5 ms·
> I answered, "i^2 = j^2 = k^2 = ijk = -1". Could you explain why? For someone without a math background, it seems indeed like a pretty arbitrary thing to defi
by xg15 7y ago
> I answered, "i^2 = j^2 = k^2 = ijk = -1".
Could you explain why? For someone without a math background, it seems indeed like a pretty arbitrary thing to define.
(I can understand the idea behind complex numbers and how the multiplication rules followed from the desire to define the square root of a negative number - however, so far, I don't get the motivation of introducing even more "special" elements)
- Koshkin 7y agoSee, for example, https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/911807/what-is-the-motivation-for-quaternions/911814 https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/911807/what-is-the-...
- nilkn 7y agoBy the Frobenius theorem, there are only three possible structures for a real finite-dimensional associative division algebra. Those structures correspond to the real numbers, the complex numbers, and what are called the quaternions. So essentially the above definition is not arbitrary because it's the only other possible way (besides R and C) to get that sort of algebraic system. Of course, this is not obvious at all. C famously is algebraically closed as a field, which makes it a ripe playground for much of topology, algebraic geometry, and analysis. There are some nonobvious generalizations of algebraic closure for the quaternions. (Naively, the quaternions are not algebraically closed in the classic sense because, evidently, ix + xi - j has no root.) As for why one might want to consider such a noncommutative division algebra in the first place, the answer I suppose is just that it manages to pop up in a variety of areas in mathematics. We've already seen the connection with rotations in 3-space (the topic of this post). Here's another. The 3-sphere (that is, a sphere in 4-dimensional space whose surface is itself 3-dimensional) can be realized as the multiplicative group of unit quaternions spanned by {1,i,j,k}. Consider the circle H = {cos(theta) + i * sin(theta)} for real values of theta; H is a subset of the 3-sphere. If r is any unit quaternion, then the coset rH is another circle. But given a subgroup H of any group G, the left cosets of H in G form a partition of G. Therefore, these circles just described form a partition of all of the 3-sphere (the Hopf fibration). Speaking of rotations, the involvement of quaternions should not be surprising. Indeed, complex numbers are intimately involved in rotations in 2-space (multiplication by a unit complex number e^(i*theta) corresponds to rotation about the origin by theta). Quaternions can similarly express rotations in 3-space, but one cannot just left- or right-multiply but must instead use conjugation. In general, one can generalize this using the techniques of geometric algebra.
- JackFr 7y agoWhen I took abstract algebra as an undergrad, we did a brief bit on the quaternions. Bursting with curiosity I asked the professor if 8 and 16 dimensional structures existed. "Of course! But just as you lose commutivity with Q, when you go to the octonions, you lose associativity, and the sedonions lack "alternativity" (had to look that up -- I didn't remember) and they're basically algebraic novelties with out any application."
- bonzini 7y agoRight, but while the Cayley-Dickson construction mostly provides novelties (though I remember reading something about octonions and string theory[1]), Clifford algebras are derived differently; they are isomorphic to complex numbers and quaternions for two and three base vectors respectively, but they produce something else after quaternion. This "something different" can be used to represent, you guessed it, reflections and rotations in a 4D space. Because they are not obtained from the Cayley-Dickson construction they are not division algebras, however. [1] https://www.quantamagazine.org/the-octonion-math-that-could-underpin-physics-20180720/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/the-octonion-math-that-could-...
- BlueTemplar 7y agoThat amazing graphic !
- jjoonathan 7y ago> the multiplication rules followed from the desire to define the square root of a negative number That's a bit reductionist. You don't just get the square root of a negative number, you get the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra (an Nth degree polynomial has N roots), which is a mathematical power tool if ever there was one. Complex numbers dramatically simplify a bunch of proofs in linear algebra, give us tons of nifty integration techniques in complex analysis (the techniques are relevant for real numbers, they just use C), provide a representation of 2D rotations that can be manipulated using the rules of algebra (this is the most relevant to the thread), and give physicists, electrical engineers, and signal processing people an abstraction to represent oscillations (energy sloshing between two buckets = two elements of a complex number, which you can then do algebra with). They're a workhorse. Quaternions are an attempt to do that in 3D. The dot and cross product of vector calculus are other pieces of those efforts. Unfortunately, vector calculus escaped the "math lab" before it was complete and got written into other fields and engineering books, so even though the underlying concepts were eventually sorted out (it's called Geometric Algebra), everybody just uses the half-baked abstractions (quaternions, dot product, cross product) which are Good Enough. It's a perfect example of "worse is better" affecting something other than software engineering.
