10 ms·
It's interesting to talk about what "IBM" has been doing, because after all the A&M IBM has done this last decade, they've actually got plenty of "activity" to
by derefr 7y ago
It's interesting to talk about what "IBM" has been doing, because after all the A&M IBM has done this last decade, they've actually got plenty of "activity" to their name. Just, activity that was previously known under the names of Softlayer, Cognos, Redhat...
Go to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mergers_and_acquisitions_by_IBM#Acquisitions_since_2000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mergers_and_acquisitio... and sort the table there by value, descending. "IBM" is a shorthand for more (un-dissolved!) subsidiaries at this point than GE or Samsung.
IBM itself is just a consulting "solution provider" company that provides "solutions" in terms of the products and services of its subsidiaries. They're never going to look like they're on the cutting edge of some space, unless that's what one of their (equally-stodgy) enterprise clients wants to pay them to do. (And even then, why build when you can buy? IMHO IBM would only ever build a new technology at this point if there was no existing company out there in the market, with that tech IP, that they could just acquire.)
Certainly, there's the Watson AI lab, though I don't think anyone's expecting much of it at this point; nor, importantly, was anyone inside IBM ever expecting much of it. Watson (the lab specifically, not the brand strategy of calling all their cloud OLAP SaaS products "Watson") is more a nod to their clients to say "of course we're looking into AI", and a pool of people competent enough that they could clone the existing ML approach of one of their competitors if one of their clients demanded it.
IBM could be a really innovative company if they rearranged their talent pool, certainly. But innovation—getting ahead of the market and so needing to educate the market on the problem their products solve—hasn't been IBM's business model since the 1950s. IBM makes money by listening to clients' "unique" needs, and then meeting them with "custom" solutions at low CapEx cost, by using an ever-larger flywheel of existing solutions pre-tuned to almost fit every possible business use-case.
- vbhavsar 7y agoI don't know why people overlook the progress IBM seems to have made in the quantum computing world. Perhaps not as impressive as Google's progress but impressive none the less.
- derefr 7y agoFor me personally, it was because even from the inside at IBM, you wouldn't hear much about what the quantum folks are doing if you were doing general tech. They really are in their own little world. I don't think they were even in the whole-IBM Slack team, though they might just have been security-compartmentalized with ACLs.
- q_eng_anon 7y agoits compartmentalized - even within the q team although qiskit is open source so literally anyone can look at the GitHub and get a pretty good idea of what's going on
- bronson 7y agoTwo reasons I can think of: - "seems to have made" is important. A decade ago, Watson seemed to be a lot of progress in the AI world. - Where's the revenue?
- StylusEater 7y agoRevenue is but a single dimension when attempting to quantify “progress.”
- MR4D 7y agoWatson has become IBM's Clippy....it never came close to living up to expectations.
- mark-r 7y agoThat's being unfair to Clippy. I expected Clippy to be an annoying joke that wouldn't last long, and my expectations were met perfectly.
- machinecoffee 7y agoWell, clippy didn't last long (although I miss the cat a bit), but the clippy jokes seem to have lasted forever.
- Covzire 7y agoI wonder if we'll see IBM get into video games before too long. Or buying a lesser known streaming company like Mixer? It would seem like an odd fit, but it wouldn't be too surprising.
- larrik 7y agoI mean, at one point (GameCube/PS2/XBox era) IBM was making the chips for all 3 major consoles. I think they've been in video games for a long time.
- Nursie 7y agoPS3 I think (Cell), and Xbox 360 (tri-core Power chip IIRC). Was the PS2 one of theirs as well?
- chungus_khan 7y agoNo, the PS2 was MIPS. IBM did do the GameCube, Wii, Xbox 360, PS3, Wii U though.
- larrik 7y agoYup, I was a generation too early
- aquova 7y agoMixer was bought out by Microsoft a few years ago
- Bombthecat 7y agoThat's how unknown it is :)
- HeWhoLurksLate 7y ago...and it's been integrated into a couple of MS games, too. Forza Horizons 4 has Mixer integrations, and even gives you a bonus experience multiplier for streaming or something like that.
