4 ms·
We cannot have people stuck in an era 3 decades old deciding the fate of our country as it goes into the future. While I agree that the age skew in politics is
by reaperducer 7y ago
We cannot have people stuck in an era 3 decades old deciding the fate of our country as it goes into the future.
While I agree that the age skew in politics is curious, and perhaps incorrect, the other side of this is, "We cannot let people with 30 years less experience, knowledge, and history decide the fate of our country as it goes into the future."
Automatically associating youth with intelligence and "progress" and stereotyping people with years of accrued wisdom to being "old fogies" is textbook ageism.
It's something most of the rest of society grows out of by the time they hit college, but also a thing that persists within the SV bubble and what is now called "bro" culture. Fortunately, it's also illegal in many arenas.
- dathinab 7y agoBut when I look at the decisions today's politicians do wrt. IT, I would argue that many 30year old ex-IT students have _far_ more experience wrt. IT topics than our current politicans. The problem is that the tech landscape moved to fast and all the wisdom and experience often just doesn't apply anymore but, to make it worse, sometimes it seems that you can bend technology to make it apply but that a very dangerous fallacy. One I have seen politicans step into frequently.
- hobofan 7y agoHow many ex-IT students become politicians? Old politicians with no IT experience are being replaced with young politicians with no IT experience. Age limits don't improve anything here.
- jvalencia 7y agoI'm also not sure that having IT-savvy politicians will change policy. The government has certain safety goals (eg trafficking) that it will still have to deal with. These might be a driver regardless of tech savvy-ness. There's an assumption that if only they knew enough -- but perhaps it's not them who don't know enough.
- Mirioron 7y agoI've been watching Louis Rossman advocating for right to repair recently.[0] Louis tells a story about how opposition lobbyists have made outrageous claims and politicians bought it, because nobody actually showed up to disagree with the claims. While it's possible that politicians would vote the same way regardless, I think they they likely do miss out on a lot of information. [0] video, watch 1 minute from here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cHQYyYSZdvQ&t=1m57s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cHQYyYSZdvQ&t=1m57s
- seppin 7y agoNone. They are all lawyers.
- reaperducer 7y agoBut when I look at the decisions today's politicians do wrt. IT, I would argue that many 30year old ex-IT students have _far_ more experience wrt. IT topics than our current politicans. While I don't disagree that many 30-year-old IT people know more about IT than politicians, politicians have to see what is good for the whole of society, not just what affects people in an IT bubble. We've seen countless times that technologists cannot be trusted alone. They have to be tempered by people from other disciplines.
- mullingitover 7y ago> While I don't disagree that many 30-year-old IT people know more about IT than politicians, politicians have to see what is good for the whole of society, not just what affects people in an IT bubble. Let's not delude ourselves, most lawmakers are not pinnacles of wisdom. They're not looking out for the best outcomes for society in the long term. They're partisans controlled by whomever pays them the most.
- jacques_chester 7y ago> We've seen countless times that technologists cannot be trusted alone. They have to be tempered by people from other disciplines. It cuts both ways. Legislatures are dominated by former lawyers. It wasn't always so. I studied law, I know it lends many relevant skills for politics. But it's no longer sufficient to have nothing but lawyers legislating, given the face of the breadth and depth of modern society. Sometimes you need a specialist inside the tent. Or, better yet, a wide variety of specialists.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoIt's not just IT. How many legislators have experience with any particular thing that they write legislation on? Not very many. I will admit that IT legislation often seems insanely out of touch. But I wonder if that's just because I know IT better than I know, say, the merchant marine.
- kiba 7y agoThe politicians are lawyers as opposed to former IT professionals.
- killface 7y agoOh yes, I'm totally going to grow out of this climate crisis... my, how hard are your pearls being clutched right now?
- reroute1 7y agojust because you believe in climate change doesn't mean you won't have other issues, like the parent was suggesting... as evidenced by your dying comment. That's not at all what they were saying.
- dang 7y agoThis comment breaks the site guidelines. Please don't do that. We already had to ask you this just a few days ago. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ta999999171 7y agoI don't want experience. I want people with less time to become endebted to corporate M.I.C. scumbags who have financial/personal blackmail on those people.
