8 ms·
Gorbachev used to say that Chernobyl was where the USSR really started to crumble. The disaster made clear how morally bankrupt and technically incompetent the
by toyg 7y ago
Gorbachev used to say that Chernobyl was where the USSR really started to crumble. The disaster made clear how morally bankrupt and technically incompetent the system really was, wiping out any remaining goodwill or trust. Similarly, Katrina was where the semi-fascist US consensus under GW Bush went to pieces.
I suspect China will experience a similar moment at some point. This might well be it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 7y ago> Similarly, Katrina was where the semi-fascist US consensus under GW Bush went to pieces. Leaving aside the offensive comparison of the US to the USSR, you overlook that after GWB, we doubled down on the “US consensus” by electing Barack “drone strike” Obama. (I think Obama was a great President, but he was also very little different than George Bush except in his oration.)
- yswhhshs 7y agoSo you think Bush was a great president then?
- siracusa23 7y agoIt's interesting to see the American side of the story: "offensive comparison of the US to the USSR" I grew up during the fall of the Iron Curtain in an Eastern European country, building Russian Spectrum (Z80) clones for the bloc, the USSR had positive and negative impacts in our lives. I still live in the apartment that I received during the communist era through my work. However the intervention of the Americans through CIA operations, after the fall of the Iron Courtain, were mostly negative, and we're still suffering because of them. Not everything is black or white in life and the story is much more complicated than the "Russia bad" the media portrays in America. But I guess each one of us is a victim of a propaganda machine.
- input_sh 7y agoAt least Obama reported the number of casualties of drone strikes, a rule which the current president got rid of via an executive order.
- user982 7y agoLies to your face are preferable to lies of omission?
- cycrutchfield 7y ago>I think Obama was a great President, but he was also very little different than George Bush except in his oration Talk about revisionist history, my goodness.
- nate_meurer 7y agoIn your opinion, what are notable differences between the GWB and Obama admins?
- rayiner 7y agoIt’s in the hindsight of history that the differences that seemed significant at the time proved to not be. On the economy, both were mainstream neo-liberals. The best example is TARP. Obama inherited and continued TARP, but it’s also what he would’ve done anyway. Obama extended the Bush tax cuts for everyone earning below $400,000. On foreign relations, both were aggressive on terrorism. On immigration, their policies and rhetoric were similar, with Bush possibly being more liberal. (Bush strongly supported the Comprehensive Immigration Reform Act of 2007, which would have given everyone illegally present in the US on January 1, 2010, a permanent visa and pathway to citizenship.) The two had different rhetoric on guns, religion, and abortion, but very carefully preserved the detante on these social issues by not proposing any significant legislation affecting them. On energy policy, both supported fracking and coal. (Obama had some last minute 2015 environmental regulations, which were quickly rolled back by Trump, but they clearly aren’t a priority seeing as how he waited until the last year of his presidency to act.) On healthcare, both had significant measures to expand coverage. (Bush’s Medicare Part D was a $50 billion/year program, while ACA was estimated to be $95 billion/year.)
- lubujackson 7y agoIt is certainly not a popular opinion. But as diametrically opposed as they appear, there are plenty of problematic issues under Obama that Dems (and Republicans) conveniently ignore. My biggest disappointment at the time: Obama kept all of Bush's economic team intact when he came into office. Yes, the same people who enabled the housing crisis and had strong ties to Goldman Sachs. Probably it should have been the biggest issue of the election but the dialogue was (and is) dominated by identity politics. The underlying issue is that Obama was beholden to the exact same corporate influences as Bush. You don't rise through Chicago politics that fast without some deals in place. This isn't a condemnation of Obama, by the way, but recognition of the system's vulnerability.
- toyg 7y ago> Leaving aside the offensive comparison of the US to the USSR My argument is that you could see the turning point in public opinion breaking a political arrangement that had looked untouchable (and downright tyrannical, with journalists being ostracized and people getting marginalized as "unpatriotic") just a few months earlier. Katrina is when even Republicans decided the regime they had supported since 2001 was not fit for purpose anymore. > you overlook that after GWB, we doubled down on the “US consensus” That's hindsight after a decade. Obama ran on a campaign of dramatic change; at the time he was seen as a massive disruption of the status-quo, way to the left of the Clintons - let alone of Cheney. Whether he then delivered on his original promises, and in which areas, is irrelevant to why he was voted in the first time.
