5 ms·
UBI will be useless unless rent seeking is eliminated with it, because the price of any good or service that profits rent seekers will be inflated almost instan
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
UBI will be useless unless rent seeking is eliminated with it, because the price of any good or service that profits rent seekers will be inflated almost instantly to maintain differentials.
Income inequality is a problem of massively unequal political and economic power, and of insider knowledge and class-cultural arbitrage - not a problem of income.
If - hypothetically - all the jobs required to provide food, shelter, and other basics were taken over by robots, there would be no reason at all not to provide them for free, and give everyone the political and economic freedom to do whatever they wanted.
It's a fair bet that while most people would do nothing much of interest - including most of those who are currently rent seekers - there would still be enough competitive drive to inspire a decent chunk of the population to excel in art, music, science, math, and other productive activities.
That would be real freedom as a birthright - not as the freedom from economic slavery that can only be earned by contributing to that slavery, as now, but as a true inalienable right.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agobecause the price of any good or service that profits rent seekers will be inflated almost instantly to maintain differentials. Which is why I'd prefer to see UBH (Universal Basic Housing).
- ta999999171 7y agoCool, Judge Dredd.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoUniversal Basic Housing just sounds like ghettos with extra steps.
- tsukikage 7y agoSo don't build ghettos. A modest proposal: make every builder donate a proportion of the flats/houses they build to local government, but decide which ones are to be donated by random lot after building work is complete.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- flukus 7y ago> because the price of any good or service that profits rent seekers will be inflated almost instantly to maintain differentials. Only if there is insufficient competition to keep prices down and the market is already broken, which is the case in some areas but not most. In the more notable cases like housing UBI still helps by freeing people to live anywhere instead of cities with plentiful jobs, and even that is largely an artificial problem in developed countries with birth rates below replacement levels.
- bhl 7y ago> UBI will be useless unless rent seeking is eliminated with it, because the price of any good or service that profits rent seekers will be inflated almost instantly to maintain differentials. I've heard this concern before, but what's the assumption that is being made? That UBI will drive more people to cities and increase demand? That landlords would simply increase rent knowing renters have a larger income? That people's long term expectations of inflation changes?
- robotresearcher 7y ago> That landlords would simply increase rent knowing renters have a larger income? This one seems a serious problem. Home sales too, since sellers know people could make larger mortgage payments. Is there a good argument for why this will not inevitably transfer much of the money to landowners?
- enraged_camel 7y ago>>Is there a good argument for why this will not inevitably transfer much of the money to landowners? I regularly rent out the guest bedroom in my house. When I do so, I do not run complex formulas to figure out what a particular tenant might be able to afford. I simply look at rents for similar units in the area, and bump it up or down slightly based on the various features and amenities the room has. I don't charge a corporate executive higher rent than I charge a college student. Their ability to pay is not relevant. You might be thinking "okay, but what if everyone's income went up in an UBI scenario?" Honestly, unless literally all the landlords in a city came together and colluded, you wouldn't see much increase, because we would have the same level of competition we have today.
- horomeme 7y ago>Honestly, unless literally all the landlords in a city came together and colluded, you wouldn't see much increase. The market is all the collusion necessary.
- robotresearcher 7y ago
- horomeme 7y agoI was worried I would read the entire thread without finding the only sound answer. Thanks for proving my worries unwarranted. UBI is a farce. Redistribution of basic commodities like housing and healthcare are the answer.