2 ms·
Lets think of what "reasonable steps" a service provider of encrypted messaging could take to prevent child porn on their service... * They could put up a big
by londons_explore 7y ago
Lets think of what "reasonable steps" a service provider of encrypted messaging could take to prevent child porn on their service...
* They could put up a big message saying 'no child porn'. I don't think that would be considered sufficient by a court.
* They could put a 'report' button. Again - insufficient.
* They could make client-side automated content scanners. Might be accepted by a court, but if you provide the scanner to the user, the government could argue it is easy to make images which bypass the scanner, which it would be.
* They could break encryption on some percentage of chats. A court would likely be looking at a particular case, and would consider the service provider not to have done their duty if the particular case at hand hadn't been checked.
I don't really see any reasonable steps which would stand up, other than breaking e2e and doing server-side scanning.
- henryfjordan 7y agoThe proposed law (according to the article) requires the committee coming up with the rules to consider user privacy (not that they have to actually do that), but that gives a platform some cover to argue that breaking end-to-end encryption is not reasonable and that the report button will have to suffice.
- tenpaiyomi 7y agoThat would be fine, if not for the fact that the committees rules can be completely overridden as desired, essentially making the committee nothing more than a public appeasement piece.