- BurningFrog 7y agoThis won't be it. For one thing, China is quite technically competent.
- agumonkey 7y agoCurrent China is not the USSR for sure, still I wonder if this will not shift people away from cheap chinese products long term. You know with the end of globalization this might give a little more push towards local/safer productions.
- intopieces 7y ago>with the end of globalization Are you implying that globalization is in decline? If so, why do you think this?
- agumonkey 7y agonot decline per se, but it used to be the de facto gold standard of economic structure. The one that had the most weight and momentum and was mostly unstoppable. Now people speak a lot more about bringing some industries back, and some are even starting local brands again (due to climate, jobs, quality concerns).
- yswhhshs 7y agoEveryone thought the USSR economy was awesome and everyone thought the ussr was competent. Authoritarians are always shit, china is shit today and its collapse is inevitable.
- sudosysgen 7y agoThe USSR was also exceedingly technically competent, except in some key areas and in administration. China could have averted this entire epidemic if they simply let the doctors warn the population of what was happening.
- ithinkinstereo 7y agoThe comparison to 80s/late-90s USSR is poor. I think this epidemic is showing the opposite, at least in terms of technical competence. The response from the central authorities has been massive and relatively well executed. The comparison is also off because the day-to-day living situation on the ground (for the average citizen) is totally different from _both_ a political and economic perspective.
- ptx 7y agoThe response might not have needed to be as massive if the initial reaction of the Chinese authorities hadn't been to send the police after the doctors who discovered the problem[1] and try to hush it up. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/01/world/asia/china-coronavirus.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/01/world/asia/china-coronavi...
- ithinkinstereo 7y agoMaybe, maybe not. I think the contrast to past epidemics is stark and shows the government is willing to learn and improve. In any case, the comparison to Chernobyl and 80s USSR is pretty off-base, wouldn't you agree?
- ptx 7y agoThe comparison fits in that a tendency to hide bad news (i.e. swallow errors and suppress warnings) erodes trust in (edit: and effectiveness of) the system.
- ithinkinstereo 7y agoWell, if we are to nitpick.... apples and oranges are both round! Yes, there are certainly similarities between the USSR and China. But if we are to be objective and fact-oriented here, comparing China today to the USSR in the 80s and its response to this epidemic to the USSR's in Chernobyl, is a big stretch.
- JohnJamesRambo 7y agoKatrina was when I realized how silly it is to think our government would ever deal effectively with a major disaster and how vulnerable we are.
- pdonis 7y agoBy "our government" do you just mean the Federal government? Or do you mean all levels of government? The mayor of New Orleans had parking lots full of empty school buses and claimed he had no way to evacuate citizens. The governor of Louisiana whined and wrung her hands instead of doing anything. The Federal response was far from perfect but it was much more effective than the state or local response.
- ausjke 7y agoexactly, USA is _united_ states, crisis like Katrina really should be dealt by the local governments first-hand, with federal help on its way. it's very different from China's system, where everyone has to get approvals from the central government.
- afarrell 7y ago> really should be dealt by the local governments first-hand, with federal help on its way Add "And some overarching flexible framework for regular coordination-practice and preparation-funding" and this seems quite clear.
- rayiner 7y agoIt’s not just the federal system, but the basic nature of disaster response. Even if the EU had jurisdiction over levees in the Netherlands, it would be ridiculous to expect an EU agency to be the front line response to flooding in Amsterdam. It’s the local government that actually knows where the risks and the resources to deal with those are. The federal government can help with money, say ensuring that poor cities have the financial resources to prepare a disaster response. But the actual response has to be local.
- 7y ago
- mikorym 7y agoMy initial reaction to the article was that it doesn't sound like the cash injection has much to do with the corona virus. Isn't the reaction to the virus somewhat overblown? > adding the total liquidity in the banking system will be 900 billion yuan higher than the same period in 2019 after the injection In other words, 300 billion yuan less without the cash injection. I may be wrong, as I don't see the reaction to the outbreak first hand, but it sounds like this is not just about the virus.
