works with a serial litigator to sue. They might win $4k in damages. If they do, serial litigator is able to recover attorney's fees which can top $200k. Serial litigator can demand a $50k settlement rather than you spending $100k defending and risking being $304k out of pocket in total. Thus, it's possible to extract settlements far beyond any actual damages incurred by the disabled person. This is what makes it a shakedown operation.
- jonathankoren 7y agoBut the business isn’t in compliance, right? The “shakedown” doesn’t work if the building is compliant, right?
- Dylan16807 7y agoWhy 'but'? It's not like any of that money goes toward making the business compliant.
- pbuzbee 7y ago$100,000 to replace stairs with a wheel chair ramp? Were more fixes necessary than just this, or is that really how much it costs to create a wheel chair ramp?
- Pfhreak 7y agoIt looks like they'd have to redo a significant portion of the front of the building to make it work, from the street up to the patio, then up again to the door. (Which, itself, may need replacing.) My guess is that $100,000 is a rounded up, order of magnitude estimate rather than a specific amount.
- rauhl 7y agoEven for California that seems a bit … steep (pun intended). Sure, there’s a relatively high minimum wage. And maybe one has to get planning approval. And maybe an engineer’s sign-off. And possibly get some sort of union labour force to install it. And maybe an environmental impact study? Still doesn’t make sense that a wheelchair ramp would incur three times the U.S. median income. Or maybe it does, and that explains why it’s so difficult to get anything done.
- duskwuff 7y agoFrom the pictures in the article, it looks like there are at least two flights of stairs involved, and the one near the door is too narrow to add a ramp that a wheelchair can climb. (Simply putting a ramp over the stairs wouldn't cut it; it'd be too steep to roll up.) I can certainly imagine how adding ramps to this building approach could require some major restructuring.
- crooked-v 7y agoEven motorized weatherproofed wheelchair lifts cost an order of magnitude less than that.
- bluedino 7y agoYou also need to redo things like the bathrooms.
- morio 7y ago
- intopieces 7y agoHeadline is misleading due to last paragraph: “While the 950 Alameda location permanently closed Friday, coffee aficionados can visit the other Cafe Crema location at 1202 Alameda. ” One has to wonder whether this was anticipated given the new location is 2 blocks away.
- CaliforniaKarl 7y agoI'm pretty sure that is not true, because (as someone who has been to both locations) the original location was too busy. The staff I talked to at the second location also told me that the second location was opened because the first location was so busy. And the article references this also: "Over the years, the shop grew into a well-recognized brand, leading Tran to open another location down the street in 2017."
- DataWorker 7y agoBut she can’t afford to comply with laws and regulations that all other business owners must? 100k for a wheelchair ramp? Come on.
- intopieces 7y agoI doubt the case is that the business couldn’t come up with the money - she could have taken a loan, for example - but more likely it just wasn’t worth the investment given the success of the much larger location within walking distance.
- blaser-waffle 7y agoAs mentioned above, it may be a 60k to settle, 100k+ to build something compliant, or close down (and maybe move to another location). It's not hard to see why it's not worth the investment. Shut it down, take the breach of contract hit on the rent, and then use that would-be-ADA-compliance loan to pick up at a different location.
- ngneer 7y agoNot an expert, but $100K claimed by the owner seems rather much. A third party assessment would be good to procure. Given the touted popularity, cost would be amortized, too. Maybe the owner derived what they had hoped out of the business.
- Nightshaxx 7y agoShe mentioned the building is old. Maybe there are other structural issues that would be brought up if a ramp was installed that would have to be delt with. I don't know though, it's just a guess.
- haroldl 7y agoAgreed. "Crema Coffee owner June Tran said bringing her 100-year-old building up to code would cost $100,000." Bringing a 100-year-old building up to code != installing a ramp.
- BurningFrog 7y agoBut you need a building permit to install a ramp, and that may come with a requirement to bring it up to code.
- mondoshawan 7y agoThen she was already willfully ignorant of the law when she started, long before ADA got involved.