- SkyBelow 7y ago>Automatically associating youth with intelligence and "progress" and stereotyping people with years of accrued wisdom to being "old fogies" is textbook ageism. Is it as much ageism as outright restricting rights based on age? That seems far more like ageism except it is so deep in our cultural DNA we don't view it as such. If we can, as a group, say that everyone below a certain age cannot have rights such as voting, thus saying they have no ability to have a say in politics that will impact their entire lives, then why can't we have age caps like saying no one over 60 can be elected in government because <insert some reasoning that mimics the same logic not letting any 17 year old vote>?
- paulmd 7y agoWe already have ageism enshrined in our constitution with minimum ages. If that's OK, then we should have upper age limits as well. The lack of an upper age limit is potentially far more damaging in the modern era than not having a lower age limit. People in the founding fathers' times didn't live into senility, if you made it to 60 you were doing pretty good and probably not going to make it for another 3 decades. We have had at least one definitely senile president in the last 30 years and the evidence strongly suggests our current one is suffering from dementia as well. The two leading Democratic presidential candidates are both 80+ years old and one of them is looking awfully senile in public too. Dementia is a serious threat to American democracy in the modern era. The structure of the American political system means that the people most likely to make a successful run are the ones that have spent 30-40 years building political capital, and those are inherently the oldest among us. Without some form of check, you end up with rule by octogenarian which is where we are. What's the average age of a Senator these days? 65 or so? And that is the most likely place a presidential campaign can be launched from. And you would want to be a senior senator to be able to beat out the other senators...
- wahern 7y agoThe average age of the 1st Congress (1789) was 46.[1] The average age of the 50th Congress (1887) was 57.[2] The average age of the 115th Congress (2018) is 61.[3] That's not a terribly huge change, especially considering the increase in age of the population. [1] Average age of all listed Senators at 1789. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1st_United_States_Congress https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1st_United_States_Congress [2] Average age of all listed Senators at 1887. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50th_United_States_Congress https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50th_United_States_Congress [3] https://www.senate.gov/CRSpubs/b8f6293e-c235-40fd-b895-6474d0f8e809.pdf https://www.senate.gov/CRSpubs/b8f6293e-c235-40fd-b895-6474d...
- K0SM0S 7y agoRespectfully, I think you are making a "classic" mistake in demographics — one of the most counter-intuitive discipline I ever studied. One TL;DR is that averages give you very, very, very partial information — without at least a median and the standard deviation, it's pretty much meaningless. Math, but applied to stats / demo yields incredibly wrong pictures if you don't look deeper. Think structure, not KPI, and longitudinal trends — what you see today isn't what's "now", a lot of it is what was set up 20, 50, 60 years ago. Another TL;DR is that the increase in life expectancy is seldom about "how long do people live" but rather "how many of us die too early" — and this is where the fantastic increase in average comes from. The end-of-life expectancy sure rose too, but much less, and is actually starting to fall back down in the US (some other countries too, it's not just Sam, but it's not a generality either). Thus the ageing of Senators has little correlation with life expectancy, it's a false correlation (again evidenced by biological facts). From a political science / historical standpoint, current epoch looks a lot like e.g. the second half of the Roman Empire ("decadence", although the word is way too negatively connoted if we mean to judge these times through a modern lens — stagnant in influence is more like it, ageing and eating well is another take). Judging by intuition from having looked at these figures, I'd say the average political apparatus is 20+ years older today than it used to be around the revolution relatively to the active population, in terms of general pyramidal structure (so, beyond averages). Again, not true in all countries — some are even trending younger in Europe, which is about a couple decades ahead of the USA in terms of demographic structure. Sorry I can't write a book for each of these TL;DR, but the knowledge on how to analyze demographics is there if you Google it.
- jonas21 7y agoI agree that stereotyping older people is ageism and should not be tolerated. However, specifically with regard to age limits, it's interesting to note that the law which prohibits age discrimination in the US also explicitly allows for mandatory retirement for "bona fide executives or high policymakers" who are age 65 or older [1]. In addition, many areas of the government such as the military and State Department have mandatory retirement ages. So one would naively expect our elected officials to fully support a similar policy being applied to them! [1] https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/statutes/adea.cfm https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/statutes/adea.cfm
- DarthGhandi 7y agoDemocracy is the purest form of discrimination there is. People can and do vote based on age, sex, race. The irony of using the now derogatory term "bro" also. Basically anyone people disagree with, they add a bro prefix/suffix in a snide way and consider the debate won. Brogrammers, cryptobros, pharma bro. Maybe you'll grow out of it one day though :)