7 ms·
ACLU: ICE and CBP Are Secretly Tracking Us Using Stingrays. We’re Suing
- sitkack 7y agoRegional directors of the organizations stonewalling the requests should be fired.
- sneak 7y agoI feel that demands like this fundamentally misunderstand the hows and the whys of these posts being filled in the first place. The nature of power in America seems to me to be widely misunderstood.
- munk-a 7y agoI think that the ability for those organizations to stone-wall is important and needs to be preserved - especially prior to the fact being released there may be very valid reasons for withholding facts... but if the stonewalling is without a just cause (which we can examine at lengths after the release of information) then there should be more severe penalties. We're getting to a point where claiming it's "a matter of National Security" is pretty much a meme and it erodes legitimate uses of this privilege - and that erosion will cause a lot of harm over time as legitimately sensitive material is forced out early... but, at the same time, being overly aggressive with punishment over borderline cases of withholding information may also have a chilling effect over properly exercising those rights. So maybe we need to leave a pretty wide grey zone.
- sneak 7y agoGovernment derives its power from the consent of the governed. Consent cannot be meaningfully granted from ignorance—it’s called informed consent for a reason. The thing that damages national security is keeping secrets.
- munk-a 7y agoI, personally, want to know if the US is assassinating people with drones, illegally detaining people overseas or snooping in on conversations... But I don't need to personally know who is working in such-and-such embassy, nor do I want to know (or want the public to know) which routes they commonly take to drive to the embassy, what their favorite foods are or where their family members reside. National secrets are a thing, there are legitimate details about government employees that are good to keep secret - so I don't think your blanket statement is really all that valid.
- sitkack 7y agoThey should be approved or denied. Stonewalling is undemocratic. There is no due process because there is no process. It is effectively a dribble or slowloris attack against the requestor.
- einpoklum 7y agoThey are probably exercising standard practice. Their superiors probably expect and want them to do this.
- Karunamon 7y ago>[ICE/CBP's] continued efforts to target and tear apart communities across the country. Is this kind of partisan dog-whistling really necessary? The ACLU does good work at the end of the day, but this sentence makes their stance on border control loud and clear. And I call it dog-whistling because it does nothing but detract from an otherwise reasonable stance on surveillance abuse, for the sake of a wink and a nod.
- tedajax 7y agoEasy for you to say if you're not in the effected communities...
- Karunamon 7y agoTo say that ICE or CBP's "effort" is to "target and tear apart communities" is the kind of dishonesty that would be rightly flagged off of HN as inflammatory nonsense.
- minikites 7y agoIt sure looks like tearing apart to me: https://www.npr.org/2018/06/19/621065383/what-we-know-family-separation-and-zero-tolerance-at-the-border https://www.npr.org/2018/06/19/621065383/what-we-know-family... >However, The New Yorker spoke to lawyers and advocates who said there is no formal process or clear protocol for tracking parents and children within the system and that chaotic systems and inadequate record keeping make it difficult even to know which facility a child might be kept at.
- stanferder 7y agoI don't think it rises to the level of dishonesty, but I do think the writer should not have included something as unknowable and irrelevant as the possible hidden motives of these agencies. Nevertheless, suing these agencies to prevent unwarranted surveillance is justified.
- claudeganon 7y agoIt’s what people who were working for the agencies themselves have said: https://www.thisamericanlife.org/656/let-me-count-the-ways https://www.thisamericanlife.org/656/let-me-count-the-ways
- briandear 7y agohttps://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/obama-administration-advising-cops-cellphone-surveillance-tech-quiet-article-1.1827776 https://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/obama-administrati... Where was the lawsuit from ACLU during the Obama years? That’s what makes the lawsuit partisan.
- nostrademons 7y agohttps://www.aclu.org/press-releases/aclu-sues-obama-administration-detaining-asylum-seekers-intimidation-tactic https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/aclu-sues-obama-administ...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- korethr 7y agoI misunderstood the title. I thought that ICE and CBP had somehow taken to retaliating against ACLU for their inquiries about Stingrays, that the ACLU had somehow found out about this and was counter-retaliating with a lawsuit. Fortunately, nothing so dramatic is happening here; their FOIA requests having been stonewalled, and they're taking to the courts to try to force compliance with FOIA. Good on them. I hope they succeed. I could do without some of the phrasing of the press release though, it comes across as needlessly inflammatory, deliberately written to paint ICE and CBP as some sort of anti-immigration evil league of evil. As an example, take the scare quotes around the term "unlawful-reentry". Here, I use the quotes to mark the word as a word under discussion, apart from the meaning the sentence would have were it not quoted. There, the only common use of quotes that makes sense to me is to mark the use as sarcastic. Sarcasm isn't helpful. If you enter a country without going through a port of entry, that's unlawful entry. If you go back to a country without going through a port of entry, that's unlawfully reentry. That holds true at every national border on this planet, and isn't some anti-immigrant invention of ICE or CBP. This sort of thing makes me sad, because that kind of sarcasm and disingenuousness makes it easier for people and groups who actually are actively opposed to rights for various other groups to paint the ACLU as acting in bad faith. Don't give your enemies free ammunition. Stick to the facts, and leave the emotionally inflammatory remarks for personal social media accounts.
- jshevek 7y agoI agree, but took the intent to be worse than sarcastic, rather a manipulative effort to invalidate another's position by implying the very language they use to describe reality is invalid. In other words, it's like prefacing the words with "so called."
- einpoklum 7y agoWhile such legal action is commendable, it seems to me that surveillance of anyone-and-everyone, at whim or at all times, is by now very ingrained in federal-level organizational practice and culture. So much so that it will not go away just because it is ruled illegal or unconstitutional. Plus, its continued use may also have legitimized it enough in the view of judges for them to have developed a large blind spot for their constitutionality.
- yingw787 7y agoI got my Guardians of Liberty card this year, third one after donating $15 / mo to the ACLU for two or three years. The cards keep getting better, maybe if I keep donating I can get like a silver or platinum card like those credit cards. Or maybe it’s just this year that the card stock is good. I should increase my monthly donations after I get a job, $15 / month is too low for somebody in software. Maybe $50 / month.
- jimbob45 7y agoSeems like the real news is that ICE and CBP haven't been given direct access to the data of cell towers from the get-go, right? Or is that not how that works?
- dang 7y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21766137 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21766137
- no_opinions 7y ago> to track down an immigrant suspected of “unlawful reentry” into the country. In other words - we don't know who they even are. Just that they're furtive and evading authorities. The unlawful entry in itself is bad, but what exactly they're doing, which could range from a scheme to dodge customs fees, unfairly circumvent immigration procedures our democratically elected congress put into law, to drug running, to spying, to hurting people. Every country identifies its entrants. Why are people so eager to make light of such a fair procedure? There is a serious national security rationale backing identifying an "unlawful entrant" ASAP. I hope the law gives the government maximum authority and upgrades their tools so they can keep us safe. I wish places like ACLU would be good examples and be candid. By the way they talk in this letter - it's not like they disagree with a law - it's like they're against the concept of the most basic principle of international travel: Getting your passport stamped.