- SkyBelow 7y ago>Quaternions are an attempt to do that in 3D. I guess the question is, why does it then stop. Why not a 4D alternative. Or if you look at it going by scalars needed in a single value, it goes from 1 to 2 to 4. Why not 8 or 16 (or some other growth)? Why does it stop there? Also, is there as easy of a problem to understand introducing the 3D technique (be it quarternions or be it Gemoetric Algebra) that works as well as using sqrt(-1) for imaginary numbers?
- JackFr 7y ago8 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octonion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octonion 16 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sedenion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sedenion 32 https://arxiv.org/pdf/0907.2047.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/0907.2047.pdf <- Trigintaduonions
- 7y ago
- jfengel 7y agoAs other replies have said, the math is kind of important. The idea of a tattoo harkens to the story of the discovery of quaternions: Rowan Hamilton was out for a walk in Dublin, trying to figure out how to generalize complex numbers. He was walking under a bridge when he came up with that equation, and carved the equation on the bridge. His carving, if it ever existed, is gone. But there is a plaque on the bridge commemorating the event. It reads: Here as he walked by on the 16th of October 1843 Sir William Rowan Hamilton in a flash of genius discovered the fundamental formula for quaternion multiplication i² = j² = k² = ijk = −1 & cut it on a stone of this bridge.
- kens 7y agoFor a summary of William Rowan Hamilton's life (including the bridge story), see this amazingly clever video based on the song from Hamilton: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SZXHoWwBcDc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SZXHoWwBcDc
- chadcmulligan 7y agoThere's also a great book "A History of Vector Analysis: The Evolution of the Idea of a Vectorial System" by Crowe which covers vectors from Complex numbers to Gibbs vectors and includes Hamilton and the competitor at the time Grassman Algebra, both the basis for geometric algebra. Its one of the only maths history books I couldn't put down.
- GlenTheMachine 7y agoMy PhD advisor was a stickler for citing original sources. Really, really original sources. He made me cite some papers written by Lagrange in the 17th century in French, when neither he nor I nor nearly anyone else who would ever read my dissertation could speak French. I got to the point where I needed to cite an original source for the quaternion equations, so I cited the bridge. He got the message.
- pflats 7y agoThanks for writing this. It was indeed a large part of why I like it. I added more detail in a reply to the parent post. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22204995 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22204995
- davidgl 7y agoI'm not a mathematician, but I think it's about extending the idea of a scalar and a single rotation (Complex numbers) into a scalar + 3 rotations (Quaternions). The idea can be extended further to a scalar with 7 rotations - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octonion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Octonion, but no further, for reasons I don't understand.
- paulddraper 7y agoYou can actually go as far as you want to with the Cayley–Dickson construction [1] of algebras. 1. Complex numbers have associativity and communitivity of multiplication. (That is, (ab)c=a(bc) and ab=ba). 2. Quaternions have associativity but not communitivity. 3. Octonions have neither. 4. Sedenions [2], trigintaduonions, and not associative, commutative, nor even alternative [3]. (Alternative is associative specifically when the middle value is equal to one of the other's; i.e. a(ab)=(aa)b.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cayley%E2%80%93Dickson_construction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cayley%E2%80%93Dickson_constru... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sedenion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sedenion [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_algebra https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_algebra
- pflats 7y agoThanks for writing this! I referenced it in a reply upthread for why I like the equation. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22204995 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22204995
- QuesnayJr 7y agoYou lose the ability to divide after the octonions.
- pflats 7y agoI got busy, so I wanna say thanks to everyone who tagged in for me. So many great answers. I'll link a few that speak the most to my own feelings. Why do I like it? I am, as klodolph notes [1], a dyed-in-the-wool algebraist. It's where I find the most beauty and joy in mathematics. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22202606 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22202606 This invention/discovery is a fundamental development in abstract algebra, not a terminal one. Quaternions are just a jumping-off point, and I've always found the Caley-Dickenson construction that pauldraper explains[2] absolutely beautiful. [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22202513 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22202513 Why would I want it specifically as a tattoo? jfengel points out the special history of that specific equation[3]: it was (allegedly) carved into a bridge in Dublin when Hamilton stumbled onto it, but the carving is gone. Kinda fitting to give it new permanence. [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22202513 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22202513 So, putting it all together: it's a fundamental development in abstract algebra, which is my jam. It's could have been permanently inscribed in a bridge, but that's been lost to time, so giving it new permanency seems fitting. Also, it's practical. My first thought was actually the Cayley table for the Klein four-group[4], but that would be a lot harder to get tattooed in a nice visible way. How I went from there to Hamilton's quaternion equation is left as an exercise to the reader. (If you're new to Cayley tables, they're just fancy times tables. Replace "e" with 1.) [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klein_four-group#Presentations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klein_four-group#Presentations