5 ms·
Why would you care about economic growth in absolute terms instead of productivity per person?
by adrianN 7y ago
Why would you care about economic growth in absolute terms instead of productivity per person?
- lostlogin 7y agoBecause wealth isn’t evenly spread and those that beat this drum are on the wealthy end of the spectrum.
- adrianN 7y agoThose seem like orthogonal problems to me. (People beating the growth-growth-growth drum are also typically on the rich end of the spectrum btw).
- daxfohl 7y agoSeems like we could have some other metrics that could also be relevant to our happiness here on Earth? Nah. Or, I think I've heard it said better, "If the purpose of life isn't 'maximizing shareholder value', we're fucked".
- lazyier 7y agoWealth spread really doesn't matter so long as everybody is getting wealthier. Which is exactly what is happening. By every metric imaginable the entire population of the planet is gaining in wealth. Some quicker then others. But gains are largely universal. Poverty is at it's lowest point in all of human history. And in a month it'll be even lower. Also when wealth goes up, overall consumption as measured by actual natural resources consumed goes down. People have this misconception that increased wealth equals increased consumption, which is hardly the case. Wealth represents a increase in well being, which more often then not, is a result of increased efficiency. By 'increased efficiency' I mean less human effort is required to produce more with less.
- throwawaybbb 7y agoThe bottom 50% of the US are poorer than they were in 1968 in both real and absolute terms. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_inequality_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_inequality_in_the_Unite...
- danharaj 7y agoBut smartphones! /s
- nkurz 7y agoI skimmed through the Wikipedia article you linked, but didn't see proof of that. I certainly could have missed it, though. Which part of the article do you feel supports your claim?
- thepangolino 7y agoIncome inequality is a very flower metric to mesure wealth variations. Imagine country A, awesome with very little income inequality. Half it’s citizens earn 9k a year and the other half 10k a year. Now country B, is very bad. 90% make 50k a year and the other 10% make 500k. That’s terrible, isn’t it? I wouldn’t want to live in country B.
- throwawaybbb 7y agoThe bottom 50% of US citizens have -0.2 trillion in wealth. That's right, they are in debt. Never in the history of the world have the poor had less than nothing.
- TFYS 7y agoWealth spread does matter, though. Inequality decreases happiness, increases crime rate, concentrates power, etc. If you're poor the fact that you have a roof over your head, food to eat and a smartphone in your pocket doesn't make you feel any better if everywhere you go you see people who are much better off than you.
- thulecitizen 7y ago
- Leary 7y agoCause two happy people is better than one very happy person
- LatteLazy 7y agoInvestment only cares about the total growth in a market, and investment is a big chunk of the economy. If I know I'll be selling 20% less widgets in 5 years as population falls, I wont upgrade my widget making machines. Suddenly the people making widget making machines are all unemployed. They stop buying widgets and my sales fall even further. That's ok when it happens in one sector but what about when it happens in every sector? There are other examples: researching a cure for a disease might make sense if there are 100,000 sufferers but not 20,000. If x% of the economy is used for scientific research, you can afford a lot more LHCs with 500m people than 50m. Growth has to fall as we have to cut population or nature will do on it for us. But it will be a difficult project with strange political outcomes.
- johnchristopher 7y ago> If I know I'll be selling 20% less widgets in 5 years as population falls, I wont upgrade my widget making machines. Suddenly the people making widget making machines are all unemployed. Isn't it time to switch to plugin making machines then ? Setup a market opportunities study to try and see how to recycle skills, know-hows and professional network?
- LatteLazy 7y agoMaybe at a local level. But not at a national one. If you lose your job, you improve you're lot by finding another one. If you're town has 100 workers but only 80 jobs, no amount of job fairs and networking will change the fact 20 people will be unemployed. That's sort of the issue here: too many people, not enough jobs. And an economic/political system that assumes getting a job is possible for everyone.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ralala 7y agoA single dollar is always worth a specific part of what can be bought. If there is less to buy, the single dollar is worth less. If there are more dollars, the single dollar is worth less. The amount of investment in LHCs might drop absolutely, but why should it relatively?
- sien 7y agoGovernment debt is proportional to the size of the economy. Many countries have social security systems that rely on the economy being big enough to pay for it.
- vladimirralev 7y agoThe transition from a larger population to a smaller one means the less workers will have to temporary fund the social programs of a large number of retired people. The retired people will also be the largest voting block and will dominate policy-making to force funds into the social programs that they worked for. Depending on the shock, this can cause total breakdown of the system. That's why everybody is racing now "to sustain the expansion at any cost" and to maintain unemployment low for as long as they can. Once people start retiring from this cycle in particular, nobody knows what will happen.
- Eridrus 7y agoThere are a lot of things we like, e.g. science, culture, medecine, software with large fixed costs and low marginal costs. A larger economy lets us have more of them. Of course, economic growth is not sufficient for this, but it is necessary.