- thedudeabides5 7y agoThe Chinese financial system is weak, as borrowers come under stress from a lack of business and can't pay and lenders pull back, the government will need to inject more and more liquidity into the system to get everyone to chill. The direct linkages to the economy aren't the killer, it's that it's hitting at a time when the system's credit (immune) system is already not at it's strongest that worries policymakers.
- joncrane 7y agoI got the same impresion. It's impossible to know whether they expected to simply let those previous repo agreements expire or if they planned to renew them.
- baybal2 7y agoThis might be similar, but I see zero chance of Xi's power taking a hit. For as long as party's institutes are intact, he will be there. Some people began to speculate that Xi wasn't seen for the last 3 days, and sudden activity of "party elders," but I bet this is just an enormous amounts of wishful thinking showing up. Xi's "system" has an expiration date attached, but it's not tomorrow. Following on that Gorbachev analogy, the Unior really started to crumble during late Breznev for reasons well documented by historians. Basically, after Brenzhen loyalists, who mostly were his contemporaries (frail 70-80 and even 90 year olds,) started to drop like flies, a whole truckload of political adventurists, with rogue 3 letter services in particular, took advantage of that to grab power. This in a few years term led to the Union turning ungovernable, and ultimately falling apart. The ultimate proof to that is that pretty much all across the former union, the power went to ex-KGB or men from other 3 letter services. Even as early as Gorbachev's first year, there were officials who were publicly disobeying his direct orders. The last generation of Union's leadership was hamstrung even before the power was formally passed to it.
- echelon 7y agoHow stable is the power that Xi has consolidated? How would the party and the public respond if there were leaks about his private life and behavior? I wonder what his skeletons in the closet are... I've also wondered how receptive the Chinese people would be to a series of documentaries or dramas that point out the inequality and unfairness in their system. A film that highlights how the government treats humans and families as cattle during national emergencies and disasters. Even the great firewall can't keep that out.
- baybal2 7y ago> How stable is the power that Xi has consolidated? Very stable. Basically nothing besides something coming from withing the party itself can shake him, and he took down all of those threats to him from within the party. Not even Mao ever managed to cleanse all of his detractors from the party up until his death. Saying this, you should not be confusing that "people are throwing looks into his back," and quiet whispers of dissatisfaction with genuine resistance. > How would the party and the public respond if there were leaks about his private life and behavior? I wonder what his skeletons in the closet are... If you can write Chinese, google those skeletons, they are up to everybody to see. Even taxi drivers here know of Xi's billionaire sister, but... taxi drivers and other general public can't do anything about that. > I've also wondered how receptive the Chinese people would be to a series of documentaries or dramas that point out the inequality and unfairness in their system. People can see that every day out of their windows, not TVs. They don't need to watch any documentaries to know that. There is the reason people use name of Dong Zhuo as an euphemism for Xi. Take a look at this video, the scene from Chang An says it all about the current political atmosphere in CPC https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jj_VMvsG7G0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jj_VMvsG7G0 Commoners resent him for disturbing a relative peace of Hu's years that they were just getting taste of, by starting a new political upheaval. CPC elders do not only see him as a threat to Jiang, but they clearly think that they themselves are his next target. His unilateral ambitions on the international stage are no match for the discontent world. And yes, the rank and file ordinary officials can't be more freaked out now. However... you also don't forget when Xi was thought to stand for reforms, it were the masses themselves who invited his ambitions to move on the supreme power. And that those who were benefiting from status quo were hit by that the most.
- goodcjw2 7y agoHow do we know that CCP and Xi will NOT survive this? Maybe the system they adopt there, just maybe, is the best system handle situation like this? With all the digital surveillance, AI, and all those new technologies, an authoritarian regime may now have the tools to outperformed the western counterpart? History doesn’t simply repeat itself, it rhymes.
- ianai 7y agoThat would be pretty frightening. There is a hypothesis out there that climate change might ignite an authoritarian regime geared toward counting climate change. Seeing that a mass surveillance program the size of whatever China has cooked up works to contain a biological outbreak and counter a catastrophe might help ignite such a thing.