- CaliforniaKarl 7y agoBesides the ramp, the other big thing (from a customer's perspective) would be the bathroom. This business was basically in a converted house. So the existing "half-bath" would probably not be large enough for ADA standards (with enough room for someone in a wheelchair to enter, close the door, transfer to the toilet, etc.).
- codezero 7y ago
- nmfisher 7y agoIt costs $100,000 to build a ramp? That sounds insane (or an outright lie - unless I'm just that out-of-touch with construction costs?).
- sk5t 7y agoRamps are surprisingly space-consuming, and might involve reconfiguring doorways, gas lines or meters, water, electrical, mucking about with the sidewalk, building railings and supports, and so on. $100k seems entirely possible in a dense, expensive city. And you might be required to build a masonry ramp. On the other hand, building a compliant wooden ramp to the porch of a woodsy roadhouse might be far less costly.
- oh_sigh 7y agoClearly the ADA lawsuits are weaponized by people looking for quick paydays via settlements, but on the other hand, this building is clearly not accessible, and it isn't just a "small, “technical violation” that can be easily fixed if a letter is sent to the business owner". I think the real question is - why do purchasers not fold ADA costs into their asking price for old buildings? This building has not been ADA compliant since before the current owner bought it. She(or her agent) should have been aware that they should actually be getting a $100k discount on the building if she needs to install ramps there to make it legal to run a business.
- alistairSH 7y agoYes, but the best (most benefit to society) solution is likely building inspectors verifying compliance when buildings/business change hands. Not plantiffs demanding sums of money to be paid personally that could be put towards the remediation.
- oh_sigh 7y agoI completely agree. The fact that a complainant can demand money to drop the suit on a personal payment seems wrong - I would like to see either reasonable damages(I couldn't enter the coffee shop so my friend had to go in for me - $10 damages), or only allow payoffs to be put into a general ADA fund and not go to enrich the individual.
- ApolloFortyNine 7y agoIt seems to me so few people were affected (there was another branch blocks away that was accessible even) that they were able to go 13 years without a complaint.
- nwallin 7y agoADA, Americans with Disabilities Act. Not Ada the programming language. I was expecting some bizarre coffee/Java riff with I dunno, TLD Systems or something.
- zcase 7y agoHere's the suit PDF if anyone wants to read. https://www.sanjoseinside.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/Crema-ADA-Lawsuit-2018.pdf https://www.sanjoseinside.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/Cre... The message seems to be: this is a nice thing, I can't readily access it, so nobody should have it. Like the kid taking his ball away after losing at soccer. Except this is someone else's ball? Open to changing my view
- percentcer 7y agoThis American Life did a segment on it. I'm still not sure if I agree with the approach: https://www.thisamericanlife.org/415/crybabies/act-three-0 https://www.thisamericanlife.org/415/crybabies/act-three-0
- Pfhreak 7y agoThe alternative is that the kid never has to share their ball with people with disabilities? I think everyone's ideal outcome is that the business makes itself accessible.
- samcal 7y agoComparing being in a wheelchair to losing at soccer seems reductive to me. Being in a wheelchair is completely life-changing and having public spaces being accessible is a very good thing for the quality of life of people being in this terrible situation. The ADA has dramatically improved accessibility for those with mobility impairments: " When asked whether access to public facilities had improved, 75 percent or more of respondents in 1994, 1998, and 2000 reported that they had perceived improvement. Not surprisingly, the percentage of people with disabilities going out to restaurants regularly has increased from 34 percent in 1986 to 57 percent in 2004."[0] [0]: https://ncd.gov/rawmedia_repository/f493e262_8a9e_49c8_ad84_404a1b91d7c3.pdf https://ncd.gov/rawmedia_repository/f493e262_8a9e_49c8_ad84_... pg 45
- imgabe 7y agoHaving access to facilities is very important, but that is not what was achieved here. Now the facility is gone and nobody can access it. If the goal was to increase access to this facility, it failed miserably.
- booleandilemma 7y agoAs someone with a relative who is handicapped I have little sympathy for businesses that aren’t ADA compliant.
- codezero 7y agoI could have sworn that ADA had provisions to protect buildings that were older and where upgrades would be too costly to implement. This sounds like that is the case... What am I missing?