- Angostura 7y agoI suppose its worth noting that IBM folks received a record 9,262 U.S. patents in 2019 - the most patents ever awarded to a U.S. company and the 27th consecutive year of it grabbing the no.1 patent spot. No idea how valuable or inovative any of these patents are, but I think its important to note when discussing: "They're never going to look like they're on the cutting edge of some space"
- bluGill 7y agoAppearing on the cutting edge to enterprise clients is important to IBM. That doesn't mean they are on the cutting edge (they might or might not be). IBM's large pool of patents is something they can advertise to clients. Most companies don't see their patents as valuable, and thus don't patent as much stuff. I've worked with former IBM people - all (or some it seems) of them have a plaque of whatever their first patent was. When they talk about it they admit it was a trivial invention that is too specific to be of much use outside the one project (thus there is no value in keeping it from competitors). IBM encourages patenting everything and has people looking for things to patent. Most other companies only patent things that are unique and worth the costs. (keeping from competitors, licensing to competitors, or keeping competitors from patenting it and stopping your use)
- rtkwe 7y agoI'm really waiting for the day that software patents are finally struck down and we can stop this farce of pretending software patents are actually useful and valuable beyond being a cudgel in legal battles.
- PaulHoule 7y agoIt's funny. IBM is one of very few companies that are producing not one but two of their own CPU architectures and ecosystems of machines around them.
- rbanffy 7y agoAnd what CPUs these are...
- mburns 7y agoPOWER and the Z Series? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_microprocessors#IBM https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_microprocessors#IBM
- rbanffy 7y agoThat was a comment on how impressive they are, not a question. ;-) Sorry.
- PaulHoule 7y agoPowerPC and the z-Architecture (successor to the 360, 370, 390, ...)
- rbanffy 7y agoMinor nitpick: IBM abandoned PowerPC. Their "low-end" servers are all POWER.
- Koshkin 7y ago... the ones that only IBM uses in their computers.
- PaulHoule 7y agoYou might buy a POWER machine from a boutique manufacturer other than IBM but there were other major players such as Motorola, Apple, then later Nintendo: Nintendo adopted with the GameCube, then Wii, but IBM made custom chips for the XBox360 and the PS3, Nintendo still uses POWER in the Wii U.
- Bombthecat 7y agoThey don't do consulting anymore. Or service. They outsource everything to sub contractors (they still apply to rfi and rfp though and win sometimes) but won't have the resources to do the job.
- Lutzb 7y agoI really don't know where you get your information from but this is demonstrably wrong IBM GBS and GTS still ploy hundred of thousands of people.
- Bombthecat 7y agoGetting the info from "working with IBM" directly.
- Lutzb 7y agoHi, fellow employee. edit: sorry. I misunderstood you. Some projects are delivered with subcontractors, of course. But I can tell you from inside that we still have a healthy GBS, GTS and Cloud Services, delivering projects.
- reaperducer 7y agoThey're never going to look like they're on the cutting edge of some space I don't follow big iron as closely as I'd like, but I was under the impression that IBM is considered pretty cutting edge when it comes to mainframes.
- dralley 7y agoThat's somewhat narrowly defined considering they're really the only remaining producer of mainframes. I'm not sure if that's literally true but it may as well be. There are some things that mainframes are legitimately better at, and some things that POWER is better at than x86, and so on. AMD and Intel benefit from incredible economies of scale that IBM could never dream of, and that's mostly where IBM loses -- the price is a lot higher and the volume a lot lower on the IBM side.
- ineedasername 7y agoI thought HP still had some weight to throw around the mainframe arena? Or has that changed by now?
- reaperducer 7y agoAnd Cray still exists.
- Koshkin 7y agoBut are mainframes themselves the cutting edge of modern computing?
- ineedasername 7y agoWell, some consider "cloud" to be a sort of mainframe revival, so in that sense, maybe? But not in the "room-sized computer" sense, no.
- woodandsteel 7y agoIf IBM has been following a wise strategy, how come its financial performance has been so poor?
- pas 7y agoPiss poor execution. Wise but unsteady hands messing up whatever they touch.
- bonzini 7y ago> innovation hasn't been IBM's business model since the 1950s The 360 was innovative in pretty much every respect. In the 90s IBM was the only one of the big Unix vendors to bet on Linux and open source.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]