5 ms·
This is more or less the thing with "Category Theory". Very fancy and neatly structured code but in the end you accomplish pretty much the same; and now nobody
by moralestapia 7y ago
This is more or less the thing with "Category Theory".
Very fancy and neatly structured code but in the end you accomplish pretty much the same; and now nobody on the team understands a bit about what you're doing.
- asdfman123 7y agoYou mean there's a way to establish yourself as an arcane code wizard and make yourself irreplaceable? Sign me up!
- moralestapia 7y agoIt's more like: "Why would we use a framework that nobody understands but you, to accomplish the same stuff a few SQL statements can do?" The former option never wins.
- crimsonalucard 7y agoExcept what you said is not true at all. Whats going on here is you're scoffing at something you don't understand. Before you scoff, understand it. Then scoff. Until then you're just as good as the ignorant people who ridiculed the theory of a heliocentric solar system.
- moralestapia 7y agoNice preconceptions, they truly add to your argument. CT brings nothing new to the table in terms of "now we can do X that we couldn't do otherwise". If you can provide an example to prove its usefulness, please do. Funny thing is that every time it comes down to "just show me" the hand-waving and "you wouldn't get it" begins. Things that work speak for themselves. >you're scoffing at something you don't understand Actually ... I was also very excited by the promise of CT a few years ago and since then I have read a lot about it and I'm quite confident "I understand" what I'm talking about. I've been programming for about 20 years, half of them with functional languages (or languages with first-class functional constructs: lisp, haskell, scala). I have read the most famous books on CT touching on programming, some of them are signed as I have spent my own money going to some CT conferences and meeting with the people there. As a conclusion, I don't mean that CT is useless in itself. It definitely is a nice mathematical framework and has proven a great tool for a few things here and there in different areas of math. But in the context of computer science, as I said it before, it does not bring anything new to the table.
- marcosdumay 7y ago> CT brings nothing new to the table in terms of "now we can do X that we couldn't do otherwise". You mean that in the "all Turing complete languages are the same"? Because I can't make sense of it with another meaning. If so, you can keep writting web applications in assembly, I guess it's comfortable using something you already know.
- crimsonalucard 7y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21876370 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21876370 One example where CT helped me.
- crimsonalucard 7y agoThat just means the concept is ahead of its time. People scoff at things they don't understand before that thing takes over the world.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoBut they also scoff at things that never take over the world. So it doesn't actually mean that it's ahead of its time. It could be an overcomplicated mess that you don't actually need, and it could to be that forever.
- crimsonalucard 7y agoExcept that post says he doesn't understand it. He's scoffing at something he doesn't understand. That is 100% ignorance. This is entirely different from scoffing at something over complicated and that you do understand.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoI'm not sure where you're getting this. moralestapia never said he didn't understand it. (In fact, in a parallel branch of the comment tree, he said that he did understand it.) He said that if you use category theory on a project, now nobody on your team understands the code. But that "you" probably doesn't mean "if you are on my team and do that, I won't understand it". It probably means more like "if one uses category theory", that is, if you use it on your team, this is the result, if I use it on my team, the same result happens. And if you mean dahart, he said (or at least implied) that he didn't understand geometric algebra, but he didn't say anything about understanding category theory.
- crimsonalucard 7y agoHis initial post said the "team" doesn't understand it so I took it to encompass "him" as part of the team. My post is in response to that. Clearly his subsequent post says he does understand CT so I'm in error on that part. Either way the "team" not understanding it, does not preclude it from being right. CT does not overcomplicate things. It just allows you to understand a program differently so you can decompose your program into smaller pieces or take a different path. Saying CT complicates things is like saying number theory complicates numbers. Number theory is numbers and CT looks very much like a good theoretical framework for program organization. In other words CT looks like a formal theory for the design of programs. We aren't at a spot where we can concretely say this, but practitioners of CT and programming are enamored with CT because it looks this way. Overall, his complaints point to a lack of understanding despite his claim.