- taiwanboy 7y agoChina is currently fighting 7 wars 1.) internal political war between xi jing ping of the old guards and the moderates. Check sinoinsider if you wish to know more. 2.) internal provincial wars with Tibet, Xinjiang, and Hong Kong. 3.) conflicts with immediate neighbors over the south sea and other illegitimate claims, including Vietnam, Taiwan, Indonesia, and Philippines. 4.) trade wars with South Korea, japan, US, and Europe. More and more factories are shutting down in China in favor of other countries 5.) debt war to derisk 400 percent Debt to GDP in consumer, corporate and government debts. This economic shutdown will at a minimum take 3% off of China’s proclaimed 6% gdp growth 6.) globalism vs populism as Americans realized they have lost 1.6 million jobs to China since 1990. 7.) health wars with the recent pig flu, Wuhan flu and now bird flu One must realize that China is losing ALL of these wars currently. The finances, social fabrics, and public anger (check Chinese netizens fight over Wuhan) are stretched to the limit. It’s only a matter of time
- HenryKissinger 7y ago8.) They're in the beginning stage of a huge demographic bomb. China's birth rate is plunging rapidly, consequence of the (now defunct) one child policy and better standards of living. China's population is aging rapidly, and there is no immigration to sustain the labor pool, like in Western countries.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tlear 7y agoImmigration is not panacea to it, just delaying the inevitable. One way or another developed societies need to come up with a way to sustain 2.1 child rate. Immigration will prolong time we have to figure it out but it will not fix it. In many ways perhaps it is better to face the reckoning earlier rather then later as Japan, Korea and soon PRC will have to do
- aquadrop 7y agoCan you give a quick tl;dr about 1?
- turk73 7y agoI don't really see how Katrina was any indictment of Bush versus an indictment of how bad the mayor of New Orleans was and how corrupt the state of Louisiana is. Not fascist at all--run by leftists for decades.
- rukittenme 7y agoYou could describe communism as “semi-fascist”. Or any political ideology for that matter. All your doing is spreading FUD. Please expand your vocabulary or be more descriptive in your criticisms.
- marcusverus 7y ago>Similarly, Katrina was where the semi-fascist US consensus under GW Bush went to pieces. What semi-fascist consensus do you imagine existed, and how was it affected by Katrina?
- SmirkingRevenge 7y agoI assume the poster is talking about the post 9/11 climate, where the country was solidly behind President Bush, while the federal government was busy ramping up Guantanamo, the patriot act, water boarding, etc. in the name of fighting terrorism.
- toyg 7y ago... a one-party state, Homeland security, Judith Miller, two wars of aggression on foreign soil (one completely illegal), the President choosing not to enforce laws he didn't like, every critical voice being labelled "unpatriotic", every media channel bleeding nationalism 24-7... the sort of thing that in other countries we'd call "a regime".
- SmirkingRevenge 7y agoA regime of 4 "good" years maybe, before it started getting real blowback for all of its excesses. In regimes more properly called regimes - those good years last for decades, or the lifetimes of their supreme leaders. So.. at least we got that going for us.
- trp1 7y agoWhich is exactly the goal of our system. Now if only we could get term limits for the Senate...
- toyg 7y agoAbsolutely, the two-terms limit held up and anyway Katrina had broken the wave for good. There is an alternative timeline where Katrina doesn't happen and GWB forces a reform of two-terms "to get the job done in Iraq, we need to stay the course", or something else to that effect (like Putin swapping jobs to get around term limits). That would have been very scary.
- hanniabu 7y ago> The disaster made clear how morally bankrupt and technically incompetent the system really was, wiping out any remaining goodwill or trust. I genuinely wonder if the current impeachment process will have the same effect. Will people move on from it thinking it's just a thing with the GOP, or will they take it as a greater systemic failure and give up on the government.
- djsumdog 7y agoThings on track for us to have the first re-election of an impeached president. Let that sink in.
- kortilla 7y agoCan you elaborate on what you mean by “semi-fascist US consensus”?
- tomcam 7y ago> semi-fascist US consensus under GW Bush Could you please explain that incredibly inflammatory point and provide some evidence please?
- whatsmyusername 7y agoI'm excited to see if it takes a newer event for this to happen to the US, or if the garbage going on now will be enough.
- papito 7y agoDude, they built a massive hospital complex in just a few days. We have a... dumb f---ing wall that gets blown over by wind and has to have major stretches of it wide open during the monsoon season to avoid flooding.
- dang 7y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22217844 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22217844.