3 ms·
I am less experienced, but my USB C experience has been less positive. Both my partner and I have USB-C phones, from different manufacturers. Both use different
by maccard 7y ago
I am less experienced, but my USB C experience has been less positive. Both my partner and I have USB-C phones, from different manufacturers. Both use different "fast charging" standards, and neither of the fast charging standards appears to work as well as with their respective manufacturers chargers (which as a side note are incredibly difficult to find replacements for). I also have a Nintendo switch, which doesn't charge with my MacBook pro's charger, and my switch charger doesn't power my MacBook properly. My car has Android auto, however the cable I was using would cut out if I played audio and used navigation, so I had to buy another cable from a different manufacturer (that cost the same as he first one) for it to work.
I've gone from multiple chargers with different ports, to multiple chargers with the same port, and specific cables with tags on them, and having to explain to my partner that you can't plug x into y, even though they all have the same port.
* Devices are a 2015 MacBook pro, an external GPU, a Huawei phone, a pixel 3, a Nintendo switch, two sets of wireless earbud. For those, I have 4 specific chargers, and two specific cables (3 if you count the moulded plug to the Nintendo switch).
- jbverschoor 7y agoThe innergie 60C Charger supports a lot of different voltages. And is super small
- voltagex_ 7y agoIt's quite late here and the Huawei charging "standard" has really thrown me, but: * Pixel - 9V/2A or 5V/3A by the looks of it. A decent USB C charger will do this * Nintendo Switch - just don't use anything other than the Switch charger or a power bank for this. It's 15V/3A, but finicky. * Macbook Pro - not familiar with this, didn't realise they went USB C all the way back in 2015, but it probably needs 60W+ and an e-marked cable. * Huawei phone - if you give me the model number I can probably work this out. It's very hard to work out what that charging spec is, but it may also work with Qualcomm QuickCharge, which apparently makes the USB-IF very sad when delivered over the Type C cable. I use a charger similar to https://www.kogan.com/au/buy/mbeat-gorillapower-80w-5-port-usb-c-and-quick-charge-30-charger-mbeat/ https://www.kogan.com/au/buy/mbeat-gorillapower-80w-5-port-u..., and I also highly recommend something like https://satechi.net/products/satechi-type-c-power-meter-for-new-macbook-macbook-pro-type-c-devices https://satechi.net/products/satechi-type-c-power-meter-for-....
- maccard 7y agoI appreciate the response. It's a p20 pro. I realize that I could find a charger that's compatible with all of the devices, but the fact is that all of them claim to be USB-C, and I'm still not sure if I buy a third party charger from a trusted brand (e.g. Anker) if it will work with all devices. Now imagine explaining your comment to a lay person! > it probably needs 60W+ and an e-marked cable. I wasn't even aware e marked cables were a thing. I guess I need something similar for correct Android auto support with my phone and my car? Honestly, your comment, while incredibly helpful, explains how unclear and how much of a mess it is.
- voltagex_ 7y agoHalf of the problem is the USB implementers forum seems to be disconnected from reality and the other half is manufacturers not wanting to use standards P20 Pro: Uses "Huawei Supercharge" which is not Huawei Fastcharge or VOOC, nor is it compatible with USB PD or Qualcomm QuickCharge. Jesus. I'll cross that brand off my list completely re: Android Auto - I have no idea, sorry. Double check the cable works correctly to transfer data to a PC (or for tethering etc) - the last time I looked, AA was VNC over IP over USB.
- maccard 7y agoAgreed that the problem is the implementors, but unfortunately that's all that matters. At least when the cables didn't fit I could easily not buy the wrong cable, but now I'm left scouring reddit or asking for help on HN!
- Dylan16807 7y ago> * Nintendo Switch - just don't use anything other than the Switch charger or a power bank for this. It's 15V/3A, but finicky. The dock can be fussy, but I think the switch itself is fine with anything that doesn't horrifically overvolt pins.
- Causality1 7y ago
- jayd16 7y agoWould you rather each of those use a custom port and none of those things be compatible at all?
- maccard 7y agoHonesrly, yes. It would be easier to explain to my partner which cable/device/charger combo she can use, and would be easier to find a replacement that I know will work. For all intents and purposes, they _are_ incompatible already, they're just pretending to be.
- somehnguy 7y agoThey already are incompatible. Just in a much more annoying fashion than ever before because the incompatibilities don't show themselves until you actually try it. I much prefer to just look at the cable and go 'nope, that clearly doesn't work with that' instead of playing cable roulette.