- msherry 7y ago> And contrary to most business owners’ beliefs, older buildings are not “grandfathered” into the ADA and are susceptible to these lawsuits.
- astura 7y agoSeems complicated...??? https://www.burnhamnationwide.com/final-review-blog/a-misunderstood-area-of-ada-compliance-existing-facilities https://www.burnhamnationwide.com/final-review-blog/a-misund... >Title III also specifically states that for public accommodations discrimination includes “failure to remove architectural barriers . . . in existing facilities” unless it can be shown that removing a barrier is “not readily achievable” or accommodations cannot be provided through other means. (See 42 U.S.C. Section 12182(b)(2)(iv)&(v)) >The ADA defines readily achievable as “easily accomplishable and able to be carried out without much difficulty or expense.” The statutory definition also provides factors to be considered in determining whether barrier removal is readily achievable and recognizes what may be achievable for one business might not be for another: >The nature of cost of the required barrier removal; >The financial resources of the involved facility or facilities; >The number of people employed by the facility; >The effect on the facility’s expenses and resources; >Impact on the operation of the facility; >Overall finances of the covered entity; >The number of employees in the covered entity; >The number type and location of its facilities; >The type of operations of the covered entity, including the composition, structure and functions of its workforce; and >The geographic, administrative or fiscal relationship of the facilities at issue to the covered entity. >(See 42 U.S.C. Section 12181(9))
- ThrustVectoring 7y agoYou have to spend high five figures in legal fees to adjudicate that, and you may lose anyway, and even if you win someone else can swoop in and re-litigate things.
- brudgers 7y agoThirteen years ago ADA had been law for sixteen years. The owner ignored it from day one. The owner had 13 years to bring the cafe into compliance.
- nkrisc 7y agoAnd in all that time they may have never been able to afford it. Perhaps the city should just demolish the building and build an ADA-compliant one on the taxpayer's dime.
- mondoshawan 7y agoOr maybe, here's an idea: crowdfund from the community and make a big deal out of it. You get good PR, which drives the business, and it makes lives better as you improve the premises. Can't crowdfund? How about a short term loan? Can't do that? How about looking for a location for your less than profitable location? Can't do that? How about fighting to change the building laws in San Jose to reduce the building costs for ADA? There hare hundreds of options available to the business owners up front. This keeps happening because they are willfully ignorant of the law of the land and refuse to do anything about it until someone decides to sue.
- brudgers 7y agoSuppose the shop sells one item per minute, is open twelve hours a day, and six days a week. Allocating $0.10 per item is $6.00 per hour, $72.00 per day, and $21,000.00 per year. Over 13 years, that's more than a quarter million dollars and more than twice the claimed cost of the ramp. For context, we are talking a dime per item in Silicon Valley. Per this website, a small cup of coffee is $2.00. https://zmenu.com/crema-coffee-roasting-co-san-jose-online-menu/ https://zmenu.com/crema-coffee-roasting-co-san-jose-online-m...
- nkrisc 7y ago10 cents might very well be the margin on a cup of coffee. But from the little I know of the food service industry, that might be generous.
- reverend_gonzo 7y agoA question, if there is someone that can answer this: It said her options were either build a ramp for $100k or settle for $60k. Who can she settle with, and who agrees that she doesn’t need to build a ramp anymore? What happens if someone else comes along and wants a ramp?
- tylerrobinson 7y agoThe article addresses this. The business owner says even if she could settle, nothing prevents her from being sued again.
- astura 7y agoIf someone else comes around wanting a ramp they get to sue too. >Tran said. “And even if we settle, there’s always the risk of someone else coming around and suing us again.”
- 55555 7y agoCan someone explain to me why a ramp costs $100k?
- reaperducer 7y agoI don't know anything about the building, but I can easily see how that could happen. Lawyers. Architects. Permits. Construction. Traffic control during construction. Environmental studies. Heck, even archeological studies if it's the right area. Maybe even soil remediation if it's determined there's anything below the ramp, like oil or radon, or who knows what. Plus, if any of it touches the sidewalk, you might have to pay the city rent every month for as long as the building stands.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoOr, put plywood over half those steps? Probably its not the steps - its the doorway being rebuilt. On a historic building.
