4 ms·
Even "realistic" WWII movies got near everything wrong. War wouldn't look glamorous if 4 out of 5 soldiers die a "glorious" death from artillery fire from 20 k
by baybal2 7y ago
Even "realistic" WWII movies got near everything wrong.
War wouldn't look glamorous if 4 out of 5 soldiers die a "glorious" death from artillery fire from 20 kilometres away.
Analogously, WWIII will likely be about thousands of soldiers being vaporised by atomic weapons, and blown to pieces by drones flown by men sitting in comfy bunkers on the other side of the globe
- ajmurmann 7y agoOr maybe for WWIII weapons will be so destructive that we instead will fight it through propaganda, surveillance and trade. Maybe a country will build some militarized, new island, but nobody would date to touch those because weapons are already to scary. Even if one country managed to install a puppet president in another, no military action would ever result because escalation to nuclear weapons is too frightening of a possible consequence.
- ISL 7y agoI think this outcome is a reasonable prediction, but it requires three key assumptions -- that those people making the decisions actually understand how terrible these weapons are, that mutual destruction is actually assured, and that those people actually care about losing.
- dredmorbius 7y agoIt's not prediction. It's history.
- verdverm 7y agoThere's an original Star Trek where war is fought in simulation and people are euthanized if they die in simulated nukes.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 7y ago> Analogously, WWIII will likely be about thousands of soldiers being vaporised by atomic weapons Analogously, WWIII will likely be about hundreds of millions of civilians being vaporized by atomic weapons.
- jcranmer 7y ago> Analogously, WWIII will likely be about hundreds of millions of civilians being vaporized by atomic weapons. There are about 14,000 nuclear weapons in existence. If we assume all of them are 300kt weapons (overly approximate), then each one has a maximum fireball area (i.e., region where people would be vaporized) of about 1.12 km². Allowing for a population density of 20,000 people per km², which is enough to make you one of the top 50 densest cities if held city-wide, this allows for about 300 million people to be possibly vaporized as an upper limit. Trying to track down the actual count of nuclear weapons by their various sizes has proven to be nontrivial, but given that the size class I used accounts for only ½ the US's active nuclear weapons, the other ½ being on the 100kt scale (which produces ⅓ the blast area, apparently), and given that the US makes up about half the world's nuclear weapons, the area that can be targeted by ranges is definitely a wild overestimate. Factor in that densely-populated slums are not going to rank high on anyone's nuke list, and that coverage to maximize number vaporized, as opposed to number killed, is not likely, and I seriously doubt that it's possible to see 100 million people vaporized by atomic weapons in any war.
- kcb 7y agoOne factor is that if WWIII broke out surely the production lines and research into even more destructive weapons would quickly resume.
- philipkglass 7y agoExisting stockpiles of nuclear weapons are adequate to destroy any industrial economy on Earth. Total war between industrialized nations lasted years in the 1940s because the vast majority of weapons failed to harm their targets, largely due to inadequate aiming. But since the 1970s people have had good precision guided weapons. Since the 1950s people have had weapons that can miss the target by miles and still destroy it. If two great powers wage total war with today's most destructive weapons, there won't be enough surviving people and infrastructure left to develop a next generation of even more destructive weapons.
- the8472 7y agoSome scifi shows, e.g. stargate, occasionally do cover people sitting in bunkers and aiming killsats at other nations while being afraid of getting vaporized themselves. Sure, most of the action is still close combat, but they don't totally neglect the remote killing.