4 ms·
One thing that often comes up with clean energy solutions is the fluctuations in capacity. In the minds of some this translates into a "OMG we need so much batt
by jillesvangurp 7y ago
One thing that often comes up with clean energy solutions is the fluctuations in capacity. In the minds of some this translates into a "OMG we need so much battery to survive the post apocalyptic circumstances that will surely make wind + solar insufficient". However in the real world, you can also address fluctuations by simply having over capacity.
If e.g. wind is half the cost of other solutions, you can install 2x the capacity that you need so that you still get 100% of what you need when winds drop by 2x. That of course creates the interesting problem of what to do with the extra energy that you don't need under normal circumstances. One solution is to simply transport it around by cable to places that have under capacity but if everyone puts over capacity in place, that's not going to soak up all the over capacity.
Solar has the same challenge. Having barely enough production + batteries can work. But when prices for solar + wind continue to drop you can start thinking about installing 2x, 3x or even 10x the capacity that is needed. That then creates a challenge of how to utilize that over capacity. This is not a problem but a huge economic opportunity.
Hydrogen is one of several ways to store energy and if we nail cheap & clean mass production, it becomes a very useful source of energy for all sorts of things. The German industry (i.e. Siemens + car manufacturers) are keenly interested in making that happen because there's going to be a world wide demand for components for all of this and that kind of is something they are good at. So, there's a very rational reason for bootstrapping the hydrogen economy like this in Germany.
- Hypx 7y ago> Hydrogen is one of several ways to store energy and if we nail cheap & clean mass production, it becomes a very useful source of energy for all sorts of things. If we’re talking about long-term storage, hydrogen is nearly the only option available. Alternatives would be ideas like synfuels or ammonia (which both use H2 as a feedstock). You need the high energy densities of chemical fuels for this purpose. Something that other ideas, like pumped hydro or compress air, sorely lack.
- solarkraft 7y agoWhat is "long term storage"? Why would you store energy for longer than it would need for the grid to provide appropriate capacity again? On a grid level (that usually means: very large), how are H2 or chemical solutions better than simply pumping water up a hill?
- Hypx 7y agoThis article might be of use: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/48693439_Large-Scale_Hydrogen_Underground_Storage_for_Securing_Future_Energy_Supplies https://www.researchgate.net/publication/48693439_Large-Scal... Long term means weeks to months of storage. This deals mainly with large season shifts in energy availability. Other ideas only really make sense for hours or days worth of storage. The need for this type of energy storage is well beyond what is plausible with pumping water or compressed air.