- droithomme 7y agoThe ADA is a terrible law that should be repealed. It is primarily used by these serial lawsuit trolls for their own payday. New built businesses should be build to comply with the building code at the time, which can include disabled access. Older businesses can be upgraded, at taxpayer expense, if that's what the government wants. It's insane and a violation of basic property rights to force business owners to upgrade older buildings at their own cost.
- rolleiflex 7y agoOn one hand, this happens, on the other, I use hearing aids and I cannot get Apple to give me a receipt for my AppleCare payment because the only way to get that is to call an internal Apple department, and that department has no email, no TTY, nothing but a phone number. I cannot call phones. And Apple doesn’t care. What are you going to do, sue them for ADA violations? That’s only for mom-and-pop coffee shops. ADA has a purpose. However, it should be limited to corporations above a certain revenue (like how GDPR is limited) and the cost of non-compliance drastically increased. At this point, Apple can afford to be non-compliant while this coffee shop has to close, which is the worst of all possible worlds.
- mixmastamyk 7y ago> And Apple doesn’t care. What are you going to do, sue them for ADA violations? Yes, maybe small claims is enough to provoke a response.
- rolleiflex 7y agoIn my understanding small claims requires demonstrable financial loss - something that is more like an unpaid invoice.
- BubRoss 7y agoSo you were told this when you talked to a lawyer?
- jkaplowitz 7y agoUsually, it requires that the relief sought be solely money damages (as opposed to e.g. an injunction), not that the money damages come from a loss per se.
- gnicholas 7y agoHow is this possible? I've gotten paper receipts when purchased in store and email receipts when purchased online. How did this fall through the cracks at POS?
- frandroid 7y agoWhat I'm trying to figure out is how is this not the landlord's responsibility rather than the commercial tenant's?
- thedance 7y agoVirtually all business leases are "triple net", with the tenant being on the hook for every expense from taxes to casualty to maintenance and improvements. Commercial landlords aren't some kind of essential component of American capitalism, they are just jerks who live at the beach and have no skin in the game.
- WheelsAtLarge 7y agoPeople get upset over this kind of cases but not being able to access a business is as discriminatory as the business shutting the door to someone because there's something the business does not like about that person. Discrimination is discrimination. The ADA act has made a huge difference in people's lives since it's passage in the '90s. We see these stories over and over which, is important to keep in mind, the exception not the rule. The majority of buildings are built ADA compliant now and most older buildings can be modified relatively inexpensively. Yes, this was the exception but even, in this case, the business was merged with another local building. One thing people always forget is that we all get old and many of us will end up with mobility limitations and we will be glad that a business is ADA compliant and we have the ability to access it.
- gpm 7y agoLike the ADA or not, this sentence is not true > People get upset over this kind of cases but not being able to access a business is as discriminatory as the business shutting the door to someone because there's something the business does not like about that person. There is a huge difference, morally and legally, between - Not spending $$$ on accommodating people. - Not going out of your way to accommodate people. - Closing your door in the face of potential business because you don't like people. It so happens that the ADA prohibits all of them (Edit: Language quoted below makes me unsure about whether or not it actually fully prohibits the first), many other anti-discrimination laws do not, and certainly I do not view someone who does the first the same as someone who does the third.
- WheelsAtLarge 7y ago>I do not view someone who does the first the same as someone who does the third. This is exactly why we have the law in the first place. If a group of people vs another can't access a business then it's discrimination. Which means a whole group can't get the services they need. If everyone felt like you did then stores, parks, schools and so many more services that are essential to life would be inaccessible to that group.
- LorenPechtel 7y ago
- HammockTester 7y agoThis always seemed very strange to me. If society deems it necessary for every business to be accessible, then society (the government) should pay for it out of tax revenue.
- pmoriarty 7y agoSure, as long as you don't mind us raising the tax rates to get the extra money needed to support your proposal.
- HammockTester 7y agoWell of course. It goes without saying that if I support the ADA then I should be willing to fund it along with everyone else.
- WC3w6pXxgGd 7y agoAnd what if I'm not willing to fund it?
- Dylan16807 7y agoIt's a one time conversion. Why not! Fix 5% per year, it'll be done soon enough.
- diffeomorphism 7y agoOr it could pay it from a tax imposed on businesses. But then collecting the tax from the businesses to then giving it back to them is just unnecessary paperwork on top of just having the businesses do it directly. So, not strange at all, we already are, just not in a convoluted way.
- pkaye 7y agoSeems like the building owner should be obligated to make the changes to the building.
- alkibiades 7y agoand this is why people become libertarians
- qtplatypus 7y agoThis came about due to a small government approach. If there was a department of accessibility then they would have issued some sort of notice and they could have negotiated a reasonable accommodation. However because the law creates a private cause of action this can’t happen.
- alkibiades 7y agono those are the big government vs communist choices
- pm24601 7y agoThe landlord should not be allowed to rent this space out until it is ADA compliant. It has been THIRTY years since ADA was passed. Enough! It should not be the problem of the business renting the space.
- mirimir 7y agoBut wait, how does closing just this location resolve the lawsuit? She has another coffee shop, and a restaurant, and says that she'll be incorporating the empty space into the restaurant. So I guess that these are all incorporated separately?
- mirimir 7y agoTFA ends with this: > While the 950 Alameda location permanently closed Friday, coffee aficionados can visit the other Cafe Crema location at 1202 Alameda. [emphasis added] So Cafe Crema is not going out of business. Just the one location is closing. And there's also this: > Tran said she could not meet the lawsuit’s demands to bring the entrance up to code, claiming it would cost her upwards of $100,000 to tear down and rebuild an ADA compliant ramp. The other option to opt for a settlement was not in the cards either, added Tran, who said she could not afford paying a massive $60,000 payout. So if she didn't comply or settle, what happened to the lawsuit? From the complaint,[0] the defendant is: CREMA COFFEE COMPANY LLC dba CREMA COFFEE ROASTING COMPANY; ALI FARHANG So who owns the second location? I was wrong about the restaurant, however. From TFA: > The original Cafe Crema will be consolidated on Feb. 1 into Tran’s restaurant, Pier 402, located at 238 Race Street. So I guess that entrance will no longer exist, solving the problem. 0) https://www.sanjoseinside.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/Crema-ADA-Lawsuit-2018.pdf https://www.sanjoseinside.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/Cre...
- goatherders 7y agoI dont understand how it's a "predatory" lawsuit when it appears to actually be valid.
- jxramos 7y ago> But under California law, a disabled person cannot claim money if they send the business owner a letter with their complaint first. Seems like a decent thing to do to at the least raise an issue with a business owner and bring it to their attention, ideally face to face. > ...businesses are not given warnings or a “grace period” to correct violations. > > Plaintiffs can simply sue with little or no notice. That’s why law firms like Moore’s can easily swoop in with a lawsuit. Seems like businesses should be given a chance first. Seems like the barrier is too low to get these lawsuits dealt out. Give folks a fair chance. This may even be an opportunity for some civic body of volunteers or even a chamber of commerce to proactively approach businesses in advance and get them into shape.
- krisoft 7y ago> Seems like businesses should be given a chance first. Said busineness had 13 years to come into compliance. How long do you think a coffe shop which does not comply with the tax code would be in busines for? If anything this story is about how slow and innefectual the enforcement is.
- LorenPechtel 7y agoThere is no enforcement other than lawsuits. The problem is that requiring this ramp is not a reasonable accommodation to most people. You basically have to wreck the business to make it accessible. In practice the result is the building is unusable, it's going to have to be razed because someone was greedy.
- satyrnein 7y agoFace to face? The issue is they can't get up the stairs to the door. That said, I don't understand why sending a letter should cost you there ability to claim damages later.
- jxramos 7y agoSure, a phone call should suffice to arrange some face to face discussion. They'd basically call to arrange meeting at a more accessible location, even if its only the sidewalk immediately outside. I don't understand that restriction either about forfeiting damages. I'm not sure the details precisely, but I'm of the opinion of second chances and a three strikes you're out sort of deal here. Maybe not literally three but obstinate refusal to address the problem.
- Baeocystin 7y agoWe lost a great pizza place down here in Gilroy for the same predatory-ADA reason. The owners were/are great folks, and deserved better. I've known many small businesses that have had this kind of issue, too, and almost without exception the suit had no moral merit. It's infuriating, and I say this as someone who is very much in favor of ADA-style accommodations in general. But they way things currently work as written is fundamentally broken.
- jxramos 7y agoI see the topic getting covered in a local newspaper pretty frequently. * https://padailypost.com/2019/03/22/another-business-hit-with-an-ada-lawsuit-by-a-frequent-plaintiff/ https://padailypost.com/2019/03/22/another-business-hit-with... * https://padailypost.com/2018/01/05/2-local-restaurants-settle-ada-lawsuits-brought-by-frequent-litigants/ https://padailypost.com/2018/01/05/2-local-restaurants-settl... A lot more can be seen in this site search, they really follow these stories and do a good job raising awareness of the problem: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=site%3Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fpadailypost.com+ada+lawsuit&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?q=site%3Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fpadailypost.c... There's a real good in depth outline of the whole subject covered by Mark Pulliam who used to practice in CA. https://www.city-journal.org/html/ada-litigation-monster-15128.html https://www.city-journal.org/html/ada-litigation-monster-151...
- jeffrogers 7y agoPossibly relevant to the spirit of the lawsuit... the other Crema location mentioned at the end of the article is almost directly across the street. This second location is at street level and accessible by wheelchair. I’m all for enabling access, but in this case, I’m also left wondering if the plaintiff was actually denied access to Crema’s products or services. The law is the law, but the spirit seems off here.
- nimish 7y agoADA is not exactly a new law -- it was over a decade old when Tran set up shop. It's entirely on her (and her real estate surveyor) for not doing the diligence to ensure that her coffee shop was accessible. I can't shed too many tears here, since she's got a profitable business; enough to expand. ADA accessibility is great. Not just for the disabled, but for everyone with reduced mobility. Ever tried to get around old European cities? It's tough even for the able bodied. Imagine that, every day, for those who are permanently with reduced mobility, including the elderly, sick, pregnant, or otherwise handicapped.
- stickfigure 7y agoYes, I have spent quite a lot of time in old European and colonial cities. They have charm in exactly the way that US cities do not, and it's a shame. I wish US cities were a lot more like European cities and a lot less like corporate strip malls. I would be wholly in favor of repealing (or at least seriously limiting) the ADA. Yes, it sucks to be mobility impaired, but we don't need to bring the whole world down to the lowest common denominator.
- calcifer 7y ago> we don't need to bring the whole world down to the lowest common denominator. ... says the man who isn't disabled.
- backupcavalry 7y agoWhile I get what you mean, he's right: there's a line that's going to get drawn somewhere, like as not. Now where exactly is something beyond my ken but there are definitely things that will never be viable for the disabled. In all honesty? I'd rather devote the resources to helping disabled people function fully (or near-fully) again. But that in of itself is sort of wishful thinking.
- mondoshawan 7y agoI would love to be able to walk just like anyone normal. Instead, I deal with major pain every day of my life because assholes like you refuse to build in basic, small things like a fucking chair to sit on while waiting, usually because "it would hurt the asthetics" or some dumb notion like it (ie: apple store, malls, amusement parks...). ADA is the lowest common denominator. Its not asking for you to rebuild a whole building -- it asks for reasonable concessions to be made -- and its absolutely amazing how business owners go out of their way to make it harder on themselves and the disabled. What I don't understand is this "line" that "must be drawn" I've seen from you and others: the point is to negotiate and find a compromise between the disabled and the owner within reasonable limits. The fact that businesses and public institutions are unwilling to play ball and throw their toys out of the pram every time this comes up is amazing and sad that it even comes to that point. Usually because upfront investment in the material/business is smaller and usually beneficial for everyone in the long run! In TFA, crema bought the location years after ADA was already law. The fact that it became a risk to them now is unsurprising, and the fact that they're closing that location is sad for both parties. The fact that it's also possibly a predatory lawsuit is also sad, and I hope something that can be rectified -- but I'm also not surprised to hear of such high numbers of lawsuits over the problem, given how old the law is now, and given how many places I have been to in the valley that don't have ramps.
- c0nsilienc3 7y agoI think you guys really ought to read about the lawyer that was only briefly highlighted in the article: https://www.almanacnews.com/news/2019/07/07/judge-finds-witness-tampering-in-ada-lawsuit https://www.almanacnews.com/news/2019/07/07/judge-finds-witn...
- gopi 7y agoThis google review for the attorney mentioned in that article is heartbreaking Dear Tanya Moore, you don't know me, but I've been following your exploitation of small business owners across the Bay Area for some time after you sued my parent's Mom & Pop copy shop for minor ADA infractions. They never recovered financially. From there followed a divorce and subsequent estrangement from both their children after unbearable drama and suffering. Our family has never been the same since you and Robert Kalani put a cloud over our lives. I want you to know what kind of chain reaction your actions and how you chose to use your law degree caused. Your aggressive tactics on small business owners who are already barely surviving is frankly despicable and your immoral decisions have negatively affected approximately 30+ people in just this one case. It looks like your day of reckoning has recently come in July '19 and I hope legislative changes follow as well. https://www.google.com/search?q=Tanya+E.+Moore&oq=Tanya+E.+Moore#lrd=0x808fcc999f6f1ed1:0xcc6de6b057e250b5,1,, https://www.google.com/search?q=Tanya+E.+Moore&oq=Tanya+E.+M...,
- networkimprov 7y agoPredators exist in many forms, not all of them masculine or violent.
- zeruch 7y agoI was one of the last artists to show there a few months back. It was a really cozy, laid back spot. These kinds of ADA lawsuits are malicious and the perpetrators should be themselves disbarred.
- MrBuddyCasino 7y agoThere has been a reform initiative proposed to prevent this, I can’t tell if it was successful though: https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/house-bill/620 https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/house-bill/620
- generalpass 7y agoLots of comments on the $100k price tag for a ramp. I used to work for a small manufacturer in San Jose. We wanted to build a simple, 300 square foot room inside of a 27,000 square foot space that would be attached to one of the space's walls. What I found most interesting about the estimation process was that no matter what type of structure (including pre-fab earthquake rated) we evaluated for, we couldn't get anything out of city hall for less than total $20,000 spent, with no guarantee that permits would actually be issued. Then, for any contractor we hired (assuming they were available within the next two years), their hourly rate rivaled the rates of downtown lawyers. After this experience, I've concluded that most people who pretend to know something about building something in Silicon Valley are just knowledgeless windbags. I know I certainly had no idea how bad it truly is.
- DataWorker 7y agoIf her competitors have to spend money on ADA compliance why should this particular business get a free ride. That would set a terrible presence as it would penalize the good people and actually incentivize businesses discriminating against disabled people. Sanjosespotlight is pretty trashy too. The enquirer of South Bay clickbait journalism.
- tabtab 7y agoThe law calls for "reasonable" accommodations. They could argue that folding their biz is not reasonable. But, they'd probably need expensive lawyers to do such, which would cause similar problems.
- GaryNumanVevo 7y ago> The disabled man’s attorney, Tanya E. Moore, for years has been the subject of much scrutiny for suing thousands of small businesses across the South Bay, filing more than 1,400 ADA cases in recent years.
- nojvek 7y agoThis article shows everything wrong with America. Lawyers abusing laws and finding loopholes to satisfy their personal greed at the expense of small businesses and communities. Current America really isn’t small business friendly but more optimized for large corporations. This can’t be good for the future.
- satyrnein 7y agoWhat's the loophole? This establishment is breaking the law as it is currently written. Perhaps you want an exemption for small businesses (which others might call a loophole).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- satyrnein 7y agoThis is the tradeoff of any regulation or law. Whether it's ADA compliance, minimum wage, environmental regulation, or even just ordinary property rights, there is always some break-even business somewhere that cannot afford $1 in incremental cost to trim the tree growing over the property line (or whatever). There's no free lunch anymore, we are out of pareto improvements. Of course ADA enforcement will cause some coffee shop somewhere to close. That in itself doesn't tell you very much. You need a fuller cost benefit analysis to tell you if the ADA is good